This reflection paper examines two key quotations from Mary Shelley's Frankenstein to argue that Victor Frankenstein, not his creation, represents the true monstrosity of the novel. The paper explores the dual nature of the protagonist's character: his admirable single-minded dedication to his scientific work and his damning hypocrisy and lack of compassion. By analyzing Victor's rejection of his creation and his failure to provide emotional care, the paper demonstrates how Shelley's narrative ultimately critiques unchecked ambition and the moral bankruptcy of abandoning responsibility. The analysis emphasizes that the creature's suffering stems directly from Victor's selfishness, making Victor the novel's authentic monster.
Victor Frankenstein's admission of his feelings toward his creation reveals monstrosity—but not in the creature itself. The quotation demonstrates the profound hypocrisy at the heart of Victor's character. He pursued his scientific goal with all-consuming desire, valuing it above almost everything else, yet the moment he achieved it, he was filled with "horror" and "disgust." This contradiction exposes Victor as the novel's true monster. His inability to accept responsibility for his own achievement, combined with his visceral rejection of something he spent years creating, demonstrates a moral bankruptcy that far exceeds any transgression of his creation. Victor wanted something desperately, attained it, and then abandoned it—a pattern of behavior that defines cruelty rather than scientific integrity.
Yet there is undeniable appeal in Victor's single-minded commitment to his work. His "ardour," his complete immersion in his scientific pursuit, and his ability to reject all distractions represent a kind of devotion that many aspire to achieve. In this respect, Victor's character is admirable. The intensity and proficiency he demonstrates in his field reflect a genuine mastery that few ever attain. Shelley captures this dedication through her deliberately structured prose, which allows readers to transcend mere words and feel the passion behind Victor's ambition. The beauty of her writing conveys something genuinely compelling about total commitment to one's art or science. It is this facet of Victor's character—his capacity for profound focus and achievement—that draws many readers to the novel and creates a tension within the narrative. One can respect Victor's dedication while simultaneously condemning his moral failings. This duality is central to Shelley's characterization and to the novel's enduring power as a meditation on ambition.
"Victor's failure as a creator-parent mirrors abandonment and neglect"
The second quotation examined here perfectly captures the sentiment raised by the first, but now the creature himself speaks. This passage reveals the immense loneliness and horror that Victor's creation experiences throughout the novel. The creature did not choose to be created; he bore no responsibility for the world's revulsion toward him. Rather, Victor bears that responsibility entirely. Victor created the creature; Victor abandoned him; and Victor set in motion the chain of events that led others to despise and fear the innocent being he brought into existence. The creature's observation that he is "miserable beyond all living things" rings tragically true. He has been endowed with sensitivity, intelligence, and a keen appreciation for life's wonders, yet he cannot experience any of them. This punishment—isolation, rejection, perpetual suffering—would typically be reserved for criminals who violated society's laws. Yet the creature is innocent. He committed no crime until others attacked and shunned him. The one who truly led this charge, who paved the way for the creature's mistreatment, is Victor himself. In this inversion, Shelley's novel becomes a profound critique of how the supposed innocent can become guilty through negligence and cruelty.
Frankenstein, often read as a simple tale of scientific overreach, is actually a novel deeply concerned with moral responsibility and the consequences of abandonment. Victor's crime is not creating life but rejecting what he created. His monstrosity lies not in ambition but in the absence of compassion.
"Victor projects his own self-hatred onto the innocent creature he abandoned"
You’re 64% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.