Evaluating Research Methods in Singapore Expatriate Studies
This paper critically evaluates the research methodology employed in Wan, Hui, and Tsang's study on factors affecting Singaporeans' acceptance of international postings. The analysis examines four dimensions: the effectiveness of the literature review in framing the study and justifying the research; the adequacy of the sampling strategy and its demographic representativeness; the validity and limitations of the survey measures used; and the overall persuasiveness of the study's conclusions. The paper finds that while the literature review and choice of measures are reasonably well-grounded, the sampling process suffers from significant demographic skew, undermining the study's ability to generalize findings to the broader population of Singaporean business professionals.
- The Literature Review and Its Functions: Assesses how well the literature review frames and justifies the study
- Sampling Strategy and Demographic Representativeness: Critiques geographic and demographic bias in respondent selection
- Survey Measures and Their Limitations: Evaluates the survey instruments and question design choices
- Evaluating the Study's Conclusions: Assesses overall persuasiveness and scope of the study's conclusions
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper uses a clear four-part structure that mirrors the stages of a research critique — literature review, sampling, measurement, and conclusions — making the argument easy to follow.
- The critique is balanced: it acknowledges strengths (well-grounded measures, regression analysis) while identifying specific, evidence-backed weaknesses (demographic skew, geographic sampling bias).
- The use of concrete demographic statistics — such as the 87.5% Chinese respondent share versus 74.2% population share — gives the critique empirical grounding rather than relying on vague assertions.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates methodological critique, a core skill in graduate-level research methods courses. Rather than simply summarizing the study, the author interrogates each methodological choice — sampling location, question wording, measure selection — against established standards and asks whether the conclusions can legitimately be drawn from the evidence gathered. This moves the paper beyond description into genuine analytical evaluation.
Structure breakdown
The paper is organized into four numbered sections, each addressing a discrete methodological question: (1) the role and quality of the literature review; (2) the sampling design and its demographic validity; (3) the survey instruments and their limitations; and (4) an overall assessment of the study's conclusions. Each section follows a pattern of summary, evaluation, and critique, culminating in a measured final judgment that neither wholly endorses nor dismisses the study's findings.
The Literature Review and Its Functions
The literature review for Wan, Hui, and Tsang's article "Factors affecting Singaporeans' acceptance of international postings" contributes to the study in several key ways. It sets the framework for the discussion, provides insight into previous research on the subject, gives international context, and determines the importance and relevance of the study by illustrating where it fits within contemporary research. These functions are consistent with the established objectives for literature reviews in general (University, 2009).
In setting the framework for the discussion, the literature review explains the basic themes concerning the decision to accept an overseas assignment, and further specifies that the paper addresses this issue with particular regard to Singaporeans. This presents the reader with the necessary framework to understand the points of discussion that follow.
A literature review should provide insight into previous research on the subject. For this topic, there are many facets of research that should be addressed, including the decision to accept an overseas assignment, the different types of overseas assignments, and the general reaction to each type. Studies at this stage of the literature review can be relatively brief. The authors are brief — perhaps too much so — but they explain the concepts adequately.
The literature review then moves into the specific Singaporean context, again covered in brief, just enough to frame the discussion. It also provides definitions of the key terms used in the study, which further helps orient the reader.
The second function this literature review serves is to provide insight into previous research on the subject. This is important because the authors are expected to identify gaps in the existing research that their paper intends to fill. In this instance, the authors argue that there is little in the existing literature that specifically addresses the acceptance of overseas assignments within the Singaporean context.
The third function of the literature review is to place the research within a full international context. This is not a function of all literature reviews, but this paper is uniquely focused on the international domain. The authors do, to some extent, attempt to cover international literature and synthesize it with Singapore-specific literature, albeit in a fairly thin manner. Again, the authors maintain that there is little previous research with which to work.
The fourth function of the literature review is to justify the current research. This can be accomplished not only by pointing out gaps in the existing body of research, but also by interpreting that body to determine which areas are most in need of contribution. The authors do this in a superficial way. While they are correct that the research fills gaps, it is the importance of those gaps that they fail to fully justify — a shortcoming that likely reflects weak argumentative writing rather than any deficiency in their logic.
Overall, the literature review expends significant effort outlining key research terms and methodology, which makes it more accessible to a lay audience — one that can reasonably be expected given the topic. The literature review ultimately provides a strong framework for the study and solid justification for its conduct.
Works Cited
Wan, D., Hui, T., & Tiang, L. (2002). Factors affecting Singaporeans' acceptance of international postings. Personnel Review, 32(6), 711–732.
No author. (2009). Literature review. University of Toronto. Retrieved November 27, 2009, from
No author. (2009). Selection of a sample. Statistics Canada. Retrieved November 27, 2009, from http://www.statcan.gc.ca/edu/power-pouvoir/ch13/sample-echantillon/5214900-eng.htm
No author. (2009). Population trends 2009. Singapore Department of Statistics. Retrieved November 27, 2009, from
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.