The Problem of Evil, Suffering, and the Design Argument
This paper examines two interrelated philosophical problems: the logical problem of evil and the argument from design. Drawing on David Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion and John Hick's soul-making theodicy, the paper explores whether the existence of suffering is compatible with an omnipotent, all-good God. It evaluates Philo's challenge to Cleanthes' design analogy, critiques Hick's claim that suffering promotes spiritual growth, and considers whether a theodicy remains tenable. The paper concludes by briefly engaging Wittgenstein's framework as a possible resolution and assessing the limits of comparing the universe to a machine designed by an intelligent mind.
- The Logical Problem of Evil: God's omnipotence and goodness conflict with evil's existence
- Hick's Soul-Making Theodicy: Suffering enables spiritual growth and moral development
- Challenges to the Soul-Making Argument: Animal, infant, and unequal suffering undermine Hick's theodicy
- Can a Theodicy Still Stand?: God's incomprehensibility may resolve the contradiction
- The Design Argument: Universe's order compared to a machine implies a designer
- Philo's Critique of the Design Analogy: Universe-machine analogy is logically and ontologically flawed
- Conclusion: Human language limits but does not invalidate theological discourse
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It uses primary philosophical sources — Hume's Dialogues and Hick's Evil and the God of Love — to ground its arguments, giving the analysis both textual authority and critical depth.
- The paper moves logically from problem to proposed solution to rebuttal, demonstrating genuine engagement with counterarguments rather than simply restating positions.
- Direct quotation is used sparingly but purposefully, with Hick's and Hume's own words introduced at moments where they carry maximum argumentative weight.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper exemplifies philosophical dialectic: it sets out a thesis (God and evil cannot coexist), introduces a counter-thesis (Hick's soul-making), systematically critiques that counter-thesis with specific cases (animal suffering, infant suffering, unequal distribution of hardship), and then proposes a qualified resolution through the idea that God is beyond human comprehension. This structure mirrors standard analytic philosophy methodology.
Structure breakdown
The paper divides into two broad movements. The first addresses the problem of evil — presenting Hume/Philo's challenge, Hick's response, objections to Hick, and a possible theodicy. The second addresses the design argument — presenting Cleanthes' analogy, Philo's refutation, and a brief defense of using the term "mind" when describing God. Together the two movements reinforce a coherent skeptical-yet-open stance toward theistic claims.
The Logical Problem of Evil
The logical problem of evil holds that if God is all-good, then evil should not exist. One might argue that evil is a creation of man and that God cannot prevent it — yet God, being omnipotent and therefore by definition capable of accomplishing all things, should be able to prevent, if not destroy, evil. Either God is not all-good, or He is not all-powerful. Alternatively, some other reason must exist to explain the coexistence of God and evil.
As David Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion vividly expresses through the character of Philo:
"The whole earth is cursed and polluted. A perpetual war is kindled amongst all living creatures. Necessity, hunger, want stimulate the strong and courageous; fear, anxiety, terror agitate the weak and infirm. The first entrance into life gives anguish to the newborn infant and to its wretched parent; weakness, impotence, distress attend each stage of that life, and it is at last finished in agony and horror." (Hume, 2006, p. 55)
If the world had an omnipotent and compassionate God ruling it, the very existence of evil implies a contradiction. God must be either omnipotent or compassionate, or suffering must not exist. Cleanthes considers the universe to be harmonious and structured, but a brief glimpse at the world reveals it to be a place filled with misery and evil.
The universe, as Philo elaborates, is a machine in which each creature fights for survival — a race for life determined, as Darwin would put it, by the survival of the fittest. Here, happiness is not the goal; rather, there is a ceaseless struggle of ecosystem against ecosystem. Given the amount of misery that exists in the world, it is difficult to conclude that an infinitely wise, powerful, and compassionate God controls it. The design of the universe suggests otherwise. At best, we can deduce that God is morally neutral.
References
Hick, J. Evil and the God of Love. New York: Harper and Row, 1977.
Hume, D. Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion. London: SCM Press, 2006.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.