Spanish Women in Film, Literature, and Social Values

Introduction: Spanish Women and Changing Social Values

Within the turn of the twentieth century, Spanish women spread into fields that were largely dominated by men. Cinematography, authorship, and activism welcomed women into their embrace — though not without considerable hardship along the way. This can be attributed to the changing, and sometimes unchanging, class and social values of Spanish families in the wake of two poignant historical eras: the Spanish Civil War and the Franco dictatorship, both of which dominated Spain around the mid-1900s.

The post-Franco era gradually gave way to a democratic Spain, and by 1976 this transition led to a meaningful shift in Spanish values, most notably in the perception of gender roles within society (Perez). In the light of politics, film, literature, and other media, society began to allow female activists, directors, and authors to let their voices be heard. This does not necessarily mean that these feminist voices displaced the patriarchal values of the Spanish household, however. Through a deeply felt moral obligation to their families, these women still retained their traditional place within the family structure.

The feminist movement in Spain began in the early 1900s, even amidst the Civil War, and persisted through the Franco years. Because of such conflicting historical events, feminism remained a stunted cause, taking secondary priority to the class struggle that consumed Spain over the decades (Davies). At the turn of the twentieth century, feminist Spain branched away from its Western neighbors; post-modern Spain was anxious to assert a distinction between its own post-modernism and the West's interpretations thereof (Labanyi). The creative works of women during the twentieth century reflect this constant social struggle, with underlying themes that tackle the roles of men and women in the household. Distinct female voices emerged in the fields of literature and film, though there remained a persistent pull back toward patriarchal values.

Film Direction and Media Leadership

The Spanish film industry witnessed the beginning of a rise of female directors. The director's seat had long been considered a "man's seat" — both nationally and internationally — though vanguard figures such as Ana Mariscal and Rosario Pi challenged this ideology (Millan). By the 1980s, the director's chair opened up to visionary women such as Pilar Miro and Josefina Molina. By the end of the twentieth century, the successes of Iciar Bollain and Patricia Ferreira gave women still greater voice in the public sphere. In addition to their professional influence, these women also maintained their roles in the household, a domestic role understood as distinct from that of men.

Pilar Miro's ambition as a director led her to study journalism and cinema, ultimately earning a degree in screenwriting at the Escuela Oficial de Cinematografia in Madrid — the first woman ever to do so (Millan). Under the Franco regime, Miro worked at Spain's only television network, Televisión Española. Her directing debut, though met with objections — directing was not then considered an appropriate activity for a woman (Millan) — came in 1976 at the close of the Franco era with La peticion. The film generated enormous controversy for its sex scenes and unconventional female characters, such as Teresa. Miro then broke new boundaries again with her second film, El crimen de Cuenca, released in 1979 (Millan). Although censorship was not formally invoked and the film premiered to considerable box-office success, the government arrested Miro on the grounds that El crimen slandered the Civil Guard.

The charges were eventually dropped, but as a director, Miro fought her way through her work, at times focusing on strong, independent women. By 1982, Pilar Miro was appointed General Director of Cinema by Felipe González's first administration (Millan). In this role, Miro took a more political and activist stance in defense of cinematic rights. Her influence over the Spanish film industry was undeniable.

Similarly, Josefina Molina fought her own battles, earning recognition as a pioneer of the female directing voice. While Miro had graduated from the Escuela Oficial de Cinematografia in screenwriting, it was Molina who first earned a degree in directing at the same institution. Molina's first film, Función de noche (1981), revolutionized Spanish cinema with its freshly reformatted documentary style, uncovering new perspectives on daily Spanish life (Millan). Her subsequent documentaries depicted women during the years of the Franco regime, showing the social and ideological conditioning women faced during their married years and the difficulties of breaking free from it.

By the 1990s, a boom of female directors emerged in Spain. Rosa Vergés, Isabel Coixet, and Eva Lesmes were among the names appearing in Spanish film circles. Actress-turned-director Iciar Bollain's film Hola, ¿estás sola? (1995) juxtaposed the lives of single women with those of bachelors, offering a commentary on the country's social problems (Millan). Film-critic-turned-director Patricia Ferreira followed in Molina's footsteps, actively making documentaries at the turn of the century. Ferreira's focus, however, differed from her colleagues who addressed primarily feminist topics. Instead, her 2000 film Sé quién eres covered a politically changing Spain, from the Franco regime to the entrance of democracy.

It is evident that these women possessed distinct voices and, in most respects, political and cultural influence. Their intentions, however, did not stray far from their personal lives. Miro's work, while opinionated and controversial, did not set out to tell women's stories purely for the sake of breaking out of the patriarchal household. In fact, while she did not reject that type of feminist storytelling, her characters are described as "complex, contradictory and even unlikable," designed to convey the full picture of a woman's life caught between her familial role and a changing outside world (Pilar).

"I don't think about cinema from the viewpoint of a woman; I think about it from the viewpoint of a director. I'm not interested specifically in telling women's stories, although I do not reject them; what interests me is to tell stories… What is clear for me is that I do not begin with predetermined women's issues in mind; people are what interest me." — Pilar Miro (Millan)

Molina's documentaries depicted the daily lives of Spanish couples and families. Her films explored the ideologies that men and women were conditioned to accept about the household during the Franco years, revealing just how startling those expectations were (Millan). She showed the difficulties of breaking from ideology even after the transition to democracy. Married couples were her primary focus, and in the 1990s she returned to the social problems of the Spanish household — to the patriarchal hierarchy that she and other contemporary women encountered in daily life.

Bollain shared the view that a director's chair is no different whether it accommodates a man or a woman. Regarding women's social standing in Spain, Bollain directly addressed the pressures placed on women who even considered leaving abusive husbands. In the post-Franco period, women became more vocal about domestic abuse, and while the broader democratic ethos might point toward leaving the household, Bollain offered a different solution: rather than having the woman leave, she advocated sending abusive men to re-education centers, in the hope that men would change and women could return to a more peaceful home (Millan). The goal was reconciliation, not departure.

Meanwhile, Ferreira commented on the similarities between the contemporary female voice and the voices of the past. Among her fellow female directors, Ferreira was the quietest about her struggles competing in a male-dominated profession.

"Yes, a woman finds more obstacles in her way… I would dare say that twenty years ago it was easier. At that time, there were so few women in my profession that they always considered you a curiosity, an oddity — you were someone who was tolerated, a demonstration of their liberal character. Now we've gone from being curiosities to being the competition. And that's as far as we have been able to get. Perhaps this just means that everything continues more or less as before." — Patricia Ferreira (Millan)

For Ferreira, the workplace had not changed much — and neither had the household.

Conclusion: Balancing Influence and Household Roles

Throughout the political turmoil and societal upheavals of twentieth-century Spain, women's spheres of influence expanded considerably, reaching into the film industry and the creative arts. From the director's chair to the writing of neo-gothic novels and feminist essays, Spanish women claimed significant public ground. It is equally evident, however, that while these spheres of influence grew, the Spanish household retained its patriarchal structure, and the social struggle between men and women persisted within it. The women of this era either spoke out against that structure, offering compromising solutions, or turned to moral and religious justifications to uphold what Spanish society expected of them. In either case, they remained within the bounds of the family structure.

Family structures are an important part of a Spanish woman's lifestyle. While the Spanish woman gained greater freedom of expression across fields — film, literature, and politics, among others — that freedom was counterbalanced by the continued expectation that she retain her role in the Spanish household. However, rather than viewing this solely as a restriction, one can also read it as a balance: a harmony between freedom of expression in the public sphere and the retention of social role and class within the family. For many of the women examined here, that equilibrium was not a defeat but a defining feature of their lives and their art.

Bibliography

"Pilar Miro — Film Society of Lincoln Center." Film Society of Lincoln Center. 7 Dec. 2007. Web. 17 Feb. 2011.

Davies, Catherine. "Feminist Writers in Spain since 1900: From Political Strategy to Personal Inquiry," in Textual Liberation: European Feminist Writing in the Twentieth Century. Helena Forsas Scott, ed. London: Routledge, 1991.

Ferran, Ofelia and Kathleen Glenn. Women's Narrative and Film in Twentieth Century Spain. New York: Routledge, 2002.

Glenn, Kathleen M. and Mercedes Mazquiaran, eds. Spanish Women Writers and the Essay: Gender, Politics and the Self. Columbia: U. of Missouri Press, 1998.

Kruse, Sharon D., and Sandra Spickard Prettyman. "Women, Leadership, and Power: Revisiting the Wicked Witch of the West." Gender and Education 20.5 (2008): 451–464. ERIC. EBSCO. Web. 6 Feb. 2011.

Labanyi, Jo, ed. Constructing Identity in Twentieth-Century Spain: Theoretical Debate and Cultural Practice. U.S.A.: Oxford University Press, 2002.

McKenna, Margaret A. "Women in Power." New England Journal of Public Policy 22.1/2 (2007): 7–16. Business Source Premier. EBSCO. Web. 6 Feb. 2011.

Millan, Juan Antonio Perez. "Women Are Also the Future: Women Directors in Recent Spanish Cinema." Cineaste 29.1 (2003): 50. MasterFILE Premier. EBSCO. Web. 6 Feb. 2011.

Miller-McLemore, Bonnie J. "Hitting Home: Feminist Ethics, Women's Work, and the Betrayal of 'Family Values.'" Journal of Religion 84.1 (n.d.): 138–140. Literary Reference Center. EBSCO. Web. 6 Feb. 2011.

Perez, Janet. "Contemporary Spanish Women Writers and the Feminine Neo-Gothic." Romance Quarterly 51.2 (2004): 125. MasterFILE Premier. EBSCO. Web. 6 Feb. 2011.

Perez, Janet and Maureen Ihrie. The Feminist Encyclopedia of Spanish Literature. 2 vols. Westport: Greenwood Press, 2002.