Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 1,915 words

Survival in the Wild: Call of the Wild vs. Hatchet

~10 min read 6 sections Literature · Hatchet
Abstract

This essay presents a comparative analysis of Jack London's The Call of the Wild (1903) and Gary Paulsen's Hatchet (1987), examining how both novels use the man vs. wild conflict to interrogate the nature of humanity, civilization, and survival. Through the experiences of Buck, a domesticated dog thrust into the brutal Klondike wilderness, and Brian Robeson, a teenager stranded alone in the Canadian wilderness, the essay traces how each protagonist's relationship with nature transforms from one of fear and incomprehension to respect and cooperation. The analysis highlights key juxtapositions — pet vs. companion, civilization vs. wilderness, cruelty vs. loyalty — and argues that both narratives ultimately question which world, wild or civilized, produces the more genuinely humane creature.

Key Takeaways
  • Introduction: Two Novels, One Wilderness Theme: Overview of both novels and central juxtapositions
  • Buck's Fall from Comfort: The Call of the Wild: Buck's kidnapping and introduction to primitive law
  • The Brutality and Order of the Sled Dog World: Life among sled dogs and Buck's integration into the wild
  • Brian's Crash into Nature: Hatchet: Plane crash and Brian's first violent encounter with wilderness
  • Learning to Cooperate with the Wild: Brian's growing respect for and cooperation with nature
  • What Humanity Means in the Wilderness: Both protagonists question civilization and true humanity
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • The essay uses sustained textual evidence — extended block quotations from both novels — to ground its comparative claims rather than relying on vague generalizations.
  • The juxtaposition framework is established early and maintained throughout, giving the analysis a clear structural logic that connects the two very different novels.
  • The concluding paragraph returns to the central question — who is truly civilized? — in a way that synthesizes both narratives and leaves the reader with a genuine interpretive provocation.

Key academic technique demonstrated

This paper demonstrates the technique of comparative close reading: placing passages from two texts in dialogue with each other to reveal shared thematic concerns. Rather than treating the novels sequentially, the essay weaves them together around common motifs (fear of the unknown, gradual respect for nature, the cruelty and kindness of humans), showing how the same themes can be expressed through very different protagonists — one canine, one human.

Structure breakdown

The essay opens by introducing both novels and establishing the central juxtapositions. It then moves through Call of the Wild chronologically — Buck's comfortable origin, his kidnapping, the shock of primitive law, and his ultimate integration into the wolf pack. Hatchet follows, tracing Brian from the plane crash through fear of individual animals to a broader acceptance of the wilderness as home. The final section synthesizes both arcs into a philosophical question about civilization and humanity.

Essay 1,915 words

Introduction: Two Novels, One Wilderness Theme

Published in 1903, The Call of the Wild is Jack London's most popular book. It is sometimes categorized as a novel for young adults, but it is in fact a dark journey into human nature, depicting a species capable of both nobility and profound cruelty. The protagonist, Buck, is a dog who is kidnapped and placed into servitude as a sled dog during the nineteenth-century Klondike Gold Rush. It is Buck's loyalty and instinct to return to his owners that drives the plot — and it is through Buck's experiences that the reader is invited to reflect on the inhumanity of humans and the genuine loyalty and humanity Buck himself demonstrates.

Hatchet is a 1987 three-time Newbery Honor book for young adults dealing with survival, and is the first of four novels featuring the same characters. The plot follows thirteen-year-old Brian Robeson, who is stranded alone in the Canadian wilderness after a crash landing from a bush plane. Brian barely survives, but learns to make fire, scavenge food, and — through trial and error — crafts more advanced tools such as a bow, arrows, and a spear, eventually enabling him to hunt larger game. The novel is ultimately about the way the human spirit endures in all forms of adversity, and the way a creative, nature-attuned individual can overcome seemingly impossible odds.

There is a great deal of juxtaposition in both novels: man vs. wild; pet vs. companion; nature vs. humanity; human spirit vs. adversity; and, above all, what actually constitutes humanity in a world outside of urban, modern civilization. Nature takes on a kind of personality in both works, though this is a complicated literary move for each author. If we analyze it carefully, we must conclude that nature is neither anti-human nor anti-individual, while at the same time far from benign or nurturing. It almost seems that humans are not wise enough to understand the rhythms of nature or to work in harmony with it. When that realization finally arrives for each protagonist, it changes everything — rather than fighting against nature, the individual accepts that there must be a balance, and that actively resisting nature only delays genuine human actualization.

5 Sections Hidden · 930 words
Buck's Fall from Comfort: The Call of the Wild210 words
In The Call of the Wild, the central contrast lies between Buck's life as a domesticated pet and the brutal existence he is forced into after his kidnapping. Buck had lived in almost palatial luxury — the only life…
The Brutality and Order of the Sled Dog World150 words
Day after day, the realities of the wild confronted Buck. The other sled dogs were, for the most part, nothing but…
Brian's Crash into Nature: Hatchet220 words
In Hatchet, the harshness of nature is established immediately in the way the plane — a supposed triumph of technology — becomes nothing but a plaything in nature's hands:…
Learning to Cooperate with the Wild190 words
There are a number of examples in Hatchet that illustrate the classic man vs. wild dynamic, particularly in the way Brian first perceives the animals…
What Humanity Means in the Wilderness160 words
Buck is the central character of The Call of the Wild, and it is through his eyes that we must ask: what is the call of the wild? Is it the call to avarice — the particularly human trait…

References

London, J. (2009). The Call of the Wild. New York: Signet.

Paulsen, G. (2007). Hatchet. New York: Simon and Schuster.

Key Concepts in This Paper
Man vs. Wild Survival Instinct Call of the Wild Human Cruelty Nature Cooperation Primitive Law Civilization Critique Animal Loyalty Coming of Age Wilderness Transformation
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Survival in the Wild: Call of the Wild vs. Hatchet. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/survival-call-of-the-wild-vs-hatchet-42126

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.