Ethics and Military Justice in A Few Good Men (1992)
This paper examines the ethical dimensions of the 1992 film A Few Good Men, directed by Rob Reiner, focusing on how military justice differs from civilian legal standards. Using the film as a case study, the paper explores the responsibilities of defense attorneys, prosecutors, and judges in a court martial setting, and how institutional loyalty, career pressures, and rank-based bias affect adherence to ethical norms. Drawing on the ABA Code as cited in Thomson's Ethics in Crime and Justice, the paper argues that the military legal system creates structural pressures that compromise fair representation, particularly for career officers serving as defense counsel.
- Introduction: Military Justice and Ethical Standards: Military vs. civilian legal ethics overview
- The Crime and Its Origins: Santiago's death and the Code Red order
- Prosecutorial Duty and the Bias of Military Courts: Systemic bias favoring officers over defendants
- Defense Attorneys and Career Pressure: Career risk chilling effective defense counsel
- Key Players: Kaffee, Galloway, and Ross: Each attorney's role and ethical stance
- Colonel Jessup and the Abuse of Authority: Jessup's contempt for legal accountability
- Verdict, Ethics, and Conclusion: Verdict fairness and unresolved ethical tensions
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It grounds abstract ethical principles — prosecutorial duty, judicial objectivity, defense representation — in specific scenes and characters from the film, making the analysis concrete and traceable.
- It draws a sustained comparison between civilian and military legal ethics, using that contrast as the paper's organizing logic rather than simply summarizing the film's plot.
- It treats secondary characters (Galloway, Ross) with the same analytical rigor as the principals, showing nuanced understanding of how institutional roles shape individual behavior.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper uses a primary text (the film) as an extended case study through which to apply an external ethical framework (the ABA Code via Thomson, 2005). Rather than evaluating the film as a cultural artifact, it treats the narrative as a vehicle for examining real legal ethics concepts — an effective technique for applied ethics writing that demonstrates how theoretical standards play out in practice.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by establishing the military justice context and the central crime, then moves outward to examine the ethical obligations of each courtroom actor in turn: the system as a whole, the defense team, the prosecution, and finally the defendant-turned-witness Jessup. It concludes by evaluating the verdict against ethical standards. This character-by-character progression allows each section to build on the systemic critique established in the opening.
Introduction: Military Justice and Ethical Standards
The film A Few Good Men (Rob Reiner, 1992) is set in the world of military justice, which is not as familiar to most people as the civilian court system. The ethical issues are generally the same, though the emphasis in a military court falls more heavily on adherence to military culture and especially on the greater expectation of conformity and loyalty. Still, the ethical concerns for lawyers and judges should be much the same as in a civilian courtroom, encompassing fairness, the rules of evidence, and adherence to justice over expediency.
The Crime and Its Origins
The crime in the film occurs outside the United States when Private Willie Santiago, a marine stationed at Guantanamo, Cuba, offers to inform on a fellow marine who had fired a shot over the dividing line into Cuba proper. That marine, Corporal Dawson, and another, Private Downey, force a rag down Santiago's throat and accidentally choke him to death. Both men are then charged with murder. Both Santiago and the two marines could be considered to have acted unethically: Santiago has no sense of civic duty and only wants to secure a transfer, while the other two respond with an action that is a clear threat to Santiago's life and well-being.
As the story unfolds, it becomes clear that the marines recognized this possibility before it happened, and that Colonel Jessup, the base commander, claims to have ordered protection for Santiago and to have arranged his immediate transfer to the United States. Jessup produces the transfer order, though Santiago was killed the night before it could be put into effect. In truth, however, this crime was not committed by angry marines acting on their own initiative. It was instead carried out at the instigation of Jessup and his subordinates. He ordered them to run what is called a "Code Red" on Santiago — a form of hazing intended to make him recant. The two marines carry out the assignment, which then goes fatally wrong. They are thus being tried not only for committing the act but for supposedly devising it themselves, which they did not.
Reference
Thomson (2005). Ethics in Crime and Justice. No further publication data provided.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.