This paper provides a comprehensive industry analysis of discount department stores, examining the structural and competitive forces that shape this retail segment. It begins by identifying pricing as the industry's dominant feature, then evaluates macro-environmental factors through a PESTLE lens, concluding that economic and socio-cultural forces are the most consequential. The paper proceeds to apply Porter's Five Forces framework — covering substitute products, competitive rivalry, new entrants, buyer power, and supplier power — to assess the industry's competitive landscape. The analysis concludes that price and selection are the critical success factors, and that the discount department store industry holds a strong growth outlook driven by sustained consumer frugality and economic pressures.
The paper demonstrates applied framework analysis — the disciplined use of established business models (PESTLE and Porter's Five Forces) to systematically evaluate a real industry. Rather than applying each factor mechanically, the author ranks their relative significance, which elevates the analysis from descriptive to evaluative. This technique is central to undergraduate business and strategy coursework.
The paper opens with a brief definition of the industry before moving through three analytical stages: (1) identifying the dominant industry feature (pricing), (2) assessing macro-environmental factors via PESTLE, and (3) applying Porter's Five Forces in detail. A concluding section synthesizes the findings, identifies key success factors, and offers an industry attractiveness rating. This mirrors a standard strategic analysis format used in business education.
Discount department stores are those that offer lower prices for products that may be lower quality, consist of extra inventory from other stores, or are simply items that consumers purchase frequently and prefer to buy inexpensively. These department stores often base their appeal on price rather than on selection, quality, shopping experience, or other factors. Understanding the forces that shape this industry requires examining both the macro-environment and the competitive landscape in which these stores operate.
The dominant feature of the discount department store industry is its pricing structure — the area in which most discount stores outperform larger retailers when it comes to competition (Rugman & Collinson, 2009). The discount retail market is growing rapidly, because a tight economy means that many more people must shop for discounts and purchase only what they need. As a result, the market share of these kinds of retail stores has grown tremendously in recent years.
At the same time, the scope of rivalry has also grown. Retailers not classified as discount department stores have recognized the need to do something to keep customers, so they have cut prices on certain items to more closely match what is offered at discount stores. By doing this, they aim to draw customers in for low-cost items while encouraging them to purchase additional merchandise. This strategy has worked relatively well, but many consumers are still choosing discount stores and shopping more carefully than they did in the past, when economic conditions were more favorable. The discount department store sector is currently in a significant growth cycle due to the economy (Liston, 1986), and even when conditions improve, growth may continue as consumers have become aware of the value these stores offer.
In the macro-environment, many issues can affect discount department stores. These include political, economic, socio-cultural, technological, legal, and environmental factors, though not all of them are highly applicable to stores of this type. Politically, there is little that a discount department store must worry about, since these stores are not engaged in activities that raise significant political concerns for either side of the political spectrum. The one exception might relate to the origin of products: if tariffs or trade difficulties arise, sourcing products from a particular country and stocking shelves with them could become a legitimate concern (Chant, 1997; Hunter & Green, 1995; Lea, 1988; Lee, 1987). This would, however, be an unusual scenario.
Economic forces are of far greater interest to discount department stores, because these forces are the primary drivers of consumer behavior at lower-cost retailers (Nickols, 2000; Rugman & Collinson, 2009). While discount department stores attract shoppers in any economic climate, they are most likely to be used by a larger number of people when the economy is struggling. Because of this, economic forces acting on the store are more significant than any other external factor. Of course, the store must also consider the other side of the economic equation: how much it is paying for merchandise. If the store is required to pay too much for merchandise, labor, or any other input, it may not be able to meet its overhead — and that will be a problem regardless of customer traffic.
Socio-cultural forces are often intertwined with economic forces, especially for a discount department store. The connection exists because these kinds of stores are typically utilized by people who either (a) do not have much money, or (b) are highly frugal (Lockwood, Loomis, & DeLacy, 1993). While these two groups sometimes overlap, it is uncommon to see wealthy or upper-middle-class consumers shopping at discount department stores. Lower- and middle-income consumers are therefore the primary customer base. When the economy deteriorates, more people fall into these income categories, which means more potential customers — but it also means that fewer of those customers may be able to purchase as much as they otherwise would. These two dynamics can balance out for a discount department store during difficult economic times.
Technology is not a significant differentiating issue for discount department stores. These stores generally employ the same basic technology as higher-priced retailers, even if their systems are somewhat older — a situation neither surprising nor problematic for employees or customers. Similarly, legal issues are not unique to discount department stores. These stores face the same kinds of legal exposure as other department stores, including defective product lawsuits, premises liability claims such as slip-and-fall injuries, and workers' compensation claims from employees injured on the job.
With respect to environmental factors, discount department stores face no greater burden than any other type of retail operation. As long as the store disposes of waste correctly and addresses spills or other environmental concerns in accordance with applicable regulations, little else is required. Overall, the only serious concerns in the PESTLE framework for discount department stores are economic and socio-cultural factors, as both of those forces drive the core business model of these stores far more than any other consideration.
You’re 33% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.