This essay examines Edgar Allan Poe's use of the Decadent literary style in "The Fall of the House of Usher," tracing how the story's imagery, diction, atmosphere, and symbolism collectively portray the inevitable decline of an aristocratic line. Beginning with a close reading of the story's opening paragraph, the essay analyzes how Poe establishes gloom, isolation, and decay through sentence rhythm, descriptive language, and personification. It then traces the progression of mental and physical deterioration through the characters of Roderick and his sister, the merging of reality and the supernatural, and the symbolic significance of the collapsing house as an emblem of a dying social order.
The paper demonstrates close reading as a primary analytical method. Rather than summarizing plot, it slows down at key passages — particularly the story's first paragraph — to examine diction, sentence rhythm, and imagery at the word level, then connects those micro-level observations to macro-level thematic arguments about decadence and historical decline.
The essay opens by situating Poe within 19th-century Decadent and Gothic literary traditions. It then performs a sustained close reading of the story's opening paragraph before expanding to discuss character psychology, the reality/supernatural tension, and the dual symbolism of life and death. The conclusion zooms out to interpret the story's ending as a commentary on the passing of the aristocratic order, with the narrator representing a new, post-aristocratic world.
Decadent writing during the 19th century took several forms. At its basis was the increasing decadence of society, along with the decay of the feudal system, the hold of the Church, and the power of those associated with these institutions. Gothic literature therefore lent itself with particular poignancy to the depiction of declining values and institutions of this period. Edgar Allan Poe frequently treated in his Gothic works the themes of royal decadence and decline, with their concomitant mental and physical decay. While he also worked in other genres such as poetry and detective fiction, Poe's engagement with the Decadent style was most evident in the fiction today classified within the horror genre. "The Fall of the House of Usher" is a prime example of such a work.
The elements, images, and themes in this well-constructed story all conspire to depict Poe's central image of decay and decadence. When the first paragraph of "The Fall of the House of Usher" is examined, it is filled with linguistic and symbolic imagery. None of this imagery bodes well for the narrator. Everything is focused upon decay and degradation, spelling little hope for the occupants inside or for the narrator as a visiting and potentially helpful friend. Even the weather contributes to the gloom of the scene, as is evident from the opening sentence of the story:
"During the whole of a dull, dark, and soundless day in the autumn of the year, when the clouds hung oppressively low in the heavens, I had been passing alone, on horseback, through a singularly dreary tract of country; and at length found myself, as the shades of the evening drew on, within view of the melancholy House of Usher." (Poe, par. 1)
Another element of decadence that becomes clear in this sentence is the sense of isolation. The narrator travels alone. Despite the gloom and the approaching evening, there is not so much a sense of immediate danger as there is one of future, impending doom. This atmosphere is accomplished by the rhythm of the narration. The most obvious rhythmic element is the sentence length. The long sentence provides a large amount of information pertaining to atmosphere rather than action. The only indication of movement in the sentence is the narrator's horse. The pace is slowed considerably through descriptive elements, as well as expressions such as "at length" and "dreary." These words visually and aurally slow the pace of movement through the countryside. The visual length of the sentence does the same thing; the narrator engages a number of the reader's senses to portray a sense of not only loneliness, but also of slow travel, physical exhaustion, and emotional depression. The sentence furthermore visualizes the end of the journey by concluding with the name of the narrator's destination: the House of Usher. The reader can almost hear the dark tolling of large bells when reading the name of the House.
The emotion depicted by the opening sentence is emphasized by the gloomy tone of the description. Words to this effect include "dull, dark," "oppressively," and "melancholy." These words convey in no uncertain terms the emotions inspired by the scene and furthermore predict the state of the occupants in the House of Usher. Interestingly, the narrator reveals only slightly later that "the House of Usher" is a phrase used to refer both to the building itself and to the Usher family that occupies it. The only remaining members of the long Usher line are a brother and sister, both of whom have fallen ill and are declining at a steady pace. This human decline is predicted by the decay of the house that the narrator describes even before seeing the shocking state of his friend, the brother.
When continuing with the description in his first paragraph, the narrator offers his audience no relief from the stark surroundings of his destination, nor does he experience any relief himself. He emphasizes the unusual gloominess with a comparison: "the feeling was unrelieved by any of that half-pleasurable, because poetic, sentiment, with which the mind usually receives even the sternest natural images of the desolate or terrible" (Poe, par. 1).
Regardless of the narrator's efforts to relieve the gloomy vision of the house by changing his viewing angle, the gloom persists stubbornly. So extreme is it that the narrator uses progressive extremes in comparison and diction to describe it. He suffers, for example, an "utter depression of soul," progressing beyond the mere physical and mental depression of the long journey and gloomy surroundings. Every single natural element surrounding the House of Usher — including shrubs and trees — contributes to the gloom rather than relieving it.
Interestingly, the narrator compares the progressive depression of his soul to a return from an opium-induced revelry. This reference is itself a particularly significant element of the Decadent style: the use of mind-altering substances. The surroundings of the House of Usher therefore act as the grim reality of a specifically oppressive existence, from which escape might be sought by means of substances such as opium.
These initial images of mental states that alternate between revelry and extreme gloom serve to foreshadow both the physical and mental state of the house's occupant. Later in the narration, it is revealed that Roderick Usher had summoned the narrator with a letter describing his suffering from a malady affecting both his senses and his psychology. The narrator has been summoned to provide assistance in the form of friendship and companionship. In light of later events, this summons can therefore be seen as a desperate and final attempt to relieve the constant mental anguish of inevitable decay and approaching death. The narrator can even be regarded as a kind of "opium" to help Roderick escape, even if only temporarily, from his suffering.
So extreme is the surrounding gloom that the narrator uses progressive extremes in comparison and diction. He describes, for example: "There was an iciness, a sinking, a sickening of the heart — an unredeemed dreariness of thought which no goading of the imagination could torture into aught of the sublime." (Poe, par. 1). In this sentence, there is a strong ambiguity in the word "torture" that denotes the extreme negativity the narrator is experiencing. The progression of gloom — demonstrated by diction such as "iciness," "sinking," and "sickening of the heart" — is so powerful that not even torture could coerce the imagination into finding even an inkling of the positive "sublime," or any memory of relief from the utter gloom of the landscape and house.
In the second part of the paragraph, it is as if the narrator suddenly experiences a reawakening, a sense of sudden questioning. He pauses and reconsiders his perception of the House of Usher. It is here that the separation between reality and the extreme gloom around him attempts to reassert itself through doubt. Rationality leads the narrator to attempt to change the scene, which ultimately fails. He is forced to return to his former conclusion: that a supernatural gloom has inserted itself into simple objects of landscape and building to create a perpetual doom that is inescapable.
You’re 57% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.