Native American Bias in K–12 Literature and Curricula
This paper examines the racial and cultural bias embedded in K–12 educational materials concerning Native Americans. Drawing on two children's books — Lynne Reid Banks's The Indian in the Cupboard and W.S. Phillips's Indian Campfire Tales — the paper identifies recurring stereotypes: objectification, generic "Hollywood Indian" imagery, demeaning language, and the "vanishing Indian" narrative. The analysis further argues that these misrepresentations are reinforced structurally by the Dewey Decimal Classification system, which marginalizes Native American knowledge by situating it in the past and outside the mainstream of human learning. Together, these curricular artifacts shape harmful misperceptions for all students and can cause particular harm to Native American children.
- Introduction: Native Americans in Educational Materials: Overview of K–12 curriculum bias against Native Americans
- Stereotyping in The Indian in the Cupboard: Analysis of stereotypes in Banks's children's novel
- Bias in Indian Campfire Tales: Examination of offensive language and generic depictions
- Language, Imagery, and the Vanishing Indian Trope: How diction and imagery erase Native contemporary existence
- Library Classification Systems and Structural Marginalization: Dewey Decimal system marginalizes Native American knowledge
- Conclusion: Systemic bias harms all students, especially Native children
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Uses specific textual evidence from each book — diction, character depictions, and illustrations — to ground abstract claims about bias in concrete examples.
- Escalates effectively from individual texts to a systemic argument, showing that library classification structures reinforce the same stereotypes found in the books themselves.
- Employs comparative reasoning (e.g., noting it would be "politically incorrect" to depict African Americans the same way) to highlight the double standard applied to Native Americans.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates critical discourse analysis applied to educational materials: it isolates specific language choices (words like "roaming," "wandering," and "redskin"), visual descriptions, and narrative structures, then explains how each choice reproduces a broader ideological framework that dehumanizes Native peoples and erases their contemporary existence.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a contextual overview of how Native Americans are treated across K–12 curricula, then proceeds book by book through close textual analysis. It concludes by widening the lens to the Dewey Decimal system, arguing that institutional library organization perpetuates the same erasure. This movement from individual texts to institutional structures gives the paper a coherent argumentative arc.
Introduction: Native Americans in Educational Materials
Many artifacts used in K–12 curricula illustrate a racial bias against marginalized groups. Native Americans are one such group adversely affected by stereotypical and offensive portrayals in educational materials and literature. American Indians are typically not mentioned in American history textbooks beyond the 6th grade. When they are referenced, it is most often in the context of Pilgrims and Thanksgiving. At other times they are depicted as adversaries to be defeated in the "settling" of the West. Based on what most Americans have been taught, Native Americans virtually ceased to exist after 1890.
In addition, a pervasive and subtle dehumanizing stereotype of Native Americans has become ingrained in American popular culture — evident in sports team mascots, Halloween costumes, and similar imagery. These misrepresentations, and the misperceptions that follow, are commonly held by all Americans and have the power to impact Native American children themselves.
References
Banks, L.R. (2005). The Indian in the cupboard. New York: Random House/Listening Library.
Olson, H.A. (2001). Classification or organization: What's the difference? Knowledge Organization, 28(1), 1–3.
Phillips, W.S. (1963). Indian campfire tales: Legends about the ways of animals and men. New York: Platt & Munk.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.