Human vs. Oyster Circulatory Systems: Open and Closed
This paper compares the circulatory systems of humans and oysters, two organisms that represent the closed and open circulatory system types, respectively. It traces the path of blood through the human heart, pulmonary circuit, coronary arteries, and systemic circulation before examining the oyster's three-chambered heart, open lacunae, gill-based gas exchange, and filter-feeding digestive process. The paper also contrasts fish and mammalian heart structure and discusses shared circulatory functions such as nutrient transport, waste removal, and immune response. Despite fundamental differences in mechanism, both systems accomplish the same essential biological outcomes.
- Introduction: Two Types of Circulatory Systems: Open vs. closed systems; Mollusca overview
- The Human Circulatory System: Heart chambers, valves, and pulmonary circuit
- Coronary Circulation and Systemic Circulation: Coronary arteries, arteriosclerosis, systemic branching
- The Oyster's Open Circulatory System: Open lacunae, digestive system, blood cavities
- Gill Feeding, Gas Exchange, and Digestion: Filter feeding, mantle exchange, waste removal
- Heart Structure: Oysters, Fish, and Humans: Chamber counts and blood pressure comparisons
- Conclusion: Similarities and Differences: Shared outcomes despite contrasting mechanisms
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Uses a clear compare-and-contrast structure that moves systematically from human anatomy to oyster biology, making the differences and similarities easy to follow.
- Grounds anatomical descriptions in specific terminology (tricuspid valve, mitral valve, lacunae, abductor muscle), demonstrating subject-matter engagement beyond surface-level description.
- Broadens the comparison by introducing fish heart structure as a useful intermediate reference point between the three-chambered oyster heart and the four-chambered human heart.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates the systematic comparative analysis technique: it introduces a shared framework (circulatory system function) and then maps each organism's anatomy onto that framework in parallel, consistently returning to the same categories — heart structure, blood flow mechanics, gas exchange, digestion — for each subject. This parallel structure allows readers to track differences point by point rather than reading two isolated descriptions.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a brief taxonomic orientation placing both organisms in context, then devotes several paragraphs to the human circulatory system in sequence (pulmonary → coronary → systemic). It then pivots to the oyster, covering its open circulatory system, feeding and respiration, and unique biological traits (sex-switching, mantle gas exchange). A comparative section on heart chamber counts across species precedes the conclusion, which restates the central contrast without introducing new material.
Introduction: Two Types of Circulatory Systems
There are two main types of circulatory systems: open and closed. Some members of Phylum Mollusca have a closed circulatory system, like humans, but not all do. Molluscs live in fresh water and under the sea; this group includes oysters, octopuses, and squid. Like fish, Phylum Mollusca do not breathe air as humans do, but rather rely on a gill-type system. Humans oxygenate their blood by breathing in oxygen and passing it through the body. Molluscs oxygenate the blood through gills by direct contact with water. Molluscs also have soft bodies.
The Human Circulatory System
The human circulatory system is made up of the heart and pulmonary system, the coronary system, and the systemic circulation. The heart, located near the center of the chest cavity, works within the circulatory system when deoxygenated blood from the body enters the right atrium. That blood then flows through the tricuspid valve into the right ventricle. Blood flows into the pulmonary artery, which branches into both lungs. There, the blood releases carbon dioxide and takes on a fresh supply of oxygen. The capillary beds of the lungs are then drained, and four pulmonary veins carry oxygenated blood to the left atrium (Inlander, 1995).
From the left atrium, blood flows through the mitral valve into the left ventricle. Contractions cause the mitral valve to close and the aortic valve to open. Two openings lead to the right and left coronary arteries, supplying blood to the heart itself. The capillaries drain into two coronary veins, which empty into the right atrium.
Works Cited
Arnaudin, Mary, and Joel Mintzes. "Students' Alternative Conceptions of the Human Circulatory System: A Cross-Age Study." Science Education 69.5 (2006): 721–733. Wiley Online Library. Web. 15 Nov. 2010.
De Pater, L., and J. W. Van Den Burg. "An Electrical Analogue of the Entire Human Circulatory System." Medical and Biological Engineering and Computing 2.2 (1964): 161–166. SpringerLink. Web. 15 Nov. 2010.
Inlander, Charles B. The People's Medical Society Health Desk Reference: Information Your Doctor Can't or Won't Tell You — Everything You Need to Know for the Best in Health Care. New York: Hyperion, 1995. Print.
Jodrey, Louise, and Karl Wilbur. "Studies on Shell Formation. IV. The Respiratory Metabolism of the Oyster Mantle." Biological Bulletin 108.3 (1955): 346–358. JSTOR. Web. 15 Nov. 2010.
Ruppert, E. E., and Karen Carle. "Morphology of Metazoan Circulatory Systems." Zoomorphology 103.3 (1983): 193–208. SpringerLink. Web. 15 Nov. 2010.
Southgate, Paul C., and John S. Lucas. The Pearl Oyster. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science, 2008. Print.
"The Wonders of the Seas: Mollusks." Oceanic Research Group. N.p., n.d. Web. 15 Nov. 2010.
Weight, Ryan, John Viator, Charles Caldwell, and Allison Lisle. "Photoacoustic Detection of Metastatic Melanoma Cells in the Human Circulatory System." Optics Letters 31.20 (2006): 2998–3000. Optics InfoBase. Web. 15 Nov. 2010.
"Phylum Mollusca: Second Largest Animal Phylum." Interagency Education Research Initiative (2006). Web. 15 Nov. 2010.
"Difference Between Open and Closed Circulatory System." GlobalShiksha.com. N.p., n.d. Web. 15 Nov. 2010.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.