Article : Niels Peter Lemche and Thomas L Thompson, Did Biran Kill David? The Bible in the Light of Archaeology Journal for the Study of the Old Testament 64 (1994) pp 3-22.
Lemche and Thompson establish themselves as minimalsts, and offer a harsh critique of the methods used by Israeli archaeologist Avraham Biran upon presenting his findings of the Tel Dan bytdwd inscription. According to Lemche and Thompson, Biran leapt to conclusions about the connection between the inscription and the Bible and distorted its significance in order to promote a fundamentalist reading of the Bible, (5). Moreover, the authors claim that Biran manipulated both the scholarly and the popular media into buying into his assertion that the inscription proved that David was a historical figure and that the Bible was therefore substantiated as historical fact.
The first claim Lemche and Thompson make is that the inscription is far removed both chronologically and geographically from the presumably corresponding Bible stories (5). Second, Lemche and Thompson show how Biran and his supporters base their entire argument on just three letters, (6). Biran also uses circular argumentation, (Lemche and Thompson 7). The authors also critique the archaeological methods used by other scholars who supported Birans conclusions, such as the dating of pottery at the Tel Dan site. Generally, the authors accuse Biran and other maximalists of bad scholarship and pseudo-scholarship, (8). To make their case, Lemche and Thompson outline their position carefully and logically, beginning with the original discovery by Biran at Tel Dan. Then, the authors explain the order in which Biran published different articles in the scholarly and popular press about the conclusions that he spuriously drew. Finally, the authors refer to several other maximalists who had jumped on the Biran theory. Essentially, the archaeological record is not definitive enough in terms of offering absolute dating potential to prove in any way that the inscription does directly refer to King David (Lemche and Thompson 7). The authors also refer to archaeologists and historians who have systematically critiqued the Biran theory, such as the work of Cryer. Summarizing the scholarly critiques of Biran substantiates Lenche and Thompsons claim that Biran jumped to conclusions. However, the authors are clear that they are not discounting the importance of the inscription itself. They are simply saying that Birans conclusions about its implications are inaccurate, sensationalist, and also lack empirical grounding.
While it seems unnecessary for the authors to go so far and accuse Biran of falsifying data (Lemche and Thompson write, one must ask whether the inscription was found in situ at all, 8), the points they make about logical...
…straightforward. In the case of Biblical archaeology, one inscription can be interpreted in a multitude of ways. According to their areas of specialization, whether it be archaeology, linguistics, or history, scholars will gather evidence and then present that evidence to their peers. It is always important to pay attention to both methodology and also to the scholars conclusions and analysis.Biblical scholarship is even more contentious than other areas of academic inquiry because it comes dangerously close to peoples biases and beliefs. People want to confirm their own worldviews, and may be using scholarship as a means to do that at the expense of academic integrity. It is surprising how catty scholars can be when engaging each other in dialogue, but refreshing to know that they do not need to hold back their emotions. It is also surprising to see that the determination to refute the Bible is as vehement as the determination to prove its accuracy.
Works Cited
Kitchen, KA. A Possible Mention of David in the Late Tenth Century BCE, and Deity Dod as Dead as the Dodo? Journal for the Study of the Old Testament 76 (1997) pp 29-44.
Lemche, Niels Peter and Thomas L Thompson, Did Biran Kill David? The Bible in the Light of Archaeology Journal for the Study of the Old Testament 64 (1994) pp…
Scholarship Purpose and Impact of Scholarship Scholarships are one of the greatest ways of helping children who, by a number of reasons, cannot bear the expenses of education mainly that of college studies. Some students might find it difficult to understand how scholarships can be beneficial from them not only in providing the financial assistance but also for many factors. scholarships for students is a sign that they are doing great in
My past has shown my willingness to maximize the opportunities presented to me, and this scholarship will give me an opportunity I would not otherwise be afforded. I have in the past overcome obstacles. In classes which the subject has not come easily to me I have found extra help and spent extra time to do well. In particular, there was a math class in which the concepts seemed like a foreign language. Yet I
For example, she orchestrated means to create eBay brand awareness throughout the world. She has proven human resources skills because she was hired out of house and has remained at the eBay helm since she started there. Whitman understands market forces and knows how to use them to her advantage and to the advantage of her company. She knows what her shareholders need and how to satisfy them and
Currently, I major in human resource management. Within the next eight (8) years, I hope to be through with a doctorate in a human resource management or development related field. This will give me an edge as a professional in human resource management and/or development. In my opinion, a doctorate in this field will also provide me with a special understanding of the various global workforce issues. Career wise,
A naturally devoted individual, my commitment to my academic course of study and to the health care profession will become further evident in graduate school, where I will meet with esteemed professors, mentors, and specialists who can help me perfect my skills and find a niche within the nursing community. While in graduate school, I intend to take advantage of internship or residency opportunities and to participate in volunteer
The knowledge and specialized skills thus acquired can serve to achieve my future goals in this field of study, and help me play an important part in society as a competent individual, involving me in matters of actual and practical interest. I believe that specialized education can thus greatly benefit me in my overall future professional achievements. It will consolidate my knowledge and experience so that these may be applied afterwards
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now