The Coquette by Hannah Webster Foster: Freedom and Women
This essay examines Hannah Webster Foster's epistolary novel The Coquette (1797), one of the best-selling American novels of the eighteenth century, analyzing how Foster uses the tragic story of Eliza Wharton to critique the gendered limits of Revolutionary-era liberty. Drawing on the real-life story of Elizabeth Whitman, Foster constructs a sympathetic portrait of a woman who refuses marriage as a form of constrained freedom, ultimately suffering for choices that harmed no one but herself. The essay traces the novel's themes of powerlessness, social constraint, and women's right to self-determination, arguing that Foster's work is as politically radical as the male-authored literature of her time, yet was marginalized precisely because it championed the inalienable rights of women.
- Introduction: A Forgotten Novel and Its Author: Foster's marginalization in the literary canon explained
- Historical Background and Real-Life Origins: Novel's basis in Elizabeth Whitman's real story
- The Novel's Popularity and Social Context: Best-seller status and real-life scandal behind it
- Eliza Wharton, Freedom, and the Constraints of Marriage: Eliza's rejection of marriage as constrained freedom
- Revolutionary Rhetoric and the Irony of Women's Liberty: Revolutionary ideals applied ironically to women's lives
- Conclusion: Foster's Radical Legacy: Foster's forgotten radicalism and its lasting significance
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper situates a largely overlooked novel within its historical and gender-political context, giving the reader both literary and social insight simultaneously.
- A well-chosen extended quotation from the novel (Letter LXVIII) is used to illustrate Eliza's voice and her tragic self-awareness, grounding the argument in primary-source evidence.
- The essay maintains a consistent sympathetic but analytical tone, neither sentimentalizing the protagonist nor condemning her, which mirrors Foster's own authorial stance.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates thematic close reading combined with historical contextualization. By connecting the novel's plot to the real story of Elizabeth Whitman and to the broader rhetoric of Revolutionary-era liberty, the author shows how a work of fiction can function simultaneously as social critique and allegorical narrative. The essay also models how to integrate a block quotation from a primary source and connect it directly back to a central interpretive claim.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens by addressing Foster's marginalization within the literary canon and contextualizing her gender. It then establishes the novel's biographical origins and its cultural reception, before moving into thematic analysis of freedom, marriage, and social constraint. The argument culminates in a reading of Revolutionary rhetoric as deeply ironic when applied to women, closing with a reflection on Foster's own constrained life as a minister's wife.
Introduction: A Forgotten Novel and Its Author
Hannah Webster Foster's The Coquette is scarcely remembered today — a point that Foster herself would probably have expected. Few women writing at the end of the eighteenth century could have anticipated that their works would achieve the fame or longevity of those produced by their male counterparts. Whether a work endures long enough to be included in the literary canon depends to some extent on its quality. But, as the case of this novel demonstrates, it is far more often the result of whether the person who wrote it was considered by the intellectual elite of the time to be the right kind of person to produce the kind of work that later generations would cherish.
As a woman, Foster was not the "right" kind of person to be a writer — at least not in her own time. Recent reevaluations of her work, as well as that of other women writing in the eighteenth-century United States, have allowed us to develop a greater appreciation of what these early American women writers produced. The Coquette strikes us today as both a compelling story — something of a potboiler, it is true, but potboilers are blessed with the great virtue of a gripping plot — and a fascinating exploration of the ways in which women could step outside the customary roles their sex was expected to maintain.
Both in her own life and in the lives of her characters, Foster created alternative stories for women to live.
Works Cited
Foster, Hannah. The Coquette. 1797.
Wenska, Walter, Jr. "The Coquette and the American Dream of Freedom." Early American Literature 11.3 (Winter 1977–78): 243–55.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.