Queue Jumping Study Review: Social Identity and Line Cutting
This paper reviews a field study conducted in Melbourne, Australia, examining reactions to queue jumping in petrol station lines. Forty-nine drivers — split nearly evenly by gender — had their place in line cut by either a luxury or non-luxury vehicle, and their responses were measured on a 28-point offense scale. Drawing on social identity theory as developed by Tajfel and Turner, the review analyzes the study's methodology, results, and discussion. The findings indicate that luxury car intrusions provoked modestly higher offense scores than non-luxury intrusions, though the gap was narrower than expected. The review also identifies key limitations not addressed in the original study, including queue position, line length, and broader socioeconomic context.
- Introduction: Defines queue jumping, social identity theory, and study rationale
- Methods: Describes experimental design, participants, and procedure
- Results: Interprets the mean and standard deviation data table
- Discussion: Evaluates findings, limitations, and social context factors
- Conclusion: Reflects on study relevance and future research directions
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper grounds its analysis in a clearly defined theoretical framework — social identity theory — and consistently returns to it when interpreting study results.
- The author honestly acknowledges both the strengths and limitations of the original study, providing a balanced critical review rather than simple summary.
- Statistical results from the appendix table are integrated into the discussion in plain language, making the numerical findings accessible without oversimplifying them.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates critical synthesis: the author does not merely summarize the study but situates it within broader social psychology literature (Milgram et al., Thoits & Virshup), identifies gaps in the original research design, and suggests meaningful directions for future inquiry. This approach distinguishes a review paper from a simple report.
Structure breakdown
The paper follows a standard IMRaD-adjacent structure: an abstract overview, a conceptual introduction defining queue jumping and social identity theory, a methods section describing experimental design, a results section interpreting the data table, a discussion section weighing findings against limitations and broader social context, and a conclusion that reflects on the study's relevance and possible extensions. References and a data appendix round out the document.
Introduction
There are a few terms and concepts that must be defined before reviewing the details of this study. First, queue jumping is exactly what it sounds like: a person new to a line — or queue — of people who inserts themselves anywhere other than at the very end of that line. A reaction to queue jumping can range from a dirty look or muttered pejorative to outright confrontation, whether verbal or physical, directed at the queue jumper (Milgram, Liberty, Toledo & Wackenhut, 1986).
Social identity theory is the idea that a person's sense of self is defined and shaped by membership in a larger social group. This concept was originally constructed and advanced by Henri Tajfel and John Turner (Thoits & Virshup, 1997). The definition is appropriate in the context of this review. The work that offered this definition drew a clear distinction between self-definition and that of the larger social group to which a person belongs. To suggest that all people who identify with a certain wider social identity will personally behave identically is overly simplistic. That said, there are commonly held rules and expectations that people in a society generally follow — and expect others to follow — and not cutting in line is certainly one of them (Thoits & Virshup, 1997).
The cited literature also points to notable similarities, rather than stark differences, between role-based identity and broader social identity. Both frameworks agree that social roles are integral to broader social identities. However, role-based identity places less emphasis on negotiations about proper behavior, and individual free will is also de-emphasized in role-based identity models such as those offered by Stryker (Thoits & Virshup, 1997).
The Deakin study was conceptually solid, but the range of reactions between luxury and non-luxury car conditions was fairly narrow. This speaks to the possibility that the price point of the cutting car may not be as influential as initially assumed — though a statistically significant difference was still observed. Someone reacting negatively to a luxury car cutting into a petrol queue may be indignant about the loss of time or money rather than specifically because the car is a luxury model. They might react in much the same way — or at least similarly — if a non-luxury car did the same thing. Even so, the luxury versus non-luxury comparison is important because there was a genuine question about whether the price point of the cutting car matters, and it does appear to matter to some degree, though it is far from the only aggravating factor for those who are cut in front of.
The study did a good job of laying out commonly held assumptions and had a clearly defined aim: to determine whether there is a distinction between a non-luxury car jumping a queue and a luxury car doing the same. That was the core comparison being made. As noted above, other dimensions can matter, but this study appropriately kept its scope narrow. The wide variation in survey responses demonstrated that there was credence to the theoretical distinction between the type of car doing the queue jumping.
The study also highlights that the prestige of the car is not the only potential aggravating factor for victims of queue jumping. Loss of money or time is not always the primary motivator, since people positioned in front of a queue jumper — who stand to lose nothing in terms of time or money — were often willing and able to voice their displeasure. A prediction was clearly stated and confirmed, yet it is also evident that since responses were quite high on the 28-point scale even for non-luxury cars, the overall level of indignation was considerable regardless of vehicle type.
Methods
As noted in the abstract, nearly 50 participants had their place in line compromised. Every one of those participants was driving a non-luxury car, with the clear intent being that the luxury car represented someone more financially well-off than the person being cut in front of. A separate group of just under 50 individuals jumped the queue, with a nearly identical gender split between the two groups. The people whose place in line was taken were presumably unaware at first that they were being observed and analyzed — a necessary condition for obtaining genuine responses rather than behavior shaped by awareness of being watched (Milgram, Liberty, Toledo & Wackenhut, 1986).
To elaborate on the design: there was a roughly equal gender split among both the queue jumpers and the people being cut in front of, as well as an even split between luxury and non-luxury cutting vehicles. All participants subject to cutting were administered the same 28-point survey, and results were averaged both within individual groups and collectively to determine whether a meaningful variation existed between the two experimental conditions.
The decision to balance the number of male and female participants and to use an equal number of luxury and non-luxury cars was methodologically sound. Skewing too heavily in either direction would have undermined the validity of the comparisons. There are plausible variations attributable to both factors, and the procedure used could readily be replicated. However, the severity and variation of responses would likely differ in favorable economic conditions compared to periods of scarcity, such as the global economic downturn that ran from 2007 to 2009.
Conclusion
Even given the age of this study, and with the evidence clearly showing that something as simple as a queue can reflect social structure and stability — or its absence — this study serves as a reminder of how complex even simple social phenomena can be. A replication of this research today would probably not be warranted unless it focused on the gender, age, or other social characteristics of the queue jumper, or examined situations in which the queue jumper did not immediately leave upon being identified. Exploring those variables in greater depth would almost certainly be worthwhile, though making clear and confident predictions about such outcomes would be difficult to achieve.
References
BBC. (2012, March 28). Filling station queues over fuel strike concerns. BBC News. Retrieved April 28, 2013, from http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-17543909
BBC. (2012, March 29). Fuel strike threat: 'Panic buying' at petrol stations. BBC News. Retrieved April 28, 2013, from http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-17553696
Helwig-Larsen, M., & LoMonaco, B. L. (2008). Queueing among U2 fans: Reactions to social norm violations. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 38(9), 2378–2393.
Lysiak, M. (2012, November 3). Hurricane Sandy leaves frenzy for gas, though help on way. NY Daily News. Retrieved April 29, 2013, from http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/hurricane-sandy-leaves-frenzy-gas-article-1.1196282
Milgram, S., Liberty, H. J., Toledo, R., & Wackenhut, J. (1986). Response to intrusion into waiting lines. Journal of Personality & Social Psychology, 51(4), 683–689.
Thoits, P., & Virshup, L. (1997). Me's and we's: Forms and functions of social identities. Rutgers Series on Self & Social Identity, 1, 106–133.
Appendix I — Table I — Affective Reactions of Drivers to Queue Jumping
Condition | N | M | SD
Luxury | 24 | 25.7083 | 2.09511
Non-Luxury | 25 | 23.6000 | 2.14870
Total | 49 | 24.6327 | 2.35160
Notes: p < 0.05 compared to Luxury Condition. Abbreviations: N = Number of study participants; M = Mean; SD = Standard Deviation.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.