This essay examines two of the most powerful stories in Tim O'Brien's The Things They Carried: "The Man I Killed" and "The Sweetheart of Song Tra Bong." The paper explores how O'Brien uses graphic honesty and first-person narration to convey the devastating psychological and moral effects of the Vietnam War. Through close reading of the narrator's silent grief over the enemy soldier he has killed and Mary Anne Bell's disturbing transformation from an innocent visitor into a figure consumed by violence, the essay argues that both stories capture experiences that ultimately surpass language — yet must be told.
The most shocking aspects of The Things They Carried are its graphic descriptions and the striking honesty with which Tim O'Brien conveys the devastating effects of war. Several stories are written with an honesty that reveals both the horrors of war and the frailty of the human spirit. The most moving of these stories are "The Man I Killed" and "The Sweetheart of Song Tra Bong."
Perhaps one of the most shocking stories in the collection is "The Man I Killed." Written in first-person narrative, its most compelling aspect is the fact that the narrator never speaks. This effect emphasizes the shock of killing someone, even in an act of self-defense. The narrator cannot take his eyes off the enemy soldier. The opening of the story describes him in unflinching detail: "His jaw was in his throat, his upper lip and teeth were gone, his one eye was shut, his other eye was a star-shaped hole" (O'Brien 124). The narrator notices every detail about the soldier, including his "bony legs, narrow waist" and "long shapely fingers" (124). He observes the man's sandals and the gold ring on the third finger of his right hand. The sight of the man and the reality of his death are overwhelming for the narrator.
Recognizing these details causes the narrator to contemplate what kind of life the soldier had lived before his death. The narrator imagines the young man being taught to defend the land, even though the thought of fighting "frightened him. He was not a fighter. His health was poor, his body small and frail. He liked books. He wanted someday to be a teacher. He hoped that Americans would go away" (125). As he watches the soldier's body decompose, the narrator still cannot stop thinking about that life. He imagines that the soldier "devoted himself to his studies. He spent his nights alone, wrote romantic poems in his journal" (128). This image allows the reader to understand the full weight of what the narrator has done. Suddenly, the dead soldier is not simply an enemy combatant; he is a man with hopes and dreams, not unlike the narrator himself.
The story is also powerful because it unfolds over only a few minutes of time. Yet those few moments change the narrator's life in a way that is beyond words. His friend Kiowa tries to get him to talk, but the narrator cannot speak. This inability to speak — combined with his inability to look away from the corpse — represents the unspoken horrors that soldiers carry with them long after the fighting ends. As O'Brien makes clear throughout the novel, some experiences resist direct articulation and can only be approached through the act of storytelling itself.
Another story that describes the brutality of war is "The Sweetheart of Song Tra Bong." This story illustrates how anyone can become a victim of war. Mary Anne Bell travels to Vietnam to visit her boyfriend and ultimately decides never to return to civilized life. What is most striking about Mary Anne is the stark contrast between her character at the beginning and at the end of the story. She arrives wearing white culottes and a "sexy pink sweater" (90), full of curiosity about the land and its people, and she picks up on things quickly.
"Mary Anne Bell arrives innocent, quickly changes"
"Mary Anne embraces violence and refuses to leave"
I found these two stories to be the most powerful in the novel because they attempt to describe something that is beyond words. I do not personally enjoy stories or movies about war. However, O'Brien's storytelling is so skillfully done that I have to admit this is a remarkable book. My friends do not understand how I can call this book "good" while still disliking war stories. The only thing I can tell them is that the stories are personal and honest, and the way they are told overrides their subject matter.
You’re 56% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.