Ehrlich and Dillard: Nature, Solitude, and Awakening
This essay compares two celebrated works of American nature writing: Gretel Ehrlich's "The Solace of Open Spaces" and Annie Dillard's "Total Eclipse." The paper examines how both authors cultivate a deeply personal, psychological relationship with the natural world — Ehrlich through her experience of Wyoming's vast, austere landscape, and Dillard through witnessing a total solar eclipse in the Yakima valley. Drawing on specific passages from each text, the essay traces shared themes of solitude, awe, human smallness, the presence of animals, and the idea of "waking up" to one's surroundings. The paper argues that both writers find healing and meaning through their immersion in nature.
- Introduction: Personal Connections to Nature: Both authors share psychological bonds with nature
- Solitude and the Vastness of Natural Spaces: Wyoming and the Yakima valley evoke profound solitude
- Awe, Wonder, and the Experience of Eclipse: Eclipse and Wyoming inspire awakening in both writers
- Animals as Equal Inhabitants of Shared Space: Animals share space equally with human observers
- Nature as Healing and the Search for Meaning: Both writers find healing and meaning through nature
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The essay grounds every comparative claim in direct textual evidence, pairing quotes from both authors to demonstrate genuine parallels rather than superficial similarities.
- It identifies a unifying conceptual thread — the idea of "waking up" — and traces it through both texts, giving the comparison analytical depth beyond mere description.
- The tone remains interpretive without overreaching; the writer is careful to note what the texts suggest rather than imposing claims the authors do not support.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates parallel textual analysis: rather than treating each author separately, it weaves the two works together thematically, showing how a quote from Dillard illuminates Ehrlich's experience and vice versa. This method of sustained cross-textual comparison is a core skill in literary essay writing at the undergraduate level.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens by introducing the shared psychological orientation of both writers toward nature, then progresses through specific shared themes: vast solitude, awe at natural phenomena, the role of animals, and finally a philosophical synthesis around the concept of awakening. A brief conclusion identifies the key distinction between the two authors while affirming what they hold in common. The Works Cited follows MLA format.
Introduction: Personal Connections to Nature
In Gretel Ehrlich's "The Solace of Open Spaces" and Annie Dillard's "Total Eclipse," we encounter two writers who share a deeply personal — perhaps even psychological — connection to the nature that surrounds them. Ehrlich discusses her beloved Wyoming and has given her essay an apt title, describing the experience of driving for miles without seeing another person. She writes: "The solitude in which westerners live makes them quiet" (Ehrlich 6). This observation seems natural when one considers that in a place like Wyoming, a person will encounter far more animals than people. Gretel Ehrlich grounds her writing in the rhythms and textures of daily life in that landscape.
Dillard begins her essay by describing the five-hour drive with her husband Gary through snowy mountains that gradually melt into green valleys to watch a total eclipse. She writes, "I watched the landscape innocently, like a fool, like a diver in the rapture of the deep who plays on the bottom while his air runs out" (Dillard 3) — a sentence that evokes both solitude and silence. In these two opening passages, the reader feels the power of the places each author witnesses, and how each allows nature to wash over her. Both Ehrlich and Dillard sit and bear witness to the space around them — mesmerized and awestruck — neither fighting what they see nor resisting how they feel.
Works Cited
Dillard, Annie. The Annie Dillard Reader. Harper Perennial, 1995. Print.
Ehrlich, Gretel. The Solace of Open Spaces. Penguin (Non-Classics), 1986. Print.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.