This paper summarizes and analyzes Tiwana and Konsynski's (2010) peer-reviewed study on the complementarities between organizational IT architecture and governance structure. The paper examines how modular, loosely coupled IT architectures — including Service Oriented Architectures, Web Services, and Platform-as-a-Service — must be systematically aligned with governance frameworks to sustain enterprise agility in turbulent markets. It further explores the implications of this alignment for information assurance and enterprise security, arguing that integrated IT architecture and governance, when supported by security platforms, can accelerate achievement of strategic objectives while enabling knowledge sharing across the organization.
This study guide is drawn from PaperDue's library of 130,000+ paper examples across 47 subjects.
The paper demonstrates source-anchored analytical writing: rather than simply paraphrasing the source article, it uses the article's conclusions as a launching point for original analysis about the broader organizational and security implications of IT architecture alignment. This technique shows how to engage critically with literature without departing from the source's evidentiary basis.
The paper opens with a focused summary of the Tiwana and Konsynski (2010) study, covering methodology and core findings. It then pivots to an analysis section that extends the study's implications into information assurance, enterprise security, and organizational culture. A brief concluding observation ties strategic execution value back to the alignment of architecture and governance. The reference list follows APA format.
In the peer-reviewed article "Complementarities Between Organizational IT Architecture and Governance Structure," Tiwana and Konsynski (2010) contend that IT architecture and IT governance design and implementation are highly dependent on systematic and process-related interdependencies that will often shift significantly over the lifecycle of any IT framework. This makes the task of ensuring adoption of IT architectural components — as diverse as Service Oriented Architectures (SOA), Web Services, Platform-as-a-Service (PaaS), and other nascent enterprise platform technologies — a continual challenge requiring alignment to a business's strategic programs, plans, and initiatives.
This is where the article unifies IT governance and IT architecture, concentrating on how each is critically important for ensuring the agility of an enterprise over time. Through a well-defined methodology and use of advanced statistical analysis techniques including Factor Analysis, the authors convey how the alignment of IT architectures and governance frameworks to business objectives enables an enterprise to be more agile in turbulent markets. The conclusion is that greater organizational agility can be attained through the systematic use of IT architectures and governance frameworks.
IT architecture modularity — defined by the loosely coupled integration of key process and system areas — in conjunction with the standardization of IT architectures and governance frameworks, forms the foundation of greater IT agility and, over time, greater IT alignment to business objectives (Tiwana & Konsynski, 2010). Service Oriented Architecture, as one prominent example, exemplifies how modular design principles can support this kind of flexible, standards-driven alignment. IT governance influences the alignment of IT architectures and frameworks throughout this process.
The implications for information assurance and enterprise security of having IT architectures that are modular enough to integrate with existing processes and systems — yet standardized enough to minimize the potential for security threats — are significant. Beyond the specific areas of IT governance decentralization and the use of IT implementation decentralization to maintain agility, the implications of information assurance and enterprise security are direct and significant for IT agility and IT alignment to strategic goals and objectives.
The organizational culture of an enterprise is very often shaped by its use of IT architectures and the integration of architectural components into governance frameworks (Mendelson, 2000). This is a key point the authors of the study make: the combined effects of a highly integrated IT architecture with IT governance, when supported by enterprise security platform components, can accelerate a company toward its objectives (Tiwana & Konsynski, 2010). The combined effects of these elements can provide an acceleration to business objectives while mitigating risks and ensuring a very high level of cross-information and knowledge sharing across the enterprise (Tiwana & Konsynski, 2010). This aspect of knowledge sharing and knowledge management as control variables in IT alignment assessment shows significant potential in the study completed by Tiwana and Konsynski (2010).
Information assurance and enterprise security act as the catalyst for unifying IT architectures and governance frameworks while also ensuring a very high level of agility and responsiveness to the market and customers. The creation of value through the combining of these factors can be measured by greater accuracy in strategic execution.
You’re 90% through this paper. Sign up to read the full paper.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.