This paper examines the contrasting roles of female characters in Sophocles' Oedipus the King and Homer's The Odyssey. Focusing on Jocasta as the sole female figure in Oedipus, the paper argues that her emotional instability, passivity, and irresponsibility reflect a diminished view of women in Greek society. By contrast, female characters in The Odyssey—including Penelope, Athena, Calypso, and Helen of Troy—display determination, agency, and complexity that transcend traditional supporting roles. The paper concludes that Homer's earlier work presents a surprisingly more empowered image of women than Sophocles' later tragedy.
Women have played a series of roles in Greek legends. Some portrayals focus on their inferiority relative to men and their helplessness when facing difficult situations alone, while others picture women as individuals who refuse to give up without putting up a serious fight. The character of Jocasta in Sophocles' Oedipus the King appears strong and dominant at first but gradually loses control as the play's action advances. In contrast, most of the female characters in Homer's The Odyssey display great strength of mind and seem capable of dealing with any difficulty they encounter, regardless of its gravity. While Queen Jocasta is one of the most unfortunate characters in Greek mythology, the women in The Odyssey demonstrate that determination is the key to success.
One might reasonably conclude that the role of women is downgraded through the character of Jocasta. She yields to temptation and fails to employ a cautious, skeptical outlook — especially given that the oracle had already warned her about her fate. Jocasta's decision to send a servant to kill her son, rather than acting herself, reveals her weakness and makes her principally responsible for the prophecy becoming reality. The Queen's emotional instability is apparently tied to her gender, reflecting a broader belief in Greek society that women were inferior to men. It was widely assumed that women were guided by their emotions rather than by reason, and that this tendency led to terrible consequences.
Given that Jocasta is the only female character in the play, it seems reasonable to conclude that Sophocles was hesitant to grant women important roles in his work. Although Jocasta appears several times throughout the play, her overall purpose and her position within the action come across as irresponsible and immature. Her husband's death does not appear to strike her as anything particularly significant, and she quickly moves on, marrying Oedipus without apparent grief.
Homer's Penelope is, in many respects, the opposite of Jocasta. Unlike Jocasta, Penelope is entirely unwilling to marry another man. Her steadfastness is all the more admirable given the relentless pressure exerted on her by numerous suitors. Jocasta, by contrast, requires only one new man to forget about Laius entirely.
The husbands themselves also stand in sharp contrast. Penelope's husband, Odysseus, is one of the most celebrated heroes in Greek tradition, while Laius is remembered chiefly for his shameful and unethical behavior. This contrast further elevates Penelope's loyalty, since her devotion is directed toward a man who is genuinely worthy of it.
"Homeric women as active, powerful figures"
"Odyssey women transcend traditional supporting functions"
"Penelope as multifaceted contrast to Jocasta"
You’re 48% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.