Racism and Ethnocentrism in Gish Jen's "Who's Irish?"
This paper offers a close reading of Gish Jen's short story "Who's Irish?" focusing on how the Chinese immigrant narrator's ethnocentric worldview exposes racism as a universal rather than uniquely American phenomenon. The analysis examines the narrator's strained relationships with her daughter, granddaughter, and Irish in-law, showing how each character's prejudices mirror the others'. The paper also considers how Jen's use of immigrant dialect and irony implicates the reader in the very stereotypes being critiqued, ultimately arguing that the story finds commonality among characters through their shared — if differently directed — prejudices.
- Introduction: Distance, Narration, and Strangeness: Narrative distance shapes reader sympathy for narrator
- Ethnocentrism Within the Family: Daughter challenges narrator's ethnic stereotyping
- Language, Stereotypes, and Reader Complicity: Immigrant dialect implicates reader in stereotypes
- Sophie's Mixed Identity and the Grandmother's Worldview: Narrator blames Irish heritage for granddaughter's behavior
- The Irish Grandmother's Revealing Reassurance: Irish grandmother's reassurance exposes her own prejudice
- Conclusion: Prejudice as a Universal Commonality: Shared prejudice bridges cultural difference in story
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Uses close textual quotation to ground every analytical claim, letting the story's language do argumentative work rather than relying on summary alone.
- Identifies an ironic structural dynamic — that prejudice functions as a bridge rather than a divider — and traces it consistently across multiple character relationships.
- Includes a self-reflexive move on reader complicity (the dialect discussion), adding analytical sophistication beyond basic character analysis.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper models irony analysis: it repeatedly locates moments where a character intends one effect (dispelling offense, correcting behavior) but achieves the opposite (revealing their own prejudice). By treating irony as a structural principle rather than an isolated device, the writer shows how theme and form reinforce each other throughout the story.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by framing the narrator's distance from the reader as the story's central interpretive lens, then moves through the family hierarchy — daughter, granddaughter, Irish grandmother — before closing with a thematic synthesis. Each body paragraph introduces a textual passage, reads it closely, and connects it back to the central claim that racism is universal. The conclusion widens the lens to comment on Jen's craft choices, distinguishing the story from more didactic treatments of the same theme.
Introduction: Distance, Narration, and Strangeness
Gish Jen's "Who's Irish?" presents a striking and unconventional take on racism and ethnocentrism. Although the story is American in setting — its characters live in America — it is told from the perspective of a Chinese immigrant, which places the reader at an immediate remove from the narrator. In a sense, this distance makes the narrator's views more acceptable and easier to engage with without immediate judgment. Similarly, the narrator's age and circumstances invite the reader's sympathies, even where her beliefs diverge sharply from what modern American society considers acceptable attitudes toward other cultures.
There are several moments in the story where this quality — an acceptance born of strangeness, or perhaps an acceptance that persists despite strangeness — is made explicit in the plot. Far from being merely a dynamic between narrator and reader, it also shapes the narrator's relationships with her daughter, granddaughter, son-in-law, and the broader world around her.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.