This paper examines the life, artistic practice, and major works of South African artist Zwelethu Mthethwa (b. 1960, Durban). Trained at the Michaelis School of Fine Art and the Rochester Institute of Technology, Mthethwa became internationally recognized for large-format color photography and pastel work that dignifies post-apartheid communities in Cape Town. The paper surveys critical responses to his art, analyzes two specific works — "Open Letter to God" (2000) and "Where Angels Fear to Tread IV" (2001) — and situates his practice within a broader conversation about documentary photography, human dignity, and social representation in contemporary South African art.
Zwelethu Mthethwa has said, "I chose color because it provides a greater emotional range. My aim is to show the pride of the people I photograph." Born in 1960 in Durban, KwaZulu-Natal, Mthethwa holds diplomas from the Michaelis School of Fine Art at the University of Cape Town. As a recipient of a Fulbright Scholarship, he studied at the Rochester Institute of Technology and in 1989 received a master's degree in imaging arts. Mthethwa left teaching in 1999 to devote himself full-time to his artwork.
He has received national and international recognition and has had over thirty-five solo exhibitions in galleries and museums in the United States, Italy, Germany, Spain, France, Switzerland, and South Africa. Residing in Cape Town, Mthethwa is best known for his large-format color photography; however, he also works in pastel and paint.
Mthethwa is one of the best-known artists of the middle generation in South Africa. He considers painting and photography to be equally important and is continually transferring ideas from one medium to the other. In his photographs, the people portrayed are as carefully positioned and the forms and hues as strictly composed as elements of an abstract painting, yet his vivid paintings and pastels recall photographs or film stills.
Like many born in the 1960s who grew up with television, Mthethwa's paintings "seem to have been influenced by sequential perception in often having a near, middle and far distance more juxtaposed than merged, as if viewed in series." In recent years, Mthethwa's work has been shown in more exhibitions than those of any other South African artist, having appeared in museums and galleries across the United States, Europe, Africa, and Asia.
Ashraf Jamal writes, "It is the interface between the lived world and 'image-making' that drives Zwelethu Mthethwa." Mthethwa achieves this through photography and pastel drawing, and in both mediums it is the empirical — the re-presentation of an actual event or scene — that is key. "For Mthethwa, 'traditional documentary photography treats people as subjects not as human beings,'" which is why his work never merely records; rather, "each element in a work is imbued with an aura, a quality that transfigures and ennobles the seen."
This philosophy distinguishes Mthethwa from conventional documentary photographers. Where many photographers in the tradition position their subjects as passive objects of social study, Mthethwa insists on the humanity, agency, and dignity of the individuals he depicts — a commitment visible in both his compositional choices and his use of vivid color.
Mthethwa is among nine contemporary artists featured in the Smithsonian National Museum of African Art's Insights exhibition in Washington, D.C. "By displaying ensembles rather than individual works, the exhibition reveals the artistic process and play of experimentation, continuity, and change in each artist's chosen subjects and materials." Artists' insights are presented in quotes that illuminate and personalize the works on display, while the curators' comments provide the cultural and political context for each work.
Together, these perspectives reveal the varied use of "visual metaphor, allegory, myth and even movement to evoke a range of experiences — the joy of masquerade, the resiliency of community, pride of place and the physical and psychic violence of political oppression." The exhibit reflects the collection's particular strength in contemporary South African art.
Mthethwa's subjects speak of human dignity and self-awareness, and they bear witness to a post-apartheid era that, unfortunately, has not changed the desperate circumstances faced by many of Cape Town's residents. Two pieces from Insights that are particularly compelling are Open Letter to God and Where Angels Fear to Tread IV.
Mthethwa's 2000 work Open Letter to God is a 116 × 135 cm digital giclée print on canvas. It is a composite of images in black-and-white and sepia-brown tones. The images themselves and their arrangement are meant to convey the silent voices of the children of South Africa.
In the lower left is a composite of five photographs of a child's ear, zooming larger in each shot, with the final image showing only the ear itself. The child's ear perhaps represents the act of waiting — waiting to hear some positive news about the future, waiting for help, waiting for prayers to be answered. Above this, and occupying the center of the print, is a striped blanket stretched across the canvas. This may represent the blanket of oppression created by poverty and the AIDS epidemic so prevalent in the region, or it might represent the "covering up" of the social ills surrounding those conditions.
In the upper right, Mthethwa has placed the image of an outstretched hand, most likely representing the cry for help that goes unanswered — always an empty hand. Also in the upper right is the image of an individual from the waist down, casting a full shadow on the ground behind him. This might represent the feeling of living in the shadows and the reality of living as less than a whole human being.
"Pastel portrait of figures amid spiritual imagery"
"Critical quotes from Van Dyke, Perl, and Caylor"
You’re 68% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.