Skip to main content
Essay Graduate 3,782 words

Modern vs. Postmodern Bereavement Theory Compared

~19 min read 7 sections Psychology
Abstract

This paper examines and contrasts modernist and postmodernist theories of bereavement and grief. Beginning with Freud's influential "grief work" hypothesis — which argues that healthy recovery requires severing all bonds with the deceased — the paper critiques this model and traces the evolution of postmodern alternatives. Drawing on Bowlby and Ainsworth's Attachment Theory, the paper explores key postmodern frameworks including the Continuing Bonds theory (Klass, Silverman, and Nickman), Worden's Four Tasks of Grief, the Dual Process Model, and the Kubler-Ross five-stage model. The paper concludes by presenting Bartholomew and Horowitz's Relationship Questionnaire as an extension of postmodern attachment thinking, arguing that maintaining bonds with the deceased is not pathological but can support healthy grieving and personal growth.

Key Takeaways
  • Introduction: Overview of grief, paper aims, and thesis
  • What Is Bereavement?: Definition and scope of bereavement
  • Modernist Theory of Bereavement: Logical positivism and grief work hypothesis
  • Freud's Severance of Bonds to the Deceased: Freud's mourning theory and its critics
  • The Evolution of Postmodern Bereavement Theory: Bowlby, Worden, Dual Process, and Kubler-Ross models
  • Continuing Bonds and the Relationship Questionnaire: Klass, Silverman, Nickman, and Bartholomew's attachment tool
  • Conclusion: Postmodernism as epistemological antithesis to modernism
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • The paper clearly states its thesis early — opposing Freud's severance-of-bonds model and supporting postmodern continuing bonds theory — and consistently returns to that central argument throughout.
  • It organizes a wide range of theorists (Freud, Bowlby, Worden, Klass, Kubler-Ross, Bartholomew) into a coherent chronological and conceptual narrative, helping readers see how the field evolved.
  • It balances theoretical exposition with evaluative commentary, acknowledging Freud's contributions while systematically critiquing his assumptions using evidence from later researchers.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper demonstrates effective comparative theory analysis: it presents two opposing epistemological frameworks (logical positivism underlying modernism versus social constructionism underlying postmodernism) and uses that philosophical contrast to ground the disagreement between specific grief models. This move — tracing surface-level theoretical differences back to deeper epistemological commitments — is a hallmark of graduate-level academic writing in the social sciences.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens with a definition of bereavement before presenting the modernist framework and Freud's specific model in detail. It then traces the postmodern response through Bowlby's Attachment Theory and several derivative models (Four Tasks, Dual Process, Kubler-Ross, Continuing Bonds). The Relationship Questionnaire section extends the postmodern argument. The conclusion synthesizes the epistemological contrast between the two paradigms, reinforcing the paper's central claim.

Essay 3,782 words

Introduction

Bereavement is a universal human experience — every person encounters the loss of a loved one at some point in life, yet each individual experiences it in a unique way. It is an undeniable truth that to be human is to grieve. The death of a loved one can be difficult, overwhelming, and deeply painful for any person. When faced with such circumstances, many individuals — especially older adults — gradually learn to endure their loss over time. For others, however, forgetting and living without a loved one is not so easy. Some people find it extremely difficult to cope with grief-stricken situations, experiencing sorrow of greater intensity or duration (Hansson & Stroebe, 2007). A number of theorists have advanced views on grief, mourning, and bereavement since the discipline of psychology was established. Among the most significant is Freud, who was the first to present a modern, systematic account of grief.

This paper presents both modernist and postmodernist perspectives on grief and bereavement, with the primary purpose of drawing a contrast between these two theoretical paradigms. Central to this argument is a challenge to one aspect of Freud's modern grief theory — specifically, the belief that a healthy life requires a person to completely sever his or her relationship with deceased loved ones. The paper disputes the modernist claim that an individual cannot live a healthy, satisfied, and fulfilling life if he or she continues to grieve and maintain a spiritual connection with the departed.

In contrast to the Freudian position, this paper supports the postmodern view of grief developed by John Bowlby and Mary Ainsworth, as well as the theorists who have built upon their work. The argument here is that maintaining a relationship with deceased loved ones is not only normal but genuinely important — and that compelling a bereaved individual to sever those bonds can, in many cases, cause serious harm.

The paper also incorporates the Relationship Questionnaire (RQ) developed by Bartholomew and Horowitz, which extends the postmodern tradition — particularly the work of Bowlby and Ainsworth — into a systematic attachment classification model.

What Is Bereavement?

Bereavement is the term used to describe the condition of having lost someone or something significant. It is sometimes defined as a period of time, a process, or a set of particular experiences associated with loss. According to Tom Attig, a well-known philosopher, "When those we love die, we embark on a difficult journey of the heart. We begin by suffering bereavement. We 'suffer' in the sense that we have been deprived of someone we love" (as cited in Hedtke, 2010).

Modernist Theory of Bereavement

According to the grief work hypothesis of modernist bereavement theory, grief must be fully worked through. This view advocates that all stages and tasks of grief must be completed and that all negative feelings associated with loss must be processed. The hypothesis holds that grief is an intrapsychic process — one that the individual undertakes alone. It also asserts that grief is time-limited, with a clear beginning and a clear end. Most critically, this hypothesis requires the individual to conclude the grief process by destroying all bonds with the deceased. In short, the modernist bereavement theory holds that recovery is achieved only when mourning follows a prescribed course.

The modernist paradigm of bereavement theory has strong epistemological roots in logical positivism. This framework prioritizes scientific rationality, goal-directedness, and efficiency, setting aside emotional connectivity. Philosophically, logical positivism rests on empiricism. As Silverman and Klass (1996) explain, empiricism "sees a rational order in the world, with one fact leading to another" (p. 21). When applied to bereavement, this leads to the assumption that universal truths about how human beings grieve can be identified through scientific investigation (Rosenblatt, 1996). Since the beginning of the twentieth century, this grief work hypothesis — rooted in logical positivism — has dominated both bereavement research and clinical practice.

4 Sections Hidden · 2,360 words
Freud's Severance of Bonds to the Deceased620 words
Modern psychological research has been profoundly shaped by Freud's contributions to the field. With respect to bereavement and grief, Freud argued that it is…
The Evolution of Postmodern Bereavement Theory780 words
Postmodern grief and bereavement theories have grown out of a social constructionist understanding of the world. This perspective holds that human beings understand reality through what they…
Continuing Bonds and the Relationship Questionnaire580 words
Dennis Klass has been involved in the study of bereavement since 1968. Silverman has worked with the bereaved for over four decades, including…
Conclusion380 words
Postmodern bereavement theory is intricate, multifaceted, and quite difficult to understand. Since its emergence in the 1980s, the postmodern movement has generated…
Key Concepts in This Paper
Continuing Bonds Grief Work Attachment Theory Logical Positivism Dual Process Model Postmodern Grief Severance of Bonds Kubler-Ross Stages Social Constructionism Relationship Questionnaire
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Modern vs. Postmodern Bereavement Theory Compared. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/modern-postmodern-bereavement-theory-111076

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.