This essay analyzes Sophocles' Oedipus Rex through the lens of free will versus fate, arguing that Oedipus is ultimately responsible for his own destruction. Rather than being a passive victim of divine prophecy, Oedipus actively brings about his downfall through arrogance, obsessive determination, and a refusal to heed the warnings of Teiresias, Iocaste, Creon, and the chorus. Drawing on Robert Fagles's commentary, the essay traces each critical decision Oedipus makes — from dismissing Teiresias's counsel to ignoring Iocaste's pleas — demonstrating that his self-inflicted catastrophe reflects the triumph of human will over fate.
The paper demonstrates close reading by moving sequentially through key scenes — Teiresias, Creon, Iocaste — and analyzing how each exchange reveals a specific character flaw in Oedipus. Rather than summarizing the plot, the writer extracts textual evidence at each stage to build a cumulative argument about the relationship between free will and fate.
The essay opens with a framing argument that challenges a common interpretation (fate as deterministic), then advances scene by scene through Oedipus's encounters with Teiresias, Creon, and Iocaste. Each section adds a new dimension to the central claim. The conclusion synthesizes the argument using Fagles and arrives at a nuanced position: Oedipus could not have changed the prophecy's content, but he could have made better choices along the way.
In Sophocles' play Oedipus Rex, Oedipus takes fate into his own hands and demonstrates the power of the human will. The play illustrates how we may not always be in control of our destinies, regardless of our efforts. It is ironic in this sense because Oedipus already had the best "fate" any man in his position could hope for — a beautiful, loving wife and a community that praised him. Some argue that Oedipus was fated to fulfill the prophecy, but the truth is that his very actions destroyed the life he had. Oedipus was strong-willed, obsessive, and arrogant to the point of making catastrophic mistakes. He failed himself and those around him because he thought he knew best.
In the beginning of the play, Oedipus has the best of intentions — he does not set out to destroy his life. He simply wants to know the truth, and for most people in most circumstances, that is not a bad thing. However, Oedipus does not stop to think about the unintended consequences of his actions because he cannot think straight. The complicated fact is that he cannot uncover the mystery of Laios' murder without revealing the truth about who he is and what he has done. Things get complicated quickly, and it begins with what the gods knew and what they predicted. The gods knew Oedipus's fate and predicted it, but this is all they did. They did not make him do anything and were not in control of his actions. Oedipus controlled his own actions, and while the gods knew what would transpire, they could not prevent any of it from occurring.
Oedipus wants to be in charge of his own destiny. He is headstrong, and his first mistake is becoming arrogant. He grows indignant after Teiresias tries to talk sense to him and urges him to be cautious. Teiresias tells Oedipus to carry his own fate (I.i.105), but Oedipus dismisses this advice because he is fixated on what he does not yet know. He thinks he knows best and refuses to leave the nagging question alone. Instead of following Teiresias's advice, he calls him a "wicked old man" (I.i.118) with "no feeling at all" (I.i.119). He also blames Teiresias for Laios' murder.
It is easy to see how angry Oedipus becomes when people do not see things his way. The sad truth is that even as he hears the truth, he will not stop long enough to consider it or reflect on what it might mean. As Teiresias tells him plainly, "You yourself are the pollution of this country" (I.i.135), practically spelling out the truth when he adds, "You are the murderer whom you seek" (I.i.143) and "You live in hideous shame with those / Most dear to you. You cannot see the evil" (I.i.148–9). Oedipus acts as though he never heard these words. He does not act on them; he does not believe them. His arrogance makes him certain he knows better than this old man.
You’re 40% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.