Marcellus Shale Drilling and Groundwater Contamination
This paper argues that natural gas drilling operations at the Marcellus Shale formation have become a significant source of groundwater contamination. Drawing on government records, environmental reports, and regulatory testimony from New York and Pennsylvania, the paper reviews evidence of radioactive wastewater, elevated levels of total dissolved solids (TDS), and toxic chemicals introduced into rivers, streams, and drinking water supplies through hydraulic fracturing. It also examines the economic motivations behind the drilling boom, regulatory responses from both states, and proposed solutions including new effluent standards and mandatory chemical disclosure requirements. The paper concludes that all major stakeholders acknowledge the contamination problem, even as proposed remedies remain incomplete.
- Introduction: Background on Marcellus Shale formation and thesis
- Radioactive Wastewater and Early Regulatory Responses: NY and PA findings on radioactive and TDS contamination
- The Hydraulic Fracturing Process and Its Contaminants: How fracking generates toxic wastewater and documented harms
- Economic Motivations vs. Contamination Threat: Drilling boom incentives weighed against health risks
- Proposed Solutions and Regulatory Reforms: State-level amendments and reporting requirements proposed
- Conclusion: Stakeholders acknowledge contamination; remedies remain incomplete
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper builds its argument through a logical progression of evidence, moving from official denials to documented findings of contamination, which gives the argument credibility and rhetorical force.
- It balances multiple perspectives — industry benefits, regulatory positions, and environmental findings — and includes a "Weaknesses" section that acknowledges counterarguments, demonstrating intellectual honesty.
- The use of specific quantitative data (e.g., 267 times the safety limit for radium-226, 9 million gallons of wastewater daily) strengthens the empirical foundation of the argument.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of a structured literature review to support a thesis, synthesizing multiple primary and secondary sources — government reports, environmental testimony, and investigative journalism — into a coherent argument. Rather than treating each source in isolation, the author connects findings across New York and Pennsylvania to build a cumulative case for aquifer contamination.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with an introduction establishing the geographic and technological context of Marcellus Shale drilling and states its thesis. A literature review section covers findings in New York and Pennsylvania separately. Subsequent sections examine the hydraulic fracturing process, weigh economic motivations against environmental risk, and propose regulatory solutions. The paper closes with an "Assumptions" section restating the evidentiary basis, a "Weaknesses" section acknowledging counterarguments, and a brief conclusion. This is roughly an undergraduate-level argumentative research paper with an explicit pro/con analytical structure.
Introduction
The Marcellus Shale is a black, fine-grained, laminated sedimentary formation that extends deep underground from Ohio and West Virginia into Pennsylvania and southern New York (Paterson 2011). In some locations it is exposed at the ground surface, while in others — such as along the Pennsylvania border in the Delaware River Valley — it lies as deep as 7,000 feet below ground. Drilling is concentrated in areas where the shale is deeper than 2,000 feet. Geologists have long been aware of the natural gas resources found in this formation, but exploring and extracting those resources proved difficult and expensive because of its depth.
Recent technological developments, however, brought new attention to the shale. Rising fuel costs on the world market and the prospect of lower extraction costs through new technology motivated the tapping of this long-neglected resource. The proximity of the shale to high-demand markets in New York, New Jersey, and New England further encouraged the venture. In 2008, the Marcellus Shale Coalition was created to undertake the project. As operations progressed, however, concerns about possible environmental and community impacts emerged. Chief among these was the contamination of water in areas spanned by the shale and, more recently, in areas distant from it. This paper argues that operations at the Marcellus Shale have become a source of contamination of groundwater aquifers.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.