This paper explores the theory and practice of employee performance appraisals within the hospitality and gaming industry, using a California resort and casino as a case study. It begins by reviewing the academic definition and purpose of performance appraisals, including their three core objectives and a four-stage cyclical model encompassing planning, execution, assessment, and review. The paper then details the organization's multilevel appraisal system, in which evaluations pass through the direct supervisor, general manager, human resource department, and payroll manager. Both the benefits and limitations of this complex system are analyzed, and the discussion is situated within broader debates about whether formal appraisals motivate or demoralize employees.
The paper demonstrates applied theory analysis: it establishes a theoretical framework (the four-stage cyclical appraisal model and its three core purposes) and then maps each element of that framework onto the observed practices of the case organization. This structure allows the reader to evaluate how closely real-world HR practice aligns with academic recommendations.
The paper is organized into five substantive sections following a logical progression. It opens with a broad discussion of modern human resource trends, then provides organizational context for the case study. A dedicated theory section defines performance appraisals and outlines competing academic perspectives. The core analytical section traces the appraisal process through all four organizational levels — supervisor, general manager, HR department, and payroll manager — before concluding with a synthesis that revisits the main arguments and acknowledges unresolved tensions in the literature.
It is now beyond any doubt that the world is changing at a rapid pace and that people must develop alongside it. Within the business community, these modifications are numerous, including a greater focus on the full satisfaction of customers' needs and wants, an orientation toward offering services rather than products, the necessity to conduct business operations in an environmentally friendly manner, and an incremental emphasis placed on human resources.
Modern-day managers strive harder than ever to hire, integrate, and retain the best employees the workforce market produces. The contemporary employee is motivated, trained, and supported in his or her professional path. The human resource department is generally responsible for improving the nature of the relationship and interaction between firm and employee. The ultimate goal of the human resource department is to increase employees' on-the-job satisfaction, which in turn cultivates higher levels of loyalty to the organization as well as increased employee effort and performance.
In more recent times, a trend has emerged toward retaining and motivating existing staff rather than hiring new personnel. Worker motivation can be achieved through diverse means, such as offering greater financial resources (including both salaries and premiums or bonuses), creating flexible working schedules, and providing training and support for professional development.
Yet the treatment of employees, however fair and equitable, must be differentiated based on the efforts and results of each individual. In order to identify the commitment and outcomes of each employee and then present them with the appropriate incentive — or sanction, if necessary — organizational leaders implement various performance appraisal systems. One organization that subscribes to the practice of performance appraisals is the Chukchansi Gold Resort and Casino.
The Chukchansi Gold Resort and Casino was officially opened on August 22, 2003, after an investment of $150 million. It takes pride in the beautiful surrounding landscape, which it uses to promote the location and attract new clientele. The resort and casino has positioned itself in the market by building a strong brand centered on pleasurable leisure time. It promotes gaming, dining, and entertainment as its main offerings, while also emphasizing its flexibility and eagerness to adapt to customer needs and to host and personalize a wide variety of events.
Chukchansi attracts its customers by promising them a great experience at the latest and most popular slot machines, at an elegant restaurant, through luxurious lodging, or through participation in unique events. Among the amenities offered are 1,800 popular slot machines, 48 gaming tables, a poker room with 12 tables, 12 individually diverse and themed bars, 400 luxurious hotel rooms, and 800 parking spaces (the Chukchansi Gold Resort and Casino Website, 2009).
The resort and casino positions its products and services by promoting their ability to free customers from the stresses of daily life and transport them into a world of relaxation and luxury. Whatever the reason that brings a customer to Chukchansi, and regardless of the duration of their stay, the resort and casino promises that visitors will experience "the most enjoyable and memorable getaway" (the Chukchansi Gold Resort and Casino Website).
While the primary target audience consists of individuals looking to gamble and attend concerts and other events hosted by Chukchansi — with admission restricted to those over the age of 21 — the company also strives to attract tourists who visit the area to enjoy its natural attractions. The resort takes pride in being located just minutes away from some of California's most beautiful destinations, including Yosemite National Park, Bass Lake, the Golden Chain Highway, the Yosemite Mountain Sugar Pine Railroad, Thornberry Museum, and the California State Mining and Mineral Museum. These are promoted by the hotel as "local attractions that offer the best in recreation, sight-seeing and adventure" (the Chukchansi Gold Resort and Casino Website).
Another means of appealing to customers is the casino and hotel's connection to the Chukchansi Indian tribe. The tribe is one of the most reputable in the United States, having historically spread across the Sierra Nevada Mountains, the Fresno River, Finegold Creek, Coarsegold Creek, and the San Joaquin River. Like many other Native American tribes, the Chukchansi are recognized for their efforts in protecting the natural environment and for living in a way that carefully balances the needs of people with the needs of nature.
Linking the casino to the beliefs of the tribe's forefathers gives it a sense of consistency, history, and tradition that appeals both to Native Americans and to visitors of other backgrounds seeking a cultural experience or a connection to history. The Chukchansi Gold Resort and Casino takes great pride in its heritage and promises to honor the beliefs of its elders and to protect the environment. It also argues that its resources and facilities are used to further balance the relationship between humanity and nature: "We are proud to offer the beauty and enjoyment of our resort and casino. They allow us to sustain the health and well being of our elders, nature and educate our children. […] Our inherited role as nature's caretakers is apparent in the environmental initiatives that help preserve our sacred land" (the Chukchansi Gold Resort and Casino Website).
While generating profit remains the primary goal of the Chukchansi Gold Resort and Casino, the company strives to achieve this objective through the satisfaction of as many stakeholder groups as possible. They serve the general public by protecting the environment and improving quality of life through cleaner air and reduced pollution. They support customers by presenting them with numerous relaxation opportunities, ranging from spa services to dining, gaming, and concerts. They also support the development of the communities in which they operate. The resort and casino creates jobs in California, thereby reducing unemployment. It pays its taxes on time, thus contributing to local budgets and the further development of the Californian community. Finally, it offers various sponsorship arrangements that improve quality of life and create new opportunities within the community.
In a concise formulation, Dick Grote and Richard C. Grote (2002) define performance appraisal as a "formal management system that provides for the evaluation of the quality of an individual's performance in an organization." They argue that the evaluation of an employee is generally conducted by that employee's direct supervisor, who normally completes a pre-designed standard form and then discusses its results with the employee.
A typical appraisal is performed with three specific objectives. First, the performance appraisal provides the logical and objective basis for salary increases, promotions, bonuses, demotions, or termination of employment. Second, it allows the supervisor to inform the employee of how his or her performance is perceived by the company and to offer input on what changes are needed in the employee's approach to professional responsibilities. Third — a more recent objective — the performance appraisal allows the supervisor to mentor the employee's professional development (Grote, 1996).
While most organizations conduct employee evaluations once a year, academics argue that the practice should be ongoing and integrated into the overall business model. In such a model, a cyclic four-stage process would occur. The first stage, performance planning, involves a meeting between the employee and supervisor at the beginning of the year, during which both parties discuss and set goals for the coming year. Objectives are contributed by both the supervisor and the employee.
The second phase, performance execution, occurs gradually throughout the year. The employee works toward the initially established goals while the supervisor provides valuable feedback and helps resolve any difficulties that arise. By mid-year, another meeting is held in which the two parties review progress made toward the pre-established objectives.
The third stage, performance assessment, occurs near the end of the year, when the supervisor gathers necessary information and completes organizational documents for the employee's appraisal. The supervisor analyzes the employee's development, forms an opinion, and forwards the report to his or her own supervisor. They then discuss salary increases, bonuses, or any other measures to be taken. The initial recommendation comes from the employee's direct supervisor and is discussed with the general director and payroll manager.
At the fourth stage, performance review, the employee and direct supervisor meet again to discuss the outcome of the appraisal process. The employee is informed of the managerial decision regarding future compensation, and a date is set for a new meeting that will establish goals for the following year — hence the cyclic nature of the appraisal system (Grote and Grote).
Beyond meeting these three core objectives, performance appraisals also offer the organization several additional benefits. They create a context in which employees are introduced to their own core competencies and limitations, enabling them to better direct their professional development. Employees take an active role in their own evaluation and gain a clearer understanding of their competencies as viewed through an organizational lens. Performance appraisals also elevate the employee-manager relationship to a more mature level characterized by greater equality, which enhances the employee's sense of fair treatment and increases motivation and organizational commitment. Throughout the evaluation process, the supervisor can identify new training needs and address them, with the ultimate outcome of improved organizational results. Importantly, all these developments regarding work quality are discussed without the traditional emphasis on financial aspects alone (Falcone and Sachs, 2007).
Despite these benefits, some scholars argue that performance appraisal systems are in fact harmful to proper organizational development. Tom Coens, Mary Jenkins, and Peter Block (2002) contend that appraisals fail to achieve the objectives for which they are intended. In their view, employee evaluation mechanisms reduce morale and commitment and obstruct the proper flow of information. In their own words, appraisal "impedes the reception of feedback, and there is no solid evidence that it motivates people or leads to meaningful improvement. Due to its inherent design flaws, appraisal produces distorted and unreliable data about the contribution of employees. Consequently, the resulting documentation is not useful for staffing decisions and often does not hold up in court. Too often, appraisal destroys human spirit and, in the span of a 30-minute meeting, can transform a vibrant, highly committed employee into a demoralized, indifferent wallflower who reads the want ads on the weekend."
The Chukchansi Gold Resort and Casino prides itself on being a premier destination for tourists, those seeking relaxation, and those seeking entertainment. In keeping with this identity, the organization expects to hire premier employees. The salaries and incentives offered to staff are competitive within the industry, and the expectations placed on employees are among the highest in the field.
Prospective candidates are attracted by the opportunity to be part of a dynamic community in which delivering entertainment to customers has reached a high level of excellence. Prospective employees are introduced to the hotel and casino in a manner that highlights its appeal and stimulates their desire to join the Chukchansi team. Unlike other resorts and casinos that recruit through mass media, employment agencies, or word of mouth, Chukchansi emphasizes online recruiting through its own website. This approach is generally more selective than others, as it reduces the overall pool of applicants. Its advantage, however, is that it also reduces the administrative burden associated with selection and recruitment. The requirement to apply online ensures that only candidates with at least basic IT skills will apply.
The demands and expectations placed on employees are high even before hiring, and they continue throughout the duration of employment. While working conditions cannot be described as unfair, the expectations are undeniably elevated and staff members must complete their tasks at a high level of quality and commitment. Still, the company recognizes and rewards the efforts of its personnel: "Chukchansi Gold Resort & Casino offers great salaries, great benefits, great co-workers and a world-class place to work" (the Chukchansi Gold Resort and Casino Website).
You’re 52% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.