Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 2,691 words

Shoah (1985) by Claude Lanzmann: Documentary Film Review

~14 min read 6 sections Arts · Film Review
Abstract

This paper reviews Claude Lanzmann's landmark 1985 documentary Shoah, a nine-and-a-half-hour film about the Holocaust that deliberately avoids archival footage and reenactments in favor of firsthand testimony. The review examines Lanzmann's interview methodology across three categories of subjects — survivors, bystanders, and perpetrators — and the four primary locations the film revisits: Chełmno, Treblinka, Auschwitz-Birkenau, and the Warsaw Ghetto. It addresses the documentary's ethical controversies, including the use of hidden cameras and accusations of selective editing, while also evaluating its lasting power as both a historical document and a work of cinema.

Key Takeaways
  • Introduction: A Documentary Without Archive Footage: Lanzmann's choice to use testimony over archival footage
  • Three Categories of Witnesses and Four Key Sites: Survivors, bystanders, and perpetrators at key locations
  • Cinematic Techniques and Emotional Impact: Close-ups, pacing, and the power of firsthand testimony
  • Ethical Controversies and Objectivity: Hidden cameras, selective editing, and bias claims
  • Historical Significance and Lasting Legacy: Shoah as historical document and cultural milestone
  • Conclusion: Memory, Humanity, and the Purpose of Shoah: The film's enduring message about remembrance and human cruelty
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • The review balances genuine admiration for the film's emotional power with honest criticism of Lanzmann's ethical choices, such as his use of hidden cameras and selective editing, giving the analysis credibility.
  • Specific testimonies — Simon Strebnik, Abraham Bomba, Rudolf Vrba, and Franz Suchomel — are cited to ground abstract claims about the documentary's impact in concrete examples.
  • The paper consistently connects formal choices (no archival footage, close-up shots, non-linear narration) to their intended effect on the audience, demonstrating media literacy.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper demonstrates evaluative analysis of a primary text — the film itself — by assessing both its cinematic form and its function as a historical document. The student distinguishes between what the film does aesthetically (allowing viewers to construct mental images) and what it achieves historically (preserving firsthand testimony before the last survivors die), showing awareness that a single work can be judged by multiple standards.

Structure breakdown

The review opens with context about the film's unusual approach, then surveys the key witnesses and locations covered. It moves into analysis of cinematic technique and emotional effect, addresses ethical criticisms, and broadens to consider the film's historical and humanistic legacy. A reflective conclusion ties memory, human cruelty, and the imperative to remember into a closing argument about the film's enduring purpose.

Essay 2,691 words

Introduction: A Documentary Without Archive Footage

French filmmaker and professor of documentary Claude Lanzmann astonished audiences with his nine-and-a-half-hour documentary Shoah. The word shoah — or Ha Shoah — literally denotes a catastrophic upheaval and is the Hebrew term for the Holocaust. Lanzmann completed the documentary in 1985, and in it he chose to work exclusively with real people who were involved in different ways in the Holocaust, taking viewers to the very places those people discuss.

Shoah consists of many hours of interviews with three categories of subjects: survivors, witnesses, and perpetrators. In order to depict historical reality, Lanzmann brings survivors back to the places where their stories unfolded, forcing them to confront the sites where the terror took place. The documentary film medium thus conveys the historical reality of the Holocaust through people who lived it — history told by those who survived, witnessed, or directly participated in its execution.

For Claude Lanzmann, the historical reality of the Holocaust means the people who outlived it and the places where it occurred. The visual backdrop to the interviews consists mostly of talking heads accompanied by footage of abandoned sites where atrocities took place. The overall effect is deeply revealing. Lanzmann was certain that reusing the dark photographs and film clips audiences already knew would no longer carry sufficient force; he needed to be original. Bringing real survivors into his film to speak about the reality of the Holocaust was far more powerful than any archival footage. He placed people face-to-face with the "demon" — in direct contact with individuals who had experienced the terror firsthand.

Three Categories of Witnesses and Four Key Sites

There are four places that particularly concerned the director: Chełmno, Treblinka, Auschwitz-Birkenau, and the Warsaw Ghetto.

The documentary opens with the testimony of Simon Strebnik, speaking about Chełmno. The man says, "I can't believe I am here." As he walks the grounds that once served as his prison and recalls the details of the camp, one can only imagine the impact that his ordeal had on his psyche. Simon was forced to sing military songs to entertain the Nazis.

Abraham Bomba was a barber who survived the death camps of Treblinka. He told the horrifying story of how he shaved the heads of his wife, his best friend, and his best friend's wife before they were taken to be gassed.

The testimonies concerning Auschwitz are given by Rudolf Vrba, who escaped from the camp before the end of the war; Muller, who worked in an incinerator burning the bodies of those killed in the gassings; and Richard Glazer. Muller describes the terror of being forced into the gas chambers himself.

At the end of the film, details about the Warsaw Ghetto emerge from a man who worked for the Polish government-in-exile and from a Nazi administrator. The Warsaw Uprising concludes the documentary.

Among the perpetrators, Lanzmann obtains a rare interview with SS officer Franz Suchomel, who provides valuable details about the camp's gas chambers. This interview, like the one with Nazi guard Franz Schalling, was filmed with a hidden camera.

From the bystanders, Lanzmann wanted to know whether they were aware of the trains arriving and departing and of the existence of the death camps. To explore this, he interviewed only Polish people, even taking one interviewee, Pan Falborski, on a train to Treblinka. In addition to these accounts, Lanzmann interviewed Holocaust historian Raul Hilberg, who discusses the historical significance of Nazi propaganda against European Jews and the Nazi invention of the Final Solution.

4 Sections Hidden · 1,040 words
Cinematic Techniques and Emotional Impact310 words
The testimonies read almost like a book, yet there are aspects of the documentary medium that film can express more effectively than written text. The survivors react emotionally to what they witnessed. Muller breaks down…
Ethical Controversies and Objectivity190 words
For any documentary, viewers take into consideration the objectivity of the film. Lanzmann does not quite succeed in making his movie objective. During…
Historical Significance and Lasting Legacy380 words
Shoah tells the story of the Holocaust from a distinctly human, "everyman" perspective. Lanzmann recognized that the victims of this horror were being forgotten…
Conclusion: Memory, Humanity, and the Purpose of Shoah160 words
Every aspect of Shoah was created so that the events depicted would not be forgotten, and especially so that those stories would never happen again. History must not be repeated — it is a lesson from…

Bibliography

Bernstein, Richard. "An Epic Film About the Greatest Evil of Modern Times." New York Times, 20 Oct. 1985.

Heilman, Jeremy. "Newest Reviews: Shoah (Claude Lanzmann, 1985)." 10 Aug. 2003. moviemartyr.com.

"Shoah." Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. wikipedia.org/wiki/Shoah.

Key Concepts in This Paper
Survivor Testimony Holocaust Memory Documentary Ethics Hidden Camera Historical Document Anti-Semitism Firsthand Witness Nazi Genocide Cinematic Form Collective Memory
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Shoah (1985) by Claude Lanzmann: Documentary Film Review. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/shoah-lanzmann-documentary-film-review-41564

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.