This paper examines the role of employee motivation and incentive programs in improving workplace performance and productivity. Drawing on examples from Ben & Jerry's Joy Gang, an optometric practice, and a veterinary clinic, the paper evaluates both financial and non-financial strategies for motivating workers. It discusses the limitations of traditional pay-for-performance models and highlights structured, team-based incentive approaches as more effective long-term solutions. The paper also addresses how tailored reward programs that account for individual and cultural differences can resolve common performance problems and support broader organizational goals.
Extensive research strongly supports the conclusion that employee motivational programs can significantly increase both the quality and quantity of performance. Motivation can improve a number of different performance problems, including those involving employees who are unwilling to accept change, distracted and unable to remain focused on their work, not working at their level of potential, or making mistakes without taking responsibility. Motivational programs can also enhance the abilities of interested and engaged workers, further increasing productivity and quality.
There are many suggested ways to motivate employees, and the challenge is to find the approach that will best support the variety of individual and cultural beliefs that shape what makes employees effective in their work. There are also universal strategies that appear to motivate all individuals, regardless of their different value systems.
Ben & Jerry's ice cream company has long been recognized as one of the best organizations for employment due to its strong employee support. Ben and Jerry recognized an important relationship between compensation, employee self-concept, and the corporate mission (Schrag, 2009). Individuals whom a company values most are compensated most, and a person can determine their relative importance to the organizational mission by comparing their salary to those in higher pay grades. Ben and Jerry established that the highest-paid person could earn no more than seven times the salary of the lowest-paid person.
In addition, the company offers a wide variety of financial and non-financial incentive programs, including the well-known Ben & Jerry's Joy Gang, which was founded in 1987 in response to increasing demands on employees. The first Joy Gang activity consisted of pizza and 15-minute massages for manufacturing employees working 12-hour marathon shifts. Jerry suggested that employees should make fun an official part of the company mission: "To infuse joy into everything we do."
The Joy Grants are cash grants of up to $500 to support ideas that bring more joy to a particular department. Joy Events are organized activities that typically include food, fun, and prizes. Joy Guerilla Tactics are secretive activities intended to surprise employees.
An increasing number of companies allow their employees to establish their own reward programs. Ben & Jerry's employee committee reviews co-workers' ideas for making the workplace a better environment and develops employee contests and social events. Inflexible incentive systems that do not recognize individual differences waste thousands of dollars by failing to work effectively. Knowing personnel well enough to provide them with an appropriate reward is essential. "An effective, structured reward program is planned in advance and operates according to established guidelines" (Gatlin, 1997).
In the 1980s and 1990s, financial incentive programs were frequently used to motivate employees. In fact, numerous companies continue to associate improved employee morale primarily with compensation. The belief that money is the primary motivator is common in corporate culture. In most cases, however, these programs may produce only a short-lived boost in productivity, and if underlying motivational problems exist, nothing is ultimately resolved. Organizations have therefore sought incentive programs — such as Ben & Jerry's — that overcome the disadvantages of purely financial approaches.
"Three-part incentive model for optometric staff"
"Base salary plus production bonuses in veterinary care"
Although traditional employee incentive programs are popular — ranging from sales commissions and other pay-by-performance jobs to more individual-specific programs — most of these programs are not fully effective. Ben & Jerry's, as well as other companies, have found ways of taking the best aspects of these incentive programs and incorporating additional factors that make them genuinely successful. The key lies in designing structured, team-oriented reward systems that recognize individual contributions while aligning staff efforts with broader organizational goals.
You’re 50% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.