Love as Action: Hooks, Peck, Jordan, and Sanchez on True Love
This essay explores the absence of a true love ethic in modern America by drawing on the works of Bell Hooks, M. Scott Peck, June Jordan, and Sonia Sanchez. It argues that American culture confuses love with romance, sexual desire, and material symbols, while patriarchal values suppress genuine emotional vulnerability. Hooks and Peck redefine love as a willed action oriented toward spiritual growth, while Jordan extends this framework to social justice and love of humanity. Sanchez's poetry captures love's emotional complexity and inequality. Together, these writers suggest that authentic love is possible but requires challenging deeply held cultural assumptions about gender, power, and the nature of love itself.
- Introduction: The Absence of a Love Ethic in Modern America: Patriarchy and cultural confusion undermine genuine love
- Love as Noun vs. Love as Verb: Love misunderstood as possession rather than action
- Bell Hooks and the Definition of True Love: Hooks defines love as spiritual, transformative action
- M. Scott Peck: Love as Choice and Discipline: Peck argues love is a willed choice requiring effort
- Sonia Sanchez and June Jordan: Love in Poetry and Prose: Poetry and essays illustrate love's complexity and politics
- Conclusion: Is True Love Possible in Modern America?: Cautious optimism about embracing a true love ethic
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper synthesizes four distinct authors into a coherent argument, showing how each writer contributes a different dimension — theoretical, poetic, and political — to the central thesis about love.
- Direct quotations from primary sources are well-integrated and used to support analytical claims rather than substitute for them, giving the argument credibility and grounding.
- The essay moves logically from cultural critique (love confused with sex and materialism) to definition (Hooks and Peck) to literary illustration (Sanchez and Jordan), creating a layered structure that builds persuasively.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative synthesis across primary sources: rather than treating each author in isolation, it identifies thematic convergences and contrasts (e.g., Hooks and Jordan both critiquing patriarchy; Sanchez and Jordan offering complementary but distinct representations of love). This technique is especially effective in undergraduate literary and cultural analysis essays where students must argue across multiple texts.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a cultural diagnosis — America's lack of a love ethic — then moves to definitional groundwork (love as verb vs. noun), followed by close engagement with Hooks and Peck's theoretical frameworks. The literary section on Sanchez and Jordan applies those frameworks to creative works. The conclusion circles back to the opening thesis and offers a cautiously optimistic assessment, grounded briefly in personal observation. The Works Cited follows MLA format.
Introduction: The Absence of a Love Ethic in Modern America
Modern America lacks a true love ethic. Writers like M. Scott Peck and bell hooks argue that our confusion about love stems from an inability to see love as an action rather than a noun, and from the confusion of romance and sex with love. Instead, they argue that true love is based on choice and the desire to nurture the self or another spiritually.
Hooks specifically argues that much of our confusion about love stems from our paternalistic culture, which teaches men that to love is to be weak and inferior. As such, love has become associated with what is feminine and weak in our culture. In their works, June Jordan and Sonia Sanchez describe the full range of what is considered love in our culture — from the sensual and romantic, to the understanding that love of humanity can help create a more meaningful and functional relationship with ourselves, others, and the environment.
Within our patriarchal society, power and domination essentially quash any hope of a true love ethic taking root. Men are taught that to be vulnerable to love is weak, and that a desire or need for love is a feminine characteristic. As such, men often learn that the expression of interest in sexual pleasure is the only manly pursuit. To many such men, talking about love and admitting the need for love in one's life is a clear invitation to be seen as weak and worthless. Consequently, many men find themselves unable to acknowledge, understand, or express their need for love. Further, they are unable to see a woman as a partner in such a search, and male-female relationships are often based on inequalities of power that place the man in a superior position. In essence, today's society frequently places the need for power above the need for love.
Love as Noun vs. Love as Verb
Today, most people think of love as a noun rather than as a verb. To most people, love is a concrete entity — a thing that exists. When they say "I love you," they mean that their love exists as a feeling they own. To love someone is not an action but a state of being, almost a possession one can hold onto. Often, love is associated with concrete, materialistic, and frequently superficial things like a wedding band, flowers, or even heart-shaped candies.
This common understanding of love as a noun is profoundly flawed. Love is an ever-changing, constantly renewing action. It cannot and does not remain static, and the very idea that it can be possessed is entirely contradictory to its fundamental nature. Love grows and expands, ebbs and flows, and is in constant change. To treat it as a noun defiles the idea of true love.
Love should instead be considered a verb — an action. True love is an experience of being, an action of the heart, rather than a property or a "thing" that can be possessed. Love is essentially the act of loving, the act of generosity of spirit and heart. Love can only be shared with another individual and can never be found in material things. The definition of flowers and heart-shaped chocolates as love is absurd and demeaning. At best, these are pale symbols of love — pale stand-ins for the genuine action of giving and caring between individuals.
It seems there are many problems with the idea of love in modern society. Love is often seen as a material thing, a noun, or is crushed by the paternalistic need for power and domination. Is it possible to truly love in our society? To answer this, it is important to understand the definition of true love in order to move toward an understanding of whether love is at all possible in the modern world.
Works Cited
Jordan, June. Some of Us Did Not Die: New and Selected Essays. BasicCivitas Books, 2003.
Hooks, Bell. All About Love: New Visions. Perennial, 2001.
Peck, M. Scott. The Road Less Traveled, 25th Anniversary Edition: A New Psychology of Love, Traditional Values and Spiritual Growth. Touchstone Books, 2003.
Sanchez, Sonia. Like the Singing Coming Off the Drums. Beacon Press, 1999.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.