This paper examines Japan's distinctive modernization strategy — often called "Japanese spirit, Western things" — through which Japanese leaders selectively absorbed Western technology and economic practices while actively protecting traditional cultural values and hierarchical authority structures. Beginning with Commodore Perry's forced opening of Japan in 1854 and tracing developments through the post-World War II economic miracle and into the 21st century, the paper explores how Japan became one of the world's leading economies without fully surrendering its cultural identity. It also considers the geopolitical tensions with China, North Korea, and South Korea that complicate Japan's future trajectory in an increasingly globalized world.
While China is often referred to as "the sleeping giant," Japan has been known as "the Rising Sun" for a variety of reasons. Many Westerners do not realize that Japan has been open to the West for only a century and a half, and are reluctant to consider the events of the 20th century in the context of the longer historical paradigm of Japanese culture, social traditions, and the view Japan has held about the outside world for centuries. It is this island-nation identity that has played such a strong role in the making of modern Japan.
Japan had been visited by European missionaries and traders as early as the late 16th century, but it was not until 1854, when U.S. naval forces under the command of Commodore Matthew Perry forced the opening of Japan to the outside world through the Convention of Kanagawa, that the country's modern trajectory truly began. Once this occurred, two trends accelerated: competition with Russia and China, and Japan's realization that in order to become part of the modern world, it needed far more resources than its islands could provide.
Eventually, this resulted in the militarization of the country and a process of modernization that did not require embracing Western culture wholesale. This approach had deep roots in tradition — opening the culture only slightly, just enough to take what was necessary to slowly and steadily modernize, without jeopardizing traditional values and, more importantly, the traditional hierarchical system of authority. Historically, this can be seen in Japan's appetite for Western technological innovations — the telephone, camera, motion pictures, and more — all of which began entering Japan in the late 19th century.
This slow, steady, but segmented opening of Japanese culture is also known as "Japanese spirit, Western things." As The Economist observed, "Instead of simply trying to preserve small cultural traditions, Japan's power-brokers tried to absorb Western technology in a way that would shield them from political competition and protect their interests. Imitators still abound in Japan and elsewhere" ("Japanese Spirit, Western Things," 2003). This is a cultural, political, and social modernization strategy that allows for the adoption of Western technology and selective cultural elements while maintaining a strong and continuous push for traditional values and mores that transcend technology.
Arguably, this technique was highly successful up to 1945 and the end of World War II. However, once the United States occupied post-war Japan and began helping to rebuild the war-torn economy, each succeeding generation has tended to move further toward Western culture, without the same veneration and adherence to Japanese tradition that characterized past generations.
Modernization has been enormously successful for Japan. Since 1956 it has been a member of the United Nations and has served as a non-permanent member of the Security Council for two decades. Japan is also one of the G4 nations, a member of APEC, and an active participant in international economic affairs with strong ties to the EU, the United States, and particularly Asian trading partners ("U.S. Backs Japan," 2007).
"Postwar miracle, global trade, and economic partnerships"
"China, North Korea, and Japan's uncertain future"
You’re 55% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.