Verified Document

Decision House Lords The Decision By The Essay

Decision House Lords The Decision by the House of Lords in the Belmarsh Detainees Case

The decision by the House of Lords in the Belmarsh detainees case (A v Secretary of State Home Office [2004] UKHL 56) illustrates the increased intensity of judicial review under the Human Rights Act. Discuss the judicial reasoning in this case in the light of the above statement.

The ruling of the Belmarsh detainees' case was seen as a major victory for the human rights movement. As, it involved twelve foreign terrorist suspects who were held in prison without trial. The decision was that these individuals who were held unlawfully and should be released from prison (Tomkins, 2005). A short time after this, the government changed their policy of holding foreign suspects without trial in prison to: placing them under house arrest. This is important, because it is showing the overall shifts that have occurred in how the government is dealing with this issue.

As a result, their policy regarding terrorist suspects changed after the events of September 11, 2001. In response, the government was given more authority in cases where the security of the...

Belmarsh is the prison where most of these individuals were held without trial. At the time, many British protestors believed that Belmarsh was the UKs version of Guantanamo Bay and the terror suspects imprisoned there were being treated unjustly and unfairly. The ruling in the decision was seen as being in line with the Human Rights Act of 1998.
From the government's perspective, the Human Rights Act was seen as something that hinders their ability to protect people from terrorism. As former Home Secretary Dr. John Reid stated, "There is a very serious [terrorism] threat, and I am the first to admit that the means we have of fighting it are so inadequate that we are fighting with one arm tied behind our backs." He further adds that politics in cases such as the Belmarsh detainees' situation stem from: the support of partisan issues at the expense of national security (Travis, 2007).

Despite these opinions of the situation (from government officials such as: Reid), the judges voted 8 to 1 that imprisoning the detainees was unlawful. Lord Bingham and others stated that although the detainees could be seen as…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Gearty, C. (2005). Human Rights in an Age of Counter-terrorism: Injurious, Irrelevant, or Indispensable? Current Legal Problems, Oxford University Press, 58, 25-46.

Poole, T. (2005). Harnessing the Power of the Past? Lord Hoffmann and the Belmarsh Detainees Case. Journal of Law and Society, 32.4, 534-561.

Tomkins, A. (2005). Readings of A v Secretary of State for the Home Department. Public Law, 259.

Travis, A. (2007). Reid Warning to Judges over Control Orders. The Guardian (London). Retrieved from http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2007/may/25/uk.topstories3.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Legislative Process in the Upper House of
Words: 4006 Length: 15 Document Type: Essay

Legislative Process in the Upper House of Parliament As Bahrain searches for viable approaches to diversifying its oil-based economy, the relatively small nation, like many of its larger counterparts, is also faced with a number of engineering and logistical challenges in its parliamentary legislative process. To determine how the legislative process is being administered in Bahrain, this paper provides a review of the relevant literature to evaluate the challenges facing

Government Why Did the Framers
Words: 5873 Length: 18 Document Type: Essay

Republicans construed Obama as suggesting government bailouts for new industries, or at the slightest a more lively federal government function in generating or supporting jobs -- concepts abominations to a lot of conservatives. The Obama campaign countered the idea as political spin that does not replicate the president's feeling or meaning, pointing to full circumstances of the quotation as confirmation (Koch, 2011). Discuss the process of how a Bill becomes a

UK Immigration and European Convention
Words: 8560 Length: 27 Document Type: Research Proposal

In the event that the analysis of records of telephone, e-mail and internet use was considered to amount to an interference with respect for private life or correspondence, the Government contended that the interference was justified. First, it pursued the legitimate aim of protecting the rights and freedoms of others by ensuring that the facilities provided by a publicly funded employer were not abused. Secondly, the interference had a

Global Warming Anti-Terrorism Measures in
Words: 1036 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

In face of such measures, citizens start more and more to lose faith not only in the Government but also in its policy implicantors: ministries, police, health system, etc. Paul Wilkinson in "Terrorism vs. Democracy: The Liberal State Response" touches on sensitive issues for the UK society like over-reaction to terrorism, using too much military and less intelligence to prevent terrorism and especially the unpopular measures of surveillance, human

Pinochet Case's Is Not Yet Satisfying to Chilean and Human Rights...
Words: 2174 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

Pinochet's Case is Not Yet Satisfying to Chilean and Human Rights Activists Although hampered by internal constraints and challenges, the nation of Chile stands poised to enter the 21st century as a major player in the world's international community. On the one hand, the sound economic policies that were first implemented by the Pinochet dictatorship resulted in unprecedented growth in 1991- 1997; these policies have also helped secure the country's

Streeter V Western Areas Exploration
Words: 2635 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

The leading case in the issue was the House of Lords decision in Regal (Hastings) VS Gulliver. The court examined the relation between the directors of the company -- the fiducially relationship and the liability of the director, with the court emphasizing on a construction of strict liability. (Lowry; Edmunds, 2003, p. 521) There has been the issue considered in the chancery courts, and in England and other countries where

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now