She uses a wide variety of resources, from the Constitution itself, (printed in the book, along with the Articles of Confederation and biographies of the delegates), personal records and diaries of the people in attendance at the Convention, and a host of other primary and secondary documents relating to the Convention.
In addition, she has a deep knowledge of the history, language, and appearances of the times, which is how she can successfully transport the reader so they feel as if they are really there as the Constitution is being drafted. Her research and her writing combine to make the book entertaining as well as enlightening. It truly gave a picture of that moment in history, how the fledgling country was struggling to govern itself, the issues the delegates themselves faced, and how they worked together to create a workable, even "brilliant" solution to crisis and lack of organization in the country. The author notes that early in the convention process, "There was consensus on only one thing: A new and more effective central government was essential."
As with any strong and distinct personalities, there were disagreements, hurt feelings, and misunderstandings. However, the delegates managed to create a viable document anyway, which is another testament to their dedication and strong sense of country.
The author organizes the book chronologically, from the time during and after the Revolutionary War until the...
This helps the reader understand the actual course of events, and what led up to the crisis among the states that helped convince people they needed to create a more stable form of government. While the book is detailed, it is not difficult to read or understand, and the author clearly understands the information, and can assimilate so that even someone not so interested in history would find this book appealing and informative. The organization helps the reader follow the events more closely, and come to learn about the delegates, just as they learned about each other while they were working in the muggy Philadelphia heat.
In conclusion, this book looks into a familiar part of American history and makes it more understandable and even more familiar. Most Americans think they understand this part of the country's heritage, but is seems that if they read this book, they might see some of their "understanding" is just romantic misconception.
Reading this book really gives a much better picture of the men who drafted the Constitution, why they did what they did, and what it has really meant for the country ever since.
References
Berkin, Carol. A Brilliant Solution: Inventing the American Constitution. New York: Harcourt,
Berkin, a Brilliant Solution: Inventing the American Constitution. New York, Harcourt, 2003, p. 9.
