Women's Nature in Dickens's Oliver Twist: Martyrs and Whores
This essay examines the symbolic and narrative functions of female characters in Charles Dickens's Oliver Twist. Focusing on Agnes, Mrs. Mann, Nancy, and Rose, the paper argues that Dickens organizes his women along a binary of good and evil, with nurturing capacity as the defining moral measure. Agnes and Rose represent idealized femininity, while Mrs. Mann embodies its perversion. Nancy occupies the most complex position: a prostitute whose innate maternal instinct ultimately drives her to self-sacrifice. The essay also considers how Fagin's quasi-maternal role among the boy thieves underscores Dickens's broader critique of a society that corrupts natural, womanly goodness through poverty, exploitation, and crime.
- Introduction: Women as Moral Anchors: Women's symbolic and narrative roles introduced
- Oliver's Mother and Mrs. Mann: Absent and Perverted Nurturing: Contrasting maternal figures shape Oliver's early fate
- Fagin's Surrogate Motherhood and Oliver's Vulnerability: Fagin's corrupt quasi-maternal role exploits Oliver
- Nancy: The Prostitute with a Maternal Heart: Nancy's innate maternal instinct drives her sacrifice
- Rose and the Ideal of Domestic Femininity: Rose embodies Dickens's ideal of womanly domesticity
- The Good–Evil Binary and Nancy's Ambiguity: Nancy complicates the novel's moral binary of women
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Grounds every claim in direct textual evidence, quoting specific chapters from Oliver Twist and letting Dickens's own words carry analytical weight.
- Maintains a coherent central argument — that nurturing capacity is Dickens's moral yardstick for female characters — and applies it consistently across multiple characters.
- Handles Nancy's complexity with nuance, resisting the temptation to flatten her into a simple redemption narrative and acknowledging the limits of her agency.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper uses binary opposition analysis — structuring the argument around good/evil, domestic/criminal, life/death — while complicating that binary through the figure of Nancy. This technique, common in Victorian literary criticism, allows the writer to expose Dickens's ideological assumptions even while tracing where the novel itself questions them.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens by stating its thesis about women's symbolic and narrative functions, then moves character by character: Oliver's mother and Mrs. Mann establish the nurturing binary; Fagin's quasi-maternal role widens it; Nancy's arc forms the analytical heart of the paper; Rose provides the ideal counterpoint; and the conclusion synthesizes these threads into a reading of Dickens's ambivalent middle-class morality. The progression is logical and cumulative.
Introduction: Women as Moral Anchors
The women of Oliver Twist play an important function in the novel, both symbolically and in terms of the plot. The novel begins with the title character being born to a woman living in poverty and being subsequently consigned to a workhouse. Later, through a series of strange circumstances, he is found to be of noble birth. Nancy, a "whore with a heart of gold," sacrifices herself so that Oliver can move on to a new life. Women in the novel are primarily seen as nurturers, and that nurturing function enables Oliver to survive. When that nurturing function is perverted — as in the case of prostitution or the scheming Mrs. Mann — Dickens uses this as evidence of the corruption of larger society. Similarly, when male figures like Fagin attempt to take on nurturing roles, this underlines the degree to which what is natural in society has become perverted, gross, and corrupt.
Oliver's Mother and Mrs. Mann: Absent and Perverted Nurturing
Early in the novel, young Oliver is seen as condemned by the unmarried status of his mother, Agnes, who dies in childbirth: "The surgeon leaned over the body, and raised the left hand. 'The old story,' he said, shaking his head: 'no wedding ring, I see. Ah! Good night!'" (Chapter 1). Although it is later discovered that Oliver's mother loved his father, the fact of illegitimate paternity results in the child being consigned to the workhouse for the duration of his early existence. His mother's disgraced, unwed state and her poverty — as well as Oliver's lack of a father — define Oliver for much of the novel.
The lack of a mother results in Oliver being placed in the hands of Mrs. Mann, a woman who, rather than placing children first — as the novel implies she should, given both her duty and her gender — places her own needs first: "The elderly female was a woman of wisdom and experience; she knew what was good for children; and she had a very accurate perception of what was good for herself. So, she appropriated the greater part of the weekly stipend to her own use, and consigned the rising parochial generation to even a shorter allowance than was originally provided for them" (Chapter 2). Adults in general focus upon their own needs for food, money, and luxury and deny the basic necessities to children, but the fact that a woman denies Oliver these things is seen as particularly noxious within the novel's moral framework.
Oliver, however, retains an angelic vision of his mother in his mind's eye, and his willingness to defend her against the taunts of another boy is presented as evidence of his moral superiority. "Of a broken heart, some of our old nurses told me… I think I know what it must be to die of that!" says Oliver, in response to allegations that his mother was "bad" — and virtually the one time in the novel in which Oliver shows any initiative is when he is defending her memory (Chapter 6).
Work Cited
Dickens, Charles. Oliver Twist. Online Literature Library. Web. 7 Dec 2014.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.