This reflection paper examines a personal salary negotiation experience in which the author, a top-performing telephone sales representative, requested a 10% pay raise from his supervisor. Despite thorough preparation and a respectful exchange, the negotiation failed to produce the desired outcome. The author left the company for a new position, only to realize he had acted too hastily and missed a better long-term opportunity. The paper identifies key negotiation failures — including emotional reactivity, lack of patience, and neglecting the other party's perspective — and draws lessons about the importance of emotional control, clear objectives, and sustained professional conduct during workplace negotiations.
Throughout my life I have been involved in many negotiations and discussions spanning a wide variety of experiences. One consistent principle that applied to all of them was the ability to communicate effectively within a negotiation. Successful use of negotiation techniques has mostly proven advantageous in my past situations. In some instances, however, I was unaware of my poor negotiation skills and later regretted my actions and behavior. The purpose of this essay is to highlight one such negotiation — one in which I failed to demonstrate the appropriate attitudes and behaviors needed to reach a successful outcome.
Most people in today's society must work in order to provide the resources necessary to sustain their lives. Negotiation is a skill that appears across virtually every professional context, from entry-level positions to executive suites. Education is very helpful in developing people toward their ultimate academic and professional goals, but schooling comes at a cost. To fund my education, I took a job as a telephone sales representative for a supply company. My negotiation skills were developed and practiced on a daily basis in that role, giving me a solid foundation in the knowledge and special traits required to be a successful salesperson. I became one of the top salespeople in my group, a reliable member of the team, and eventually took on a leadership role — demonstrating and teaching others certain techniques that helped generate new sales and profits. By excelling at work, I soon encountered new types of negotiations in which more seasoned and professional tactics were at play.
I eventually realized that I was earning the same amount as the rest of my colleagues, despite being responsible for a disproportionate share of the company's profits. I began to consider whether I should ask for a raise. I was confident in my abilities and believed my skills could transfer successfully to another employer — one that might pay me more. At the same time, I genuinely enjoyed my job, my coworkers, and even my boss. Still, I felt it was fundamentally unfair that I was not being compensated more for the work I was producing.
The first step in any negotiation is gathering as much knowledge and information as possible before entering the discussion. After careful consideration, I decided to ask for a 10% pay raise, which I believed fairly reflected my contribution to the company. I researched salary data and confirmed that someone in my position and geographic area was typically earning more than I was. With that information in hand, I decided the time was right to approach my supervisor.
"Respectful but emotionally charged pay raise discussion"
"Accepting a new job after the raise was deferred"
"Reflecting on patience, emotions, and better negotiation tactics"
You’re 39% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.