Reductive Entrapment in Hawthorne's "The Birthmark"
This essay examines Nathaniel Hawthorne's short story "The Birthmark" through the lens of Adrienne Rich's feminist essay "When We Dead Awaken: Writing as Re-Vision." Drawing on Rich's argument that male poets entrap women in reductive, one-dimensional roles defined by beauty and youth, the essay analyzes how Aylmer's treatment of Georgiana mirrors the objectifying tendencies Rich identifies in poets such as Poe and Wordsworth. The paper explores Aylmer's manipulation, his latent misogyny, and Georgiana's gradual self-erasure, ultimately arguing that Hawthorne mourns rather than endorses these dynamics. A concluding comparison with Shakespeare's Sonnet 130 highlights a contrasting model of male authorship that resists objectification.
- Introduction: Artistic Captivity and Hawthorne's Vision: Rich's framework applied to Hawthorne's story
- Rich, Poe, and Wordsworth: Beauty as a Woman's Only Value: Male poets reduce women to beauty alone
- Georgiana's Awakening to Her Reductive Worth: Georgiana recognizes her value is purely aesthetic
- Aylmer as Tyrannizer: Domination, Flattery, and Control: Aylmer manipulates Georgiana through veiled tyranny
- Misogyny Concealed: Aylmer's God-Complex and Georgiana's Self-Erasure: Aylmer's hidden hatred and obsessive control
- Shakespeare as Counter-Model: Celebrating Flaws Without Entrapment: Shakespeare contrasts with objectifying male poets
- Conclusion: Hawthorne's Mourning of Female Subjugation: Hawthorne mourns rather than endorses entrapment
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper establishes a clear critical framework in its opening paragraph — Rich's concept of artistic captivity — and applies it consistently throughout the analysis of Hawthorne's story, giving the essay strong theoretical coherence.
- Direct quotations from both primary and secondary sources are well integrated, with the author always explaining how each quote supports the argument rather than letting the quotations stand alone.
- The concluding comparison with Shakespeare's Sonnet 130 is particularly effective: it provides a counterexample that sharpens the essay's central claim without introducing an unrelated argument.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The essay models how to apply a theoretical lens — in this case, Rich's feminist critique of male-authored poetry — to a prose literary text. The author maps Rich's observations (objectification, pedestaling, woman-hating) onto specific scenes and quotations from Hawthorne, demonstrating that literary theory and close reading can reinforce each other systematically.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens by introducing Rich's framework and positioning Hawthorne's story within it. It then works through the text scene by scene — Georgiana's initial reaction to Aylmer's criticism, her eventual capitulation, Aylmer's dream sequence, and his failure to affirm her life's value — each time cross-referencing Rich's claims. The essay closes by pivoting to Shakespeare as a positive model, creating a tidy comparative conclusion that reinforces the paper's argument without restating it mechanically.
Introduction: Artistic Captivity and Hawthorne's Vision
In her essay "When We Dead Awaken: Writing as Re-Vision," Adrienne Rich frankly alludes to the artistic captivity that male writers impose on women, arguing that women have always been trapped and explored by poets and will no doubt continue to suffer this experience. While some might argue that women are merely acting as the muse to the poet — that the male poet places women upon a pedestal — Rich demonstrates that this is far too simplistic a viewpoint to hold. Rather, poets create one-dimensional women and enshroud them between the words of the poem, locking them into an eternal, reductive reality. In doing so, male poets exert a form of artistic tyranny. As Rich shows, this state of captivity diminishes all meaning into a battle of holding on to beauty and youth, implying that these are the most important things to women above all else.
Hawthorne deftly showcases all of these issues in his short story "The Birthmark," demonstrating the danger of these dynamics not in a didactic fashion, but in what Vladimir Nabokov would call "a violin in a void." Hawthorne's story acknowledges and mourns the subjugation of women in artistic captivity.
Rich, Poe, and Wordsworth: Beauty as a Woman's Only Value
Adrienne Rich captures the female experience of artistic captivity under the male writer quite aptly:
"And there were all those poems about women: it seemed to be a given that men wrote poems and women frequently inhabited them. These women were almost always beautiful, but threatened with the loss of beauty, the loss of youth — the fate worse than death. Or, they were beautiful and died young, like Lucy and Lenore."
Rich demonstrates that in the world of the male poet, the female is permitted to take center stage, but only if she is beautiful. Edgar Allan Poe unforgettably refers to "the rare and radiant maiden whom the angels name Lenore" in "The Raven," and William Wordsworth, among his many Lucy poems, describes "A lovelier flower / on earth was never sown" — though the reader learns little else about these women. A pervading lack of depth functions almost like a death sentence for these characters, and one observes this dynamic clearly in Hawthorne's "The Birthmark."
Upon Aylmer's delicate expression of repulsion toward Georgiana's birthmark, Georgiana realizes — however subconsciously — that much of her value in this marriage depends upon her appearance and how lovely or unlovely she seems in her husband's eyes. Such a realization has a deadening effect upon her sense of self, and Georgiana states: "Danger is nothing to me; for life, while this hateful mark makes me the object of your horror and disgust — life is a burden which I would fling down with joy. Either remove this dreadful hand, or take my wretched life!"
Bibliography
Hawthorne, Nathaniel. "The Birthmark." Online Literature. www.online-literature.com. Accessed December 10, 2010.
Nabokov, Vladimir. Invitation to a Beheading. New York: Vintage Books, 1989.
Poe, Edgar Allan. The Raven. London: George Redway, 1885.
Rich, Adrienne. "When We Dead Awaken: Writing as Re-Vision." New Bulgarian University. www.nbu.bg. Accessed December 10, 2010.
Shakespeare, William. "My Mistress' Eyes Are Nothing like the Sun." In The Sonnets of William Shakespeare, edited by E. Dowden. London: Kegan, Paul, Trench and Co., 1881.
Wordsworth, William. "Lucy." Poetry Archive. www.poetry-archive.com. Accessed December 10, 2010.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.