This paper reviews Mary E. Odem's Delinquent Daughters: Protecting and Policing Adolescent Female Sexuality in the United States, 1885–1920, analyzing its central thesis and key themes. Odem examines two distinct historical periods: the 1880s, when young women were seen as victims of predatory older men, and the post-1900 decades, when reformers reframed adolescent girls as "delinquents" requiring moral policing. The review explores Odem's treatment of the purity movement, age-of-consent legislation, racial and class biases among reformers, judicial hostility toward reform efforts, and families' use of the court system to manage daughters' behavior. The paper also assesses the strength of Odem's research methodology, including her use of court records, primary sources, and statistical appendices.
The paper demonstrates effective use of textual evidence in a book review context. Rather than merely summarizing chapters, the writer selects specific passages and page citations to support evaluative claims about Odem's thesis, methodology, and argument structure. This technique — quoting, contextualizing, and then interpreting — is a core skill in humanities writing at the undergraduate level.
The review opens by identifying Odem's thesis and the book's two-part historical structure. It then moves thematically through major arguments: the purity movement and age-of-consent legislation, the courts' failure to uphold reform goals, and families' use of the courts against their own daughters. The final sections evaluate Odem's research methodology and conclude with a judgment of the book's value and broader significance. This thesis-first, theme-by-theme, evaluation-last structure is standard for academic book reviews.
This paper analyzes Mary E. Odem's Delinquent Daughters: Protecting and Policing Adolescent Female Sexuality in the United States, 1885–1920, including the author's thesis and key themes. In this book, Odem studies the sexuality laws designed to protect young women in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, along with the reformers who worked to ensure those laws were upheld in court. She writes, "This book explores both the moral reform campaigns that produced new policies of sexual regulation and the actual enforcement of those policies at the local court level" (Odem 2). This statement serves as her central thesis and the underlying thread that ties the entire book together.
The book is broken into two key periods: the 1880s, when society believed young women were morally corrupted by older men, and the two decades following the turn of the century, when reformers believed a new type of delinquent young woman had emerged — one who needed to be policed not from predators, but from her own decadent desires. The first period viewed young women as nothing more than victims of sexual predators; one reaction was to raise the age of consent, in an attempt to hold more men accountable for preying on young women. The second period viewed young women as more willing participants in sexual activity — as "delinquents" who needed to be managed by the court system. Using actual cases she researched, Odem provides numerous examples of both framings, which bring the book to life for the reader.
Odem uses several key themes to examine the sexuality and mores of the era and how those mores affected young women. The book focuses on the court system, the girls and their families, and the reformers who worked to monitor adolescent girls and their sexual activity. Her first major argument concerns older male predators luring young girls into so-called "white slavery." This framing dominated the first period of reform, casting young women as innocent victims in need of legal protection from unscrupulous men.
Another key theme is her argument that the moral campaigns created to manage female sexuality were rooted in a variety of social constructs. She writes, "First, moral campaigns to control teenage female sexuality were fueled by gender, class, and racial tensions in American society" (Odem 4). Odem maintains that middle-class white women were at the forefront of this reform movement and that they consistently ignored the plight of other women — notably Black women — in their quest for laws governing the actions of men who preyed on young women.
In the first reform movements in California during the 1880s, Odem notes that reformers sought to raise the age of consent from 10 to 18, following a national trend to protect young girls from "vicious men." It is notable that male legislators resisted the reformers for several years and initially raised the age of consent only to 14 (Odem 9). This resistance is especially striking given the strict moral climate of the time. Today, with the age of consent at 18, the idea of legally permitting sexual relations with girls as young as 10 or 14 seems almost unthinkable — and yet the laws of that era allowed it. There is an apparent juxtaposition in the fact that the more morally permissive society of today maintains a higher age of consent than the ostensibly strict Victorian era. Nevertheless, the reformers ultimately succeeded in raising the limit, and the result endures.
This quest for morality legislation stemmed from a broader purity movement gaining strength across the nation. The movement sought to ban prostitution, supported temperance, and worked increasingly to create laws protecting women from sexual predators and abuse. Reformers also sought to transform how men thought about sex and sexual relationships, aiming to make those relationships more equal and moral. However, their concerns largely did not extend to Black women and other minorities — their focus remained on white women who might be lured into "white slavery" by unscrupulous men. The reformers achieved considerable success: by 1920, they had raised the age of consent to 16 or 18 in nearly every state and had established numerous halfway houses and other refuges for young women endangered by or recovering from sexual abuse (Odem 37).
In conclusion, this is a fascinating look into the sexual mores of Victorian America, and how society policed those mores throughout its institutions. The author shows how young women of the time were changing, creating new responsibilities for themselves, and becoming more modern and open, at a time when their parents simply wanted to control them and their activities. Young women were moving out of the domestic sphere, forging new lives, and consorting with men — and this frightened conservative society. The response was to create and enforce strict laws governing sexuality in an explicitly moral framework.
This book belongs on the shelf of anyone interested in women's history, sociology, or criminal justice. It reveals the ways in which morals and society were transforming at the turn of the century, and how, even amid reform efforts, white middle-class women maintained clear cultural dominance over minorities — including in the courts and in the domain of sexual conduct. The book is a compelling look at a society on the brink of changing values and ideals, and at the real power men held over women during this period — power that reformers were determined, if only partially successful, to dismantle.
In many ways, the young women Odem portrays are not so different from those of any generation. They were searching for identity, attempting to assert themselves, and seeking to break free from the constraints of the past. Each generation challenges its parents' ideals to some degree, and these young women — caught between the Victorian and Progressive eras — were no exception. The author portrays her subjects and their court cases with detail and measured interpretive insight, helping readers understand the nature of sexual reform in America and how, increasingly, women became the targets of moral judgment in the very legal system that was ostensibly created to protect them. It is a look back at a period when relatively little scholarship had examined the juvenile court system and women's experience within it — and it remains, by turns, fascinating, troubling, and revelatory.
Odem, Mary E. Delinquent Daughters: Protecting and Policing Adolescent Female Sexuality in the United States, 1885–1920. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 1995.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.