This paper analyzes the key challenges facing Germany's automobile industry, drawing on a 2007 Economist article. It examines the European Commission's proposed CO2 emission standards, the high production costs associated with German premium vehicles, and the evolving tastes of consumers who increasingly favor environmentally friendly and budget-conscious alternatives. The paper discusses how major German manufacturers — including Volkswagen, BMW, Mercedes, Porsche, Audi, and DaimlerChrysler — are responding to these pressures through joint hydrogen research, clean-diesel technology, and potential outsourcing to Eastern Europe, while questioning whether their traditional premium-car orientation can survive shifting global demand.
The first thing that comes to mind when thinking about luxury automobiles is Mercedes, which immediately points us toward Germany's car industry. Germany is one of the world's most important automobile producers, its strength rooted in a long tradition of quality manufacturing. However, the German car industry's future does not appear as bright as its present, according to The Economist's article "Germany's Car Industry: The Big-Car Problem. Germany Produces Some of the Fastest and Most Luxurious Cars in the World, but Is That Yesterday's Game?" The article focuses on the changes that will influence the car industry worldwide in general, and Germany's car industry in particular. These changes relate to newly proposed CO2 standards, rising production costs, and shifting buyer tastes.
In February 2007, the European Commission proposed a new CO2 emission limit, raising the standard to 130 grams of CO2 per kilometer, to be reached by 2012. This regulation will likely change the face of Germany's car industry considerably, forcing German producers to develop a new outlook and invest more heavily in research and development. It will also create competitive problems, as only six German-made models comply with the new emission standards, while 34 models produced by competitors already meet the target. Moreover, most of the cars emitting more than 200g of CO2 per kilometer are German-made.
The situation has not pleased German producers, as expected. The impact will extend beyond the automobile market to the labor market as well, since the car industry is Germany's largest and most profitable sector, with one seventh of the country's manufacturing workforce employed within it. That said, the immediate effects are not anticipated in the near term, as the German stock market has so far been only minimally affected by these new conditions.
Despite these pressures, things will not deteriorate overnight for German automobile producers, since most have registered growing profits in recent years. Volkswagen's 2006 operating profits increased by 52% compared to the previous year. Mercedes, DaimlerChrysler's car division, is reviving after a difficult period. Meanwhile, rising petrol prices have done little to dampen sales at Porsche and BMW. This strong financial performance provides a buffer, but does not eliminate the structural challenges ahead.
Buyer tastes and their evolution are among the most important factors shaping the car market's future, as both demand and supply — and ultimately prices — are driven by consumer preferences. Those preferences appear to be shifting from luxury-oriented to environment-oriented. Buyers are increasingly interested in a vehicle's environmental characteristics rather than its appearance or performance prestige. This behavioral shift is most visible in the United States, where Chrysler's sales have been heavily affected. A similar trend is expected to emerge in European markets, including Germany's.
Buyers' choices are now also influenced by fiscal policy instruments designed to shift demand away from high-emission vehicles. In London, for example, the traffic-congestion charge zone has been extended, but environmentally friendly vehicles are exempt. Also in London, the cost of resident parking permits is to be determined by engine size. In Germany, a tax based on vehicles' emission levels is likely to be introduced. These policy measures will shape consumer behavior and drive significant changes in both demand and supply.
Furthermore, German producers' development priorities appear to be out of step with consumer needs. They continue to develop fast, powerful vehicles capable of exceeding 125 mph, yet speed limits in many areas are 55 mph. This disconnect will cause a shift in demand toward less powerful and less expensive cars. Drivers today face growing restrictions and are far more environmentally conscious than they were a decade ago, and the new direction of car demand reflects this awareness.
"High costs of electronics-heavy premium vehicles and market limits"
"Hydrogen, clean diesel, budget cars, and Eastern Europe outsourcing"
Demand for German vehicles as currently produced is likely to decrease, since the products offered by manufacturers are increasingly out of step with what customers want. Consumers are now oriented toward low-cost cars that use efficient, alternative fuels. German producers will surely be able to adapt to these challenges — it is only a matter of time before they do.
You’re 57% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.