This essay compares Duke Orsino and Countess Olivia in Shakespeare's Twelfth Night, arguing that both characters are ultimately in love with the idea of being in love rather than with real people. Drawing on textual evidence and the 1996 Trevor Nunn film adaptation, the paper examines how Orsino's theatrical melancholy and Olivia's performative mourning reveal parallel emotional immaturity. The essay further notes that the play's resolution — in which both characters settle for substitutes — underscores the shallowness of their original passions and forms a key part of the play's satirical critique of romantic self-indulgence.
Both Duke Orsino and the Countess Olivia in Shakespeare's Twelfth Night are victims of unrequited love for the duration of most of the play. Orsino begins the story besotted with Olivia, a noblewoman who has refused to marry because she is still mourning her brother. Yet a closer look at both characters reveals that neither is truly in love — each is, instead, in love with the idea of being in love.
Orsino seems less genuinely in love than captivated by the romantic pose itself. He plays melancholy music constantly and sends love letters to Olivia, but he never engages with her face to face. Being in love with a woman who cannot love him back appears to satisfy his self-image rather than any real need for companionship.
The first glimpse the audience has of Orsino is as he strides in, declaring: "If music be the food of love, play on; / Give me excess of it, that, surfeiting, / The appetite may sicken, and so die" (I.1). Later, he asks the fool Feste to play a song containing the lyric: "I am slain by a fair cruel maid" (II.4). Orsino speaks extravagantly of love one moment — telling Viola, disguised as his servant Cesario: "Our fancies are more giddy and unfirm, / More longing, wavering, sooner lost and worn, / Than women's are" — and then contradicts himself just as passionately in the next breath: "There is no woman's sides / Can bide the beating of so strong a passion / As love doth give my heart" (II.4). These self-contradictions expose the performative nature of his passion.
Initially, Olivia appears a far more serious character. She is described as grief-stricken over her father's and brother's deaths: "For whose dear love, / They say, she hath abjured the company / And sight of men" (I.2). However, when the audience actually encounters Olivia, the impression is quite different. Her mourning is just as theatrical as Orsino's love-making from afar. She dresses herself in sumptuous black clothing yet remains fully capable of engaging in witty banter with Feste, who mocks her pretensions of grief just as freely as he mocks Orsino's belief in his own hopeless devotion. As Feste quips: "The more fool, madonna, to mourn for your brother's soul being in heaven. Take away the fool, gentlemen" (I.5).
It is Viola who identifies Olivia's central flaw: "I see you what you are, you are too proud" (I.5). Olivia knows she is beautiful, and she wishes to shield that beauty from the world — an impulse rooted in vanity rather than sorrow.
"Olivia falls for an image, not reality"
"Both settle for substitutes, exposing shallow passion"
You’re 55% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.