Lincoln, Slavery, and Race: Review of Frederickson's Big Enough
This paper reviews George Frederickson's Big Enough to Be Inconsistent: Abraham Lincoln Confronts Slavery and Race (Harvard University Press, 2008). It examines Lincoln's racial attitudes in the context of nineteenth-century white American opinion, tracing his evolution from cautious constitutional opposition to slavery's expansion through the pragmatic decision to issue the Emancipation Proclamation in 1863 and, finally, to his tentative embrace of limited Black suffrage near the war's end. The review also addresses Lincoln's colonization proposals, the political pressures of the border states, and the debate over whether his antislavery record reflects deep moral conviction, shrewd political calculation, or both.
- Lincoln's Racial Views in Historical Context: Lincoln's racism compared to white contemporaries
- Constitutional Limits and the Goal of Preserving the Union: Lincoln's antislavery views constrained by Constitution
- Gradual Emancipation, Colonization, and Border State Politics: Colonization plans and border state pressures
- The Emancipation Proclamation as a War Measure: Emancipation Proclamation issued to win the war
- Lincoln's Legacy and the Question of Consistency: Lincoln's postwar legacy and historical judgment
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The review consistently grounds Lincoln's positions in their specific historical and political context, avoiding anachronistic moral judgments by comparing Lincoln to his contemporaries such as Douglas, Davis, and Andrew Johnson.
- It uses direct quotations from Frederickson's text to anchor each claim, lending credibility to the analysis and demonstrating close engagement with the source material.
- The paper maintains a clear chronological thread — from Lincoln's pre-war stance through the Emancipation Proclamation to the 13th Amendment — making a complex ideological evolution easy to follow.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of comparative contextualization: rather than evaluating Lincoln in isolation, it repeatedly measures his positions against those of political rivals and contemporaries. This technique allows the writer to make qualified claims about Lincoln's "milder" racism without either excusing it or overstating it, which is the hallmark of nuanced historical argument.
Structure breakdown
The review opens by situating Lincoln's racial attitudes within broader nineteenth-century white American opinion, then moves through his constitutional constraints, his colonization proposals, and his political calculations regarding the border states. It reaches its climax with the Emancipation Proclamation and the 13th Amendment, and closes by assessing the overall consistency — or productive inconsistency — of Lincoln's record. Each paragraph advances a single stage of this chronological and analytical arc.
Lincoln's Racial Views in Historical Context
Like almost all white Americans in the nineteenth century, Lincoln held prejudicial or racist views about Black people and was reluctant to extend full citizenship and political rights to them. His native state of Illinois had a constitutional provision that barred Black people from settling there at all, as did Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, and other Northern and Western states. Only a few New England states actually granted nonwhites equal citizenship and voting rights before the Civil War. Whites could — and did — oppose the expansion of slavery in the Western territories and even slavery itself, while still not being particularly favorable to Black equality.
Nevertheless, compared to his contemporary opponents — Senator Stephen Douglas, Andrew Johnson, and Jefferson Davis — who spoke openly of their contempt for Black people, their support for slavery, and their belief in Black inferiority, Lincoln's racism was of a milder variety. Unlike Davis, who owned over 500 slaves, or Douglas, whose wife owned 150 slaves in Mississippi, Lincoln had never been a slaveholder and never made any public or private statement sympathizing with slavery. Just the opposite: he stated that he would never want to be a slave or a master, since the core of his political and social philosophy was that every person had the natural right to rise as far and as fast as their talents permitted. As he put it in 1861, all people should "have an equal chance" in life, even though he did not accept full equality and citizenship rights for Black Americans (Frederickson 87).
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.