This paper examines the strategic considerations involved in opening a new, independent coffee shop designed to compete with Starbucks. It argues that building a new business is preferable to acquiring an established brand, citing lower costs, fewer inherited liabilities, and greater owner flexibility. The paper outlines three core competitive strategies—cost leadership, differentiation, and focus—and explains how their combined use can help the new shop capture market share. It also identifies partnership as the most suitable ownership structure and concludes with a brief business plan covering the executive summary, company description, market analysis, organizational structure, and marketing approach.
Today's business world is highly competitive, with new enterprises constantly emerging to challenge well-established players. This paper explains the strategy that would be used when opening a small business—specifically, a coffee shop intended to compete with Starbucks. It examines whether opening a new coffee shop is more sensible than purchasing an existing Starbucks franchise, considers the most appropriate form of ownership for the new shop, and presents a basic business plan for the proposed establishment.
To compete effectively with Starbucks, a clear business strategy must be developed and implemented. Strategy is critical because it helps the coffee shop achieve its goals and, ultimately, establish a strong presence in the market. As Porter (2008) argues, the attractiveness of a business within its industry primarily determines its profitability and long-term market presence.
The strategic business plan for the new coffee shop centers on gaining a competitive advantage over Starbucks by offering consumers better value. This will be achieved primarily through lower prices compared to similar Starbucks products. Additionally, the shop will include complimentary accompaniments—such as biscuits and cookies—with coffee purchases. While this may give the impression that certain items are priced higher, the overall cost to the customer is actually lower, since Starbucks sells such accompaniments separately, making its total spend higher by comparison (Griffin, 2012).
A cost leadership strategy will be used to establish a competitive advantage on a broader scale. This approach is aimed at capturing the largest possible share of the market by attracting the greatest number of customers through fair and affordable pricing. The coffee shop will offer high-quality coffee at prices that are both reasonable and accessible. Costs of production will be minimized as much as possible, and those savings will be passed on to customers in the form of lower prices—without reducing the profits the shop intends to generate. Because the shop is new and seeking to establish itself, it will price its products below those at Starbucks, directly targeting the market share that Starbucks currently dominates (Farquhar, 2012).
The differentiation strategy aims to offer customers products that are distinct in quality and that they will genuinely value. The coffee shop will attract customers by producing coffee that stands apart from Starbucks offerings. A wide variety of coffee will be available, including espresso, Americano, cappuccino, black coffee, dry cappuccino, flavored coffee, white coffee, café latte, café macchiato, café latte freddo, Turkish coffee, and instant coffee, among others. All of these options will be prepared to taste better than their Starbucks equivalents. Light snacks will also be available to accompany the coffee, and a dedicated team will be committed to crafting the best possible cup for every customer.
For more background on how Porter's generic strategies apply to small businesses, the differentiation approach is particularly well-suited to markets where an incumbent competitor holds strong brand recognition.
"Targeting coffee lovers and combining all strategies"
"Building new is cheaper and more flexible"
"Partnership chosen for shared capital and management"
"Full plan covering operations, market, and marketing"
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.