Family Presence During Resuscitation: Benefits and Challenges
This paper examines the complex issue of family presence during cardiopulmonary resuscitation, weighing the potential benefits against the practical and ethical challenges involved. It reviews historical survey data and clinical research to argue that family members should generally be offered the option of being present during resuscitation efforts, provided that appropriate support structures—including trained facilitators, institutional guidelines, and staff education—are in place. The paper also addresses healthcare providers' concerns about distraction, increased responsibility, and disruption, while highlighting evidence that informed staff often change their attitudes positively once exposed to research demonstrating the benefits of family presence programs.
- Introduction: The Case for and Against Family Presence: Overview of competing arguments around family attendance
- Support Structures and Institutional Guidelines: Role of facilitators, policies, and hospital resources
- Benefits of Family Presence: Evidence and Outcomes: Historical survey data and closure for bereaved families
- Staff Attitudes and Behavioral Responses: Healthcare providers' concerns and changing perceptions
- Conclusion: Balancing Rights and Responsibilities: Conditional recommendation for family presence programs
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Presents a genuinely balanced argument, acknowledging legitimate concerns from both family members and healthcare providers without dismissing either side.
- Uses specific historical evidence—the 1985 survey and the Robinson et al. clinical study—to ground abstract policy arguments in real-world data.
- Connects individual interactions (patient, family, staff) to broader institutional responsibility, showing how policy gaps lead to inconsistent practice.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of counterargument integration: rather than simply advocating for family presence, it raises objections (distraction, emotional interference, confidentiality concerns) and systematically addresses each one, strengthening its overall thesis. This dialectical structure lends credibility to the final recommendation.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by acknowledging the risks and constraints of family presence, then pivots to historical and clinical evidence supporting the practice. It examines the "trilateral" relationship among patient, family, and staff before concluding that, where family behavior remains composed and support systems are available, presence during resuscitation should be a standard option offered to families. Citations from Doyle et al. (1987) and Mian et al. (2007) anchor the argument at key points.
Introduction: The Case for and Against Family Presence
When considering the presence of family members in the resuscitation room, various factors must be taken into account. If the patient does not respond to resuscitation measures, it is likely that the next of kin will be affected by the experience, potentially leading to traumatic repercussions. Moreover, by allowing family members to be present, staff are expected to ensure a minimum level of support. However, given that resuscitation requires the concentration of all available forces and efforts on the patient, there may be no staff available to support the family—particularly when no trained facilitators have been delegated that responsibility. Some hospitals may also lack the resources to address this issue adequately.
This is why family presence during resuscitation is not always recommended: it can affect relatives negatively. On the other hand, it has long been acknowledged that family presence in the resuscitation room carries real benefits. Being present should be an option—families ought to be given the right to choose whether or not they wish to attend cardiopulmonary resuscitation. However, hospitals should reserve the right to ask relatives to leave in cases where emotional interference could disrupt or jeopardize the resuscitation process.
References
Doyle, C. J., Post, H., Burney, R. E., Maino, J., Keefe, M., & Rhee, K. J. (1987). Family participation during resuscitation: An option. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 16(6), 673–675.
Mian, P., Warchal, S., Whitney, S., Fitzmaurice, J., & Tancredi, D. (2007). Impact of a multifaceted intervention on nurses' and physicians' attitudes and behaviors toward family presence during resuscitation. Critical Care Nurse, 27(1), 52–61.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.