Criminal Investigation Task Forces: Evidence and Legal Issues
This paper examines the strategic, legal, and evidentiary dimensions of conducting a criminal investigation through a multijurisdictional task force. Using a scenario involving multiple explosions across seven counties and two states, the paper analyzes when a task force is appropriate, its advantages and disadvantages, and how leadership and cooperation should be structured. It also addresses the legal requirements for forensic evidence collection, the chain of custody, the admissibility of testimonial evidence, and the appropriate sharing of investigative information with task force members, other agencies, victims' families, news reporters, and the general public.
- Investigative Task Force: Structure and Decision-Making: When to form a task force and who decides
- Advantages and Disadvantages of a Task Force: Resources versus coordination risks in task forces
- Task Force Cooperation: VPD's Role and Demands: VPD leadership demands and task force size
- Legal Issues in Multijurisdictional Investigations: Chain of evidence and legal risks across agencies
- Forensic Evidence Collection and Analysis: Collection procedures and chain of custody rules
- Testimonial Evidence and Admissibility: Rights, statements, and inadmissibility consequences
- Public Information and Information Sharing: What information to share and with whom
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper is well-organized around a practical scenario, applying general investigative principles to a specific multi-agency, multi-jurisdictional case involving explosions across two states and seven counties.
- Each section addresses a distinct question, making the argument easy to follow and ensuring that all relevant aspects of task force investigation — legal, forensic, and procedural — are systematically covered.
- The paper consistently balances competing concerns, such as the benefits of pooled resources against the risks of evidence mishandling or leadership conflicts, demonstrating analytical nuance.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates applied reasoning: it takes abstract principles from criminology and criminal investigation literature and applies them directly to a hypothetical but realistic scenario. Rather than simply defining concepts, the author consistently asks "what does this mean in practice for VPD?" — connecting theory to operational decision-making at each stage of the investigation.
Structure breakdown
The paper is organized into five major parts — Task Force, Legal Issues, Forensic Evidence, Testimonial Evidence, and Public Information — each subdivided into numbered questions. This Q&A format mirrors a formal investigative brief. The introduction establishes the scenario, and each subsequent section builds logically on the one before, concluding with public-facing information management protocols.
Investigative Task Force: Structure and Decision-Making
This investigation should be carried out by VPD personnel as the lead agency and head of a multijurisdictional task force. There are several reasons for this. First, VPD was the first agency to begin investigation of the crimes because the first explosion and damage occurred within its jurisdiction. Second, a task force is needed because there are multiple locations for the explosions, deaths, and injuries. With seven counties and two different states involved, it is very important that a task force be established to work together on a cohesive plan to convict the individuals responsible for the criminal acts. When task forces work together, they can provide proper coverage of a criminal act over a larger area (Baden & Roach, 2001).
When a crime scene encompasses more than one jurisdiction, or when there are a number of criminal acts that are tied together but have occurred in multiple jurisdictions, an investigative task force should be considered (Nickell & Fischer, 1999). While these task forces are not always needed, their value cannot be ignored and should be carefully weighed before any final decision is made. The larger and more dangerous the crimes, and the larger the area in which they were committed, also plays a role in determining whether a task force is the right choice (O'Hara & O'Hara, 2003).
The decision to create a task force should belong to the chief or other officer in charge of the lead agency (Nickell & Fischer, 1999). In this case, that would be the VPD. If too many people are involved in that decision, the process can become unnecessarily complicated (Nickell & Fischer, 1999). There are times, however, when government agencies assert authority and create a task force because of the nature and scope of the crime (O'Hara & O'Hara, 2003). When that occurs, there are usually terroristic or international implications.
Advantages and Disadvantages of a Task Force
Investigative task forces have both advantages and disadvantages. The main advantage is the extra manpower they provide (Barak, 1998; Burgess, Roberts, & Regehr, 2009). They can also enable a pooling of resources — including not just personnel, but also vehicles, K-9 units, laboratories, forensic investigators, and others who can provide insight into particular crime scenes or crime sprees (Baden & Roach, 2001).
However, there are also disadvantages. The classic problem is having too many leaders and not enough personnel to carry out the actual work. In other words, too many people trying to direct the investigation can get in each other's way, while there are too few people doing the hands-on work (Deflem, 2006). There is also the risk of losing evidence and information between agencies, or working with agencies and officers who are not fully committed to sharing all of the evidence gathered during the investigation (Deflem, 2006). When that occurs, an otherwise well-conducted investigation can fail, and criminals can go free (Baden & Roach, 2001). These problems will often not be identified until they have already caused harm (Deflem, 2006). It is important to carefully weigh the pros and cons before suggesting or initiating a task force.
References
Baden, M., MD., & Roach, M. (2001). Dead reckoning: The new science of catching killers. NY: Simon & Schuster.
Barak, G. (Ed.). (1998). Integrative criminology (International Library of Criminology, Criminal Justice & Penology). Aldershot: Ashgate/Dartmouth.
Burgess, A. W., Roberts, A. R., & Regehr, C. (2009). Victimology: Theories and applications. NY: Jones & Bartlett Learning.
Deflem, M. (Ed.). (2006). Sociological theory and criminological research: Views from Europe and the United States. NY: Elsevier.
Nickell, J., & Fischer, J. F. (1999). Crime science: Methods of forensic detection. KY: University Press of Kentucky.
O'Hara, C. E., & O'Hara, G. L. (2003). Fundamentals of criminal investigation (7th ed.). NY: Charles C. Thomas Publishers.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.