This paper examines the concept of "Main Street" as a form of American idealism and evaluates how Times Square functions as New York City's version of that ideal. It traces the cultural mythology surrounding Main Street — as a hub for community needs, social gathering, and civic institutions — and measures Times Square against those criteria. While Times Square excels as a destination for entertainment, spectacle, and tourism, it lacks many traditional pillars such as banks, churches, and post offices. The paper also highlights Times Square's revitalization through arts investment on 42nd Street as an example of the quintessentially American ideal of self-improvement and reinvention.
The paper demonstrates the use of a definitional framework as an evaluative tool. By first constructing a working definition of "Main Street" — including its civic, social, and commercial dimensions — the writer creates measurable criteria against which Times Square can be systematically assessed. This compare-against-a-standard approach is a useful technique in short analytical essays.
The essay opens by defining Main Street and its role in American idealism, then applies that definition to Times Square in two stages: first identifying the ways it qualifies, then acknowledging where it falls short. The final section reframes Times Square's transformation narrative as itself an expression of American idealism, bringing the argument full circle. The structure is linear and clearly signposted throughout.
The concept of "Main Street" in America refers to the primary street at the center of a city or town — a destination unto itself where the primary attractions and pillars of the community are located. It is common to find post offices, schools, banks, churches, and city halls situated on or near a town's main street. It is equally common to find forms of entertainment and relaxation there, which is why cinemas, theatres, concert halls, shops, and restaurants typically cluster around a city's central main street.
Part of the American idealism connected to Main Street lies in the sense that it is the place where a person can go to have all their needs fulfilled — whether mailing a letter, depositing a check, lighting a candle, having lunch, or buying a new scarf. One of the central mythologies of Main Street, therefore, is that it is a place where all of one's needs can be met. This is deeply connected to why people congregate there. Because of this draw, Main Street becomes a location where community members are more likely to encounter one another, reinforcing and strengthening the overall sense of community.
When measured against these ideals, it is both easy and difficult to see how Times Square functions as New York City's Main Street. On one hand, the connection is clear. As one source describes it: "As city districts go, Times Square is a global legend, and rightfully so: the cinematic epicenter of NYC tourism and Broadway theater, it's a must-see New York attraction. Its fabled days of epic squalor are a distant memory, but there's still plenty of spectacle to appreciate" (Timeout, 2013). This sentiment captures the general sense that Times Square is the main street of New York City — one of its most famous thoroughfares, offering attractions ranging from cinemas to Broadway theatres.
Indeed, one can argue that with all its lights and electronic billboards, Times Square is an attraction unto itself. It draws both locals and tourists through its sheer visual spectacle. In this capacity, New York's main street both contains actual destinations for people to explore and is the destination in and of itself (DreamCue, 2014).
You’re 49% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.