Evaluating a Loan Application: Key Financial Criteria
This paper examines the criteria a banker should consider before approving a small business loan. Using a hypothetical borrower named Jason as a case study, the paper argues that unaudited financial ratios alone are insufficient for making a sound lending decision. The author identifies the need for audited financial statements, additional ratios such as the cash ratio, accounts receivable turnover, and inventory turnover, as well as qualitative factors including the borrower's character, management capability, and collateral. The paper concludes that no lending decision should be made under conditions of data deficiency, and that a thorough, documented assessment is the only responsible approach.
- Introduction: What a Banker Needs Before Lending: Audited statements required for reliable lending decisions
- Assessing the Numbers Jason Provided: Surface-level ratios appear positive but are insufficient
- Beyond the Basics: Capacity and Collateral: Loan size fit and asset security must be evaluated
- Additional Ratios That Reveal True Financial Health: Cash, receivables, and inventory ratios add critical depth
- Character, Track Record, and Loan Term Alignment: Management integrity and business history matter greatly
- Conclusion: Why the Current Information Is Not Enough: No approval possible without complete, verified financial data
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Uses a concrete, relatable scenario (lending to "Jason") to ground abstract financial concepts in a practical decision-making context.
- Clearly distinguishes between what the provided numbers show and what they cannot show, demonstrating analytical rather than surface-level reasoning.
- Incorporates the Five Cs of lending framework organically, applying it to the case without simply listing definitions.
- The conclusion takes a firm, well-reasoned stance — refusing to recommend approval — which gives the paper a strong, credible voice.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates applied financial analysis: it starts from available data, identifies its limitations, and systematically builds the case for what additional information is required. This "gap analysis" approach — moving from what is known to what is missing — is a hallmark of sound credit evaluation writing at the undergraduate level.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by establishing the requirement for audited statements, then evaluates the ratios provided at face value before pivoting to their limitations. It expands outward through three layers — additional ratios, structural factors (capacity and collateral), and qualitative factors (character and track record) — before delivering a clear, justified refusal to lend. The progression from data to judgment is logical and well-paced.
Introduction: What a Banker Needs Before Lending
There are several things a banker must know before lending money to any applicant. Chief among these is a set of audited financial statements covering at least the past three years. The auditing process ensures the reliability and truthfulness of financial statements — unaudited figures are simply not worth the paper they are printed on. The auditing process will uncover irregularities, and having that assurance is essential before committing capital. Furthermore, the auditor's report provides a professional stamp of approval. Knowing that a qualified auditor has signed off on the statements is a critical part of ensuring that a lending decision is grounded in sound, verified information about the financial condition of the company (Crawford, 2018).
Assessing the Numbers Jason Provided
On the surface, the information Jason provided seems reasonable. A lending decision would not be made on these numbers alone, but in principle a current ratio of 3.1 suggests a solvent company. The fact that asset turnover is improving is also a positive sign in terms of the cash conversion cycle. If net income and earnings per share (EPS) are trending upward, that too is encouraging — though as a creditor, free cash flow and debt subordination are of greater concern. Still, having these figures moving in the right direction is a good sign.
However, the raw numbers only tell part of the story. It is not actually relevant that net income is up if Jason's financials are based on a lemonade stand and he is borrowing to buy diamond-mining equipment. The critical question is whether the company can specifically handle borrowing the dollar figure it is requesting — and that is not something these particular numbers can answer on their own.
References
Crawford, C. (2018). The importance of audited financial statements of a business firm. Your Business. Retrieved March 15, 2017, from https://yourbusiness.azcentral.com/importance-audited-financial-statements-business-firm-17757.html
Hayes, A. (2018). Ratio analysis: Using financial ratios. Investopedia. Retrieved March 15, 2017, from https://www.investopedia.com/university/ratio-analysis/using-ratios.asp
Kiisel, T. (2013). The five Cs of small business lending. Forbes. Retrieved March 15, 2018, from https://www.forbes.com/sites/tykiisel/2013/11/05/the-five-cs-of-small-business-lending/#719ed0c9555a
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.