This paper examines the Mafia as the dominant popular culture expression of the Italian-American identity, tracing its roots to the distinctive social, cultural, and political conditions of Sicily. Beginning with the historical context of Sicily's separation from mainland Italy, the paper discusses how corrupt local leaders and organized crime networks gradually assumed state-like functions in the 19th century. It then explores how American gangster culture — particularly the rise of the American Mafia in the 1920s — shaped the Sicilian Mafia's criminal character. Finally, it analyzes the Mafia's deep connection to the Italian identity through the country's tradition of individualism, fragmentation, and resistance to centralized authority.
The primary popular culture expression of the Italian-American identity is the Mafia, whose fame is much to the dismay of many Italian-Americans. The Mafia holds this distinction largely because of the influence of Francis Ford Coppola's landmark film The Godfather, which won an Academy Award in 1972 and reinvented the gangster movie genre ("The Mafia in Popular Culture," n.d.). The popularity of the Mafia as an expression of the Italian-American identity has been fueled by the group's extortion, its establishment as a deeply rooted criminal organization, and its involvement in political corruption and murder. The Mafia is essentially characterized by popular American derivations and strong ties to the Italian identity.
Sicily is a region of Italy that has historically held a distinct position from the rest of the country. Some of the major ways in which this region has differentiated itself from mainland Italy include its obvious physical character as an island, as well as numerous social and cultural differences. Moreover, Sicily has its own government, dialect, and mentality — all of which contributed to the emergence of the Mafia. In essence, the Mafia's emergence and growth are attributed to the fact that Sicily has historically been a place to be exploited rather than governed (Lindo, 2008). Nonetheless, the origin of the Sicilian Mafia is complex, as several scholars have identified different contributing factors and elements.
Generally, the Mafia arose from the perception of Sicily as fundamentally different from the rest of Italy — a perception reflected in its distinctive government, dialect, and mentality. The region became characterized by organized crime, which was viewed as a sign of poverty and backwardness that would be eliminated through the country's unification in 1860. Contrary to the hopes of many Italians, however, the state legitimized numerous corrupt local leaders who appeared to keep Sicily under control but in reality fostered the growth of local illegitimate power. These corrupt local leaders, mostly drawn from the wealthiest aristocratic families, provided the earliest foundations for the Mafia. They contributed to the emergence of several Mafia networks in the 19th century, which gradually assumed state-like functions such as providing leadership, collecting taxes, and enforcing their own laws. As these networks grew, political and economic life were significantly adjusted to accommodate them as an accepted reality. Legitimate governments faced enormous difficulties in asserting their authority, since doing so required redefining these widely accepted networks as criminal.
American culture also played a crucial role in the history and development of the Mafia, as reflected in the emergence of the Italian-American identity. The American derivations of the Mafia were rooted in gangster life and culture, which significantly influenced the organization to the point that it became the primary popular culture expression of the Italian-American identity — albeit to the disappointment of many Italian-Americans ("The Mafia in Popular Culture," n.d.). Gangster life and culture in America provided the basis for the Mafia to develop as a network of organized crime operating across both Italy and the United States.
In its earliest years, the Mafia carried no criminal connotations; it was a term commonly used to refer to people who were suspicious of central authority or government. However, the group shifted toward criminality following the emergence of the American Mafia in the 1920s. The Sicilian Mafia began extorting protection fees from landowners and subsequently became a violent criminal organization in the 19th century, a transformation accelerated by the rise of the American Mafia to prominence in the 1920s. While these two groups were separate entities, they shared a code of conduct, loyalty, and traditions such as omertà ("Origins of The Mafia," n.d.). The code of omertà — a strict vow of silence — enabled both the Sicilian and American Mafias to maintain secrecy and operational success. It also contributed to their ability to influence political, judicial, and business leaders, making it exceptionally difficult for law enforcement agencies to dismantle them.
Despite being largely shaped by popular American derivations with regard to its criminal activities, the Sicilian Mafia is strongly linked to the Italian identity. This strong link is the basis for its consideration as the primary popular expression of the Italian-American identity and culture. The relationship between the Mafia and the Italian identity is reflected in the general social and cultural conditions of the country that provided the basis for its development. The Italian identity is characterized by a deep commitment to fragmentation and individualism, reflected in the country's relative inability to unify under a common central power. Compared to the rest of Europe, Italy lacked a common set of values that would enable the whole society to develop cohesively (Battilana, 2003). Individualism and fragmentation thus became core features of the Italian identity and contributed directly to the emergence of the Mafia. The Mafia's rise is largely attributable to this individualism and to the absence of collaborative solidarity among the lower classes.
The Mafia emerged in Sicily because of the perception of that region as distinct from the rest of Europe — a distinctiveness reflected in its own dialect, government, and culture. Since the group was later influenced by gangster culture in America, it came to be characterized by both popular American derivations and a strong link to the Italian identity.
Battilana, S.C. (2003, November). Why did the Mafia emerge in Italy? An institutional answer. Retrieved from Stanford University website: http://web.stanford.edu/~silviacb/PEPR/Why%20did%20the%20Mafia%20Emerge%20in%20Italy.pdf
Lindo, S.B. (2008, May). Identity in flux: The Mafia, Antimafia, and Sicily's discovery of new Italian unity. Retrieved from Connecticut College website: http://digitalcommons.conncoll.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1001&context=italhp
"Individualism and fragmentation fuel Mafia emergence"
You’re 95% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.