Verified Document

Failure To Provide Informed Consent Is Usually Research Paper

¶ … failure to provide informed consent is usually analyzed under negligence principles. Some states view the standard as to what a reasonable patient would want to know, whereas others view the standard as to what a reasonable physician would provide. Which standard is preferable? Why? The difference between the reasonable patient standard vs. The reasonable physician standard reflects the fact that a layperson's conception of risk is different than the perspective of a trained professional. "The Reasonable Patient Standard simply says the doctor has to disclose all information which would influence you, or any other reasonable person, in deciding whether or not to go ahead" (The reasonable patient standard in informed consent, n.d, JDMD).

The difference between a patient's perspective and a physician's perspective can perhaps best be illustrated in the following example. In 2009, "a government medical task force recommended major changes in breast cancer screening guidelines...suggesting that most women should not begin getting routine mammograms until age 50, and then only once every two years" (Breast cancer screening...

Many women were outraged, even though statistically speaking, unless they are in a high-risk category, earlier screening does not result in improved health outcomes and can result in increased anxiety due to false positives. However, quite often patients want to know 'just in case,' for their individual peace of mind, if they may have a potentially cancerous growth. Similarly, patients often demand antibiotics for themselves or their children, even if an infection may be viral, 'just in case' the antibiotic might be helpful. This had led, some feel, to an increase in antibiotic-resistant strains of bacteria.
However, although the 'reasonable patient' standard is extremely problematic, the problem with the 'reasonable physician' standard is that it denies the patient a great deal of autonomy over his or her own body. For example, from a physician's perspective, an antidepressant drug that causes a patient 20 lbs. Of weight gain may not seem like much, in light of the alleviation of the patient's symptoms. From the patient's perspective, this might be unacceptable, and even if the…

Sources used in this document:
References

Breast cancer screening should begin at age 50, panel finds. (2012). PBS. Retrieved:

http://www.pbs.org/newshour/updates/health/july-dec09/breastcancer_11-16.html

Fed & State law on advanced directives. (2012). Washington State. Retrieved:

http://www.wsha.org/EOL-FedState.cfm#footnotes
http://blog.jdmd.com/index.php/the-reasonable-patient-standard-in-informed-consent/
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Confidentiality Breaches & Informed Consent when Testing New Drugs...
Words: 2871 Length: 9 Document Type: Essay

Confidentiality Breaches in Clinical Practice The confidentiality and privacy of patients are considered as one of the fundamental freedoms that they should enjoy and are safeguarded under Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPPA). It is also a precept of the American Medical Association’s Code of Ethics and the Hippocratic Oath. The breach of confidentiality is unethical and illegal. Medical professionals are under the obligation of protecting the patient’s confidentiality.

Business Using Gelso 2006 , Harlow
Words: 16758 Length: 60 Document Type: Term Paper

Researchers have an occasion to further organizational science and to make research practical by producing information that can impact changing organizational forms and circumstances. Pragmatically, academic researchers are not likely to get access to a company that is going through change unless the practitioners believe the research will be helpful (Gibson & Mohrman, 2001). There have been a number of calls to augment the significance and effectiveness of organizational science

Marketing Campaign and Marketing
Words: 4551 Length: 15 Document Type: Research Paper

Community Needs Assessment Recent observations in the tri-county area of rural Iowa have shown a disturbing trend of a constant increase in women and young children in the emergency departments and shelters. These women and young children visits emergency departments and shelters with different healthcare concerns including undetected female cancers, miscarriages, pediatric pediculosis, and symptoms of malnourishment. The county's health executive, Susan, has convened a meeting on behalf of the three

Postoperative Vision Loss Elements of
Words: 8700 Length: 30 Document Type: Research Proposal

More times than not, a patient will argue that he did not understand what the physician stated to him; even amidst documented proof the medical professional and the patient did engage in an informed conversation. "The fact that a meeting took place does not necessarily mean that there was a meeting of the minds" (Informed consent…, 2010, ¶ 5). This issue leads some health care providers to assert that

Healthcare Legal Issues: Care and Treatment of
Words: 4675 Length: 16 Document Type: Research Paper

Healthcare Legal Issues: Care and Treatment of Minors The evolution of the hospital is a unique social phenomenon reflecting societal attitudes toward illness and the welfare of the individual and the group. Hospitals existed in antiquity, in Egypt and in India. After Christianity became the state religion of the Roman Empire, hospitals were built in Christian nations. Subsequently, after Islam arose, hospitals were built in Moslem countries as well. Regardless of

Program Evaluation Home and Community-Based
Words: 7215 Length: 25 Document Type: Essay

C. Evaluation question(s) and aims. The primary question that will be addressed is to identify whether HCBS program is able to provide service to the target population. The evaluation questions will also be directed to the cost effectiveness of the program. The following evaluation questions are identified: 1. Is the program meet the budget requirements of the 1915 (b)? 2. Has the program generates cost saving? 3. Has the program has been able to

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now