El Cid Essay

Download this Essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Essay:

El Cid and Medieval History

Medieval Spain was a constant battlefield where Christians and Moors fought constantly. The Moors had invaded Spain in the early stages of the 7th century and remained in control of the area well into what are now known as the Middle Ages. The Moors had begun their campaign in Europe intent upon conquering the entire continent but had been stopped at the Pyrenees by Charles the Hammer. Nevertheless, the Moors remained in Spain for over 700 years and their influence on Spanish culture remains evident to this very day. These influences include the Spanish language and its architecture.

In the course of over 700 years many legends and tails arise both fictional and real. When these legends and tails begin, at least when they are based upon living characters, they tend to accurately reflect the conditions and events as they occurred. As time progresses, however, the legends and tales begin to lose their historical and factual accuracy.

In the long period of Moorish occupation in Spain there are many stories of resistance and attempts at ridding the area of the Moors but none are greater or more significant than the stories surrounding one Rodrigo Diaz de Vivar, colloquially known as El Cid. El Cid was a Castillian nobleman and military leader who rose to become the chief general in King Alfonso's army and in said capacity led Alfonso's efforts to rid Spain of the Moorish influence. The documentation regarding El Cid's birth, death, and life are well documented but through the passage of time and the publishing of historical accounts legend and historical facts have become understandably mixed. As best as anyone can tell, El Cid apparently found himself fighting on behalf of the Christians while at other times he was known to have fought with the Arabs. How this developed and why is often confusing and because of the historical period during which El Cid lived (1043-1099) the historical facts are not well documented. Much of what is known about El Cid was passed down through word of mouth and its attendant problems or through the use of poems which by their inherent nature often mixed fact with fiction in order to produce an engaging story. One of these poems, entitled as either El Cantar de Myo Cid or El Poema de Myo Cid in Spanish, or in English as The Lay of the Cid or The Poem of the Cid, is the oldest of the preserved Spanish poems and some of the subtle differences in the translation of this poem through the centuries provide an clear idea of how facts can become blurred through the years despite the good intentions of those providing the translations.

The cited poem shows some variations from historical facts. The poem in question does not mention that El Cid had a son while, in fact, he had a son named Diego Rodriquez, who died at the Battle of Consuegra. Another fact cited incorrectly by the poem is the fact that his daughters' names were Christiana and Maria but the poem identifies them as Elvira and Sol.

The problem with these poems is that they were composed prior to the date when such stories were transcribed in writing, that is, they were transmitted through oral means only. As a result, there was a high probability of error. Even as the poems began to be transcribed, the poems were being written in medieval Spanish which differs substantially from the Spanish in use today. Therefore, there remains the possibility for error. Nevertheless, the stories relative to the history of El Cid have proven to be of great historical significance and, surprisingly, have also seemingly free of grandiosity. They portray a historical figure of great complexity whose legend may be deserved and, for many years, it was assumed by many historians that the El Cid legend was historically accurate but modern historians such as Richard Fletcher are beginning to raise questions.

One of the leading authorities on El Cid, Richard Fletcher, who teaches medieval history at the University of York in England, has aggressively taken aim at the accuracy of El Cid's legend in his book, The Quest for El Cid.

Fletcher argues that El Cid never had any particular belief that he was taking part in the so-called re-conquest of Spain from the Moors. Instead, Fletcher argues that El Cid's interest in the Spanish Muslims was more related to his desire to pursue the immense stores of gold possessed by the Muslims and not be any desire to expel them from Spain. Fletcher writes: "In Rodrigo's (El Cid) day there was little if any sense of nationhood, crusade, or reconquest in the Christian kingdom of Spain. Rodrigo….was as ready to fight alongside Muslims against Christians as vice versa. He was his own man and fought for his own profit."

Fletcher does believe that the primary sources relied upon for depicting life during the time of El Cid do a creditable job of depicting the rich cultural and ethnic mix of Muslims, Christians, and Jews, that lived in relative peace on the Spanish peninsula but he is careful to point out that The Poem of El Cid upon which much of the history of the period is based is full of fictional elements. Fletcher, however, felt that the poem, based on what he was able to uncover regarding medieval Spain and the stories surrounding the legendary El Cid was deeply rooted in historical fact.

Fletcher analogized The Poem of El Cid to other legendary epics from other cultures such as The Song of Roland

in France and Beowulf

in English literature. Both epics were revealing about the era about which they were written but, like all such epics, were written to tell a story and not written to document events in history. Over time they have been used as an insight into the period but true historians would never rely upon them as being precise history. These epic poems were developed in an era that predated written records and relied heavily upon the stories being transmitted orally. As a result, many of the details were lost in the process and the more inspiring portions were subsequently omitted. Fletcher would point out that as the stories were transmitted orally the tendency would be for the story tellers to emphasize the portions of the story that glorified the heroes of the story and omit the portions that reflected negatively on the hero. This is human nature and it lends a lack of credibility to the entire story. For this reason, among others, Fletcher relied more heavily on the literary work of Menendez Pidal in doing the research for his book than upon any translation of the Poem of El Cid.

Although the historical details of El Cid may be questionable the poem does provide good insight into the chivalry of the day. Due to the fact that narrators are less likely to embellish information such as human behavior the poem is believed to be a reliable source as to the knightly qualities of the characters described therein. As such, El Cid embodies the qualities of the honorable knight but, as the story develops, he is also described as possessing qualities commonly associated to criminals, or more appropriately, mercenaries.

The Poem of El Cid has been translated numerous times throughout history and there are differences in all the translation. Its value as a historical document is questionable but it remains an important piece of literature. Experts in medieval history still reference the translated versions when analyzing medieval Spain and it provides insights into the time period. Through the passage of time, The Poem of El Cid, has created a legend that became larger than life in Spain. In Spain, the Cid has developed into a…[continue]

Cite This Essay:

"El Cid" (2011, May 10) Retrieved December 10, 2016, from http://www.paperdue.com/essay/el-cid-44484

"El Cid" 10 May 2011. Web.10 December. 2016. <http://www.paperdue.com/essay/el-cid-44484>

"El Cid", 10 May 2011, Accessed.10 December. 2016, http://www.paperdue.com/essay/el-cid-44484

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • El Cid

    El Cid was a courageous and brave knight, who was born in Burgos in circa 1040, and was, during his lifetime, a great and popular hero. He was given the title of 'seid' or 'cid', which meant 'Lord' or 'Chief', by the Moors, and also that of 'Campeador' or 'Champion' by his own admiring countrymen. Unfortunately, tradition and legend have competed with one another through time, to such an extent

  • Infanta in Le Cid the

    Neither to force nor reason will men yield; Only in semblance can the wound be healed" (II.3.27-30). In other words, she seems aware of the fact that, as warriors, both men may owe allegiance to the King, but their own fierce natures are even more critical to them than this allegiance. They will not allow even the King's counsel to end their feud. The Infanta seems to consider her

  • Life in a Medieval Castle

    The Cid is a fair and just man, which is part of the knightly image, and he lives a good and just life. He is pious, and he commands respect, as the growth of his forces during his exile indicates. The image of the knight is also extremely brave, especially in battle, and both books hold up this image. The Cid and his men are extremely brave on the

  • Icelandic Sagas the Saga of Grettir the

    Icelandic Sagas The Saga of Grettir the Strong and Egil's Saga tell us much about the life in Scandinavia at the time and about the culture that produced these works. In this regard, they are similar to other epics and sagas which convey information about the life of the past, from the Homeric epics through Virgil, Beowulf, El Cid, and many others. The plots might emphasize heroic actions and great battles,

  • Peru in Comparison to Uganda Colombia &

    Peru in Comparison to Uganda, Colombia, & India This paper looks at Peru, and discusses three fundamental problems faced by this country. The paper then compares Peru to three other developing countries, Uganda, Colombia and India, in terms of these three fundamental problems. Peru was subjected to over a decade of military rule, which ended in 1980; since then, the country has been ruled by a succession of democratic governments, but

  • Oil and Gas Industry in

    A large body of literature has treated many different aspects of these influences on Asia, Europe and the United States (Busser & Sadoi, 2003). The importance of the study relates to the current trends taking place in Libya where aggressive steps have been taken in recent years to normalize relations with the international community. For example, Libya opened up its programs to develop weapons of mass destruction to international

  • Oceanography the Effects of Climate

    It is difficult to assess to what extent these changes be contributed to global warming, however, due to the relatively short history of observation available to oceanographers. The events put forth in the Pentagon Report are a plausible scenario, although many scientists contest the events as something which is not likely to happen in the near future. There is every possibility though that if climate change continues due to


Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved