Survival and Isolation in Gilman and London's Short Stories
This paper compares and contrasts Charlotte Perkins Gilman's "The Yellow Wallpaper" and Jack London's "To Build a Fire," examining how both stories explore human survival against powerful antagonistic forces. In Gilman's story, the enemy is the late-nineteenth-century medical establishment and a society that suppressed women's intellectual lives; in London's story, it is indifferent natural forces. The paper argues that both narratives warn against isolation and loneliness, showing how each protagonist ultimately fails to survive — one descending into madness, the other freezing to death — because of the destructive effects of being alone and unheard.
- Introduction: Two Stories of Survival: Both stories explore survival against antagonistic forces
- Gilman's Critique of the Medical Community: Gilman's personal experience motivates her critique
- Society, Isolation, and the Decay of the Mind: Society denied women intellectual life, worsening illness
- London's Man Against Nature and Aloneness: Man ignores advice and travels alone into danger
- Comparing the Two Protagonists: Smug man versus self-aware but unheard woman
- Conclusion: Antagonistic Forces and Human Failure: Both protagonists fail; both warn against isolation
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It grounds the comparative argument in authorial biography, using Gilman's own published confession to establish the autobiographical basis of "The Yellow Wallpaper," which strengthens the thematic reading.
- It maintains a clear parallel structure throughout, consistently pairing the two stories' themes — hostile nature vs. hostile society, and physical death vs. mental collapse — so the comparison remains focused.
- Direct quotations from primary and secondary sources are integrated naturally and used to support, rather than replace, the student's own analytical claims.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates the use of a thematic comparative framework: rather than summarizing each work separately, the student identifies shared thematic concerns (isolation, antagonistic forces, failed survival) and uses those as the organizing principle for analysis. This approach allows meaningful contrast — the man ignores good advice out of arrogance, while the woman is ignored despite her self-awareness — without losing sight of what the two works share.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a thesis establishing the shared survival theme and the key distinction between the two antagonists. It then dedicates two sections to Gilman, drawing on biographical context before moving to the story itself. A central section addresses London's story, focusing on the theme of aloneness. The comparative section brings both protagonists together for direct contrast, and the conclusion ties the dual themes — hostile forces and isolation — back to the shared outcome of failure.
Introduction: Two Stories of Survival
"The Yellow Wallpaper" by Charlotte Perkins Gilman and "To Build a Fire" by Jack London are two classic short stories dealing with humanity's struggle for survival against powerful antagonistic forces. In Gilman's story, this power is demonstrated in the form of the medical community and society, while in London's story it is nature itself. There is a meaningful difference between these forces: one story does not hold nature responsible for what happens to the protagonist, while the other finds no enemy other than nature itself.
Both stories also speak against isolation and loneliness. Isolation is the worst possible way of treating a person because it leads only to further destruction and decay of the human mind, body, and soul, as evidenced in "The Yellow Wallpaper." And it is loneliness — combined with a stubborn desire to survive without anyone's help — that ends the man's life in "To Build a Fire."
References
Labor, Earle. The Call of the Wild, White Fang, and Other Stories (Oxford World's Classics). Oxford University Press, USA (1998).
Patarca-Montero, Roberto. Medical Etiology, Assessment, and Treatment of Chronic Fatigue and Malaise: Clinical Differentiation and Intervention. Informa Healthcare (2004).
Charlotte Perkins Gilman, "Why I Wrote the Yellow Wallpaper" (1913). The Forerunner.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.