Verified Document

Proximate Negligance You Decide: The Law Who Case Study

Related Topics:

Proximate Negligance You Decide: The Law

Who is to blame?

Factual Summary

Suzy Marks and her friends Jerry and Kate were ordered to leave Elsewhere City Park at the 11pm curfew time by Officer Ruthless. Suzy told the Officer she wanted to wait for her friend Orson, who was supposed to pick her up at 11pm or said she would walk the short distance home. Officer Ruthless ordered her into Jerry's vehicle and said she should leave immediately. Jerry made several stops on the way home and got into an accident, causing Suzy to be injured

Was Officer Ruthless' action the proximate cause of Suzy's injuries?

Restate or summarize the question. What is the legal question you are going to answer?

Was Officer Ruthless negligent?

Legal...

CBS, "the threshold and, in this case, dispositive question with respect to the assertion of a claim for negligence is whether any duty was owed to the plaintiffs" (8). Officer Ruthless, as a public servant, had a duty to ensure that the park's curfew was upheld but also to protect the safety of the young people. Officer Ruthless should also have anticipated possible injury given Suzy's reticence and the fact that she was sitting in a truck without a seatbelt (although seatbelts are not required in the back of camper trucks by law).
In Herrara et al. v. Quality Pontiac, Quality Pontiac was found to be the proximate cause of a vehicular injury because by instructing customers to leave car keys in the vehicle, they made the cars very likely to be…

Sources used in this document:
References

Herrara et al. v. Quality Pontiac. Find Law. Retrieved:

http://caselaw.findlaw.com/nm-supreme-court/1323261.html

McCollum v. CBS. (1988). Retrieved:

http://eejlaw.com/c/McCollum_v_CBS_E09.pdf
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

How to Prevent Car Accidents
Words: 711 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Practicing Safe Driving: How to Prevent Accidents on America's Roads In 2006 alone, the total number of automobiles registered with the U.S. Bureau of Transit topped 135.3 million (U.S. Census Bureau, 2010). With the amount drivers on the road, one must question the protection a driver gives and receives while driving. Advancements in technology and increasing time constraints are grounds for the escalating concern of distractions. These same time constraints are having

Automobile Risk Avoidance Aptitude Studies of Reaction
Words: 1316 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Automobile Risk Avoidance Aptitude Studies of reaction times have been of interest to a wide variety of people for several centuries. Among one of the industries that stands to benefit the most from a more comprehensive understanding of reaction times is the automobile insurance industry, which charges customers premiums based on the risk that they might get into an accident. There is reason to believe that this propensity is directly

Launching a Car Rental Company at OKC Airport
Words: 2037 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

New Car Rental Property Proposal Despite the proliferation of ride-sharing services such as Lyft and Uber, the rental car industry continues to thrive, with average fleet sizes and revenues experiencing significant increases since 2015 (2016 U.S. car rental market, 2017). One market location that is well positioned for a new non-franchise car rental enterprise is Oklahoma City, Oklahoma (OKC) which hosts a world-class international airport, the Will Rogers World Airport, located

Angelo Epifani Drove His Car Into My
Words: 942 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Angelo Epifani drove his car into my daughter, killing her instantly. The driver left the scene of the accident, likely fearing the repercussions and unable to face the consequences. My daughter was left lying on the street in the middle of the night, alone, to die. Her name was Jiao Shiqi. She was only 20 years old when she died, a delightful, kind, intelligent, and sweet girl. Jiao Shiqi had her

Colgan Air Flight 3407 Accident
Words: 3090 Length: 12 Document Type: Research Proposal

On the hand, some plans may be slow to respond to the pilot's commands; complicating the piloting process, much like a sports car, for example, that under steers or a truck that over steers (Personal Communication, 2010). Bay contends that training on more than one plane of a particular model would prove to be a positive practice for airlines to implement. Bay asserts that the following questions need to be

Medical Ethics at an Accident
Words: 661 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

This was an individual specifically trained in lifesaving techniques for accident and emergency victims, and he should not leave an obviously injured person. His training prepared him for just this situation, and since he was the first person on the scene, he could literally make the difference between life and death. The accident victim with an obvious head injury could be suffering from shock, and the head injury symptoms

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now