This essay examines Stephanie Black's documentary "Life and Debt" and its critique of economic globalization's impact on Jamaica. Through contrasting the experiences of tourists visiting Jamaica with the lived reality of Jamaican workers, farmers, and citizens, the paper explores how international financial institutions—particularly the International Monetary Fund, World Bank, and Inter-American Development Bank—have dismantled local industries, replaced domestic agriculture with imported goods, and created a economy dependent on low-wage sweatshops and tourism. The documentary reveals the structural inequalities underlying globalization, demonstrating how developing nations become trapped in cycles of debt and poverty while enriching wealthy countries and multinational corporations.
Jamaica is a land of sea, sand, and sun—and a prime example of the devastating impact economic globalization can have on a developing country. Through voice-over narration adapted from Jamaica Kincaid's book A Small Place, filmmaker Stephanie Black's documentary Life and Debt has successfully revealed how the "mechanism of debt" is destroying local agriculture and industry while substituting sweatshops and cheap imports. The film presents perspectives from Jamaican workers, farmers, government officials, and policy makers who experience the reality of globalization from the ground up. This essay presents a comparison and contrast between the lives of tourists visiting Jamaica and the lives of Jamaican natives as depicted in Black's documentary, demonstrating how tourism serves as both a symptom and mask for the island's economic crisis.
"If you go to Antigua as a tourist, this is what you will see," as Kincaid narrates in the film. Lovely hotel room linens, a balcony view of perfect beach, perfectly tanned foreigners, and even a wedding between tourists set against a backdrop of perfectly blue surf are everything visitors encounter. They are "allowed" to remain ignorant of the death, poverty, and misery that Jamaican natives suffer on this island. This carefully curated experience is precisely what the "visitors' industry" is designed to conceal.
Tourists earn all this privilege and enjoy their marvelous vacation because they "deserve" this trip—having spent "hard and cold and dark long days working in North America (or, worse, Europe), earning some money so that they could stay in this place," as Kincaid observes. The contrast in freedom is striking: tourists can enter Jamaica by simply showing a driver's license, while Jamaican citizens must answer countless questions about why they wish to visit tourists' native countries. Tourists move through customs swiftly and without luggage searches, whereas "an Antiguan black returning to Antigua from Europe or North America with cardboard boxes of much needed cheap clothes and food for relatives" faces intensive scrutiny.
The tourists might be delighted by the large amount of Jamaican dollars they receive in exchange for their twenty dollars, but it would not occur to them that this currency's weakness results from repeated devaluations imposed by the International Monetary Fund. It is perhaps better for tourists not to know that everything in their delicious meals came off a ship from Miami. The tourists in the film function as a metaphor for all Americans and people from wealthy countries who may be unaware of life beyond their hotel gates. All they see upon arrival in Jamaica are swaying trees and natives splashing in warm turquoise water.
In stark contrast, tourists need not think about how Jamaica's economy is being decimated by globalization with help from the International Monetary Fund, the World Bank, the Inter-American Development Bank, U.S. corporations, and "free trade" policies. After the first fifteen minutes of the documentary, audiences witness the difference between the vacation paradise of Montego Bay—with its blue sea, white sand, and drinks with umbrellas—and Kingston, where Jamaican sweatshop workers provide tax-free labor at thirty dollars per week for companies like Tommy Hilfiger and Hanes. The contrast extends to agriculture: once-successful dairy, chicken, and banana farmers have been ruined by U.S. powdered milk and chicken imports, as well as produce from Chiquita and Dole.
The documentary recounts how the Chiquita banana conflict included a police crackdown on striking workers in 1992, during which twenty-three people were killed. Tourism is now one of Jamaica's few remaining viable industries. Information provided by the narrator—such as details about how the sewage system functions or how the beef industry has been destroyed by cheap frozen patties shipped from the United States—adds a sobering dimension to the sights tourists see from tour bus windows on the way to their hotels, passing Baskin-Robbins, McDonald's, Burger King, and groups of natives who, as Kincaid describes them, are "squatting on the side of the road, hanging out with all the time in the world. You might look at them and think: They are so relaxed, so laid back. They are never in a hurry."
However, as former Jamaican Prime Minister Michael Manley explains, these workers are idle not by choice but because they have been put out of work by years of brutal international tax and tariff structures and inequitable labor laws. Manley provides crucial context for understanding Jamaica's predicament: he was elected on an anti-IMF platform in 1976 but was forced, by lack of viable alternatives, to sign IMF agreements in 1977. "Going to the IMF and signing that agreement was one of the more bitter, traumatic experiences of my life," Manley states. He emphasizes that this experience is a global pattern affecting the Third World: "IMF country that has a good education system, a good public health system…All of them are caught in the old colonial chains." This observation reveals how structural adjustment policies trap developing nations in cycles of dependency.
The documentary demonstrates that Jamaica's economic collapse stems directly from policies imposed by international financial institutions. The International Monetary Fund, the World Bank, and the Inter-American Development Bank now control nearly every facet of the Jamaican economy. The primary beneficiaries are franchises like McDonald's, Wendy's, and Burger King, which contribute little more than unskilled, low-paying service jobs.
Consumer advocate Ralph Nader summarized the problem effectively when he described globalization as "the subordination of human rights, environmental rights, and consumer rights." The mechanisms outlined in Life and Debt expose how this subordination operates in practice. Devaluation of local currency, removal of tariffs protecting domestic industries, and mandated privatization of public services all function to benefit wealthy nations and multinational corporations while impoverishing workers and farmers in developing countries.
The documented destruction of Jamaica's agricultural sector illustrates this pattern clearly. Farmers who once supplied domestic and regional markets were forced to compete with heavily subsidized U.S. agricultural exports. Similarly, local manufacturing industries could not survive once tariff protections were eliminated. The result is a nation that must import nearly all its food and manufactured goods, creating dependency on foreign currency and deepening the debt cycle that perpetuates this vulnerability.
This documentary perfectly captures the largely ignored downside to globalization and the subsequent domination of the world economy by the U.S. and Western Europe. Specifically, it demonstrates that undeveloped and developing countries continue to grow poorer at the expense of the rich. Life and Debt is essential viewing for anyone who believes globalization is the only path for developing countries to compete with the rest of the world, and for anyone seeking to understand the reasons behind global protests against international financial institutions and trade policies.
You’re 98% through this paper. Sign up to read the full paper.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.