Big Business In America Essay

Length: 4 pages Sources: 5 Subject: Government Type: Essay Paper: #16611991 Related Topics: Romeo And Juliet, Democracy In America, Lobbying, Freedom Of Expression
Excerpt from Essay :

Christina Cui

Ethics in Business

The Nature of Corporation

The evolution of democracy is such that it periodically conditions the environment to "create a system that makes the participation of some citizens count more than the participation of others" (Shriffin as cited in Alzola, 3). Today, a wealthy elite and the deep pockets of corporations have unduly influenced the checks and balances on which the American version of representative government was established. Even though each American citizen is entitled to one vote, citizens of ordinary means and circumstances have essentially been decoupled from true representation. Massive amounts of money are poured into lobbying and electoral activities, hobbling any effort to ensure equality in voice or vote. This paper will first argue that the current political and judicial climate is incompatible with the ideology of the demos or common people. Following, the discussion will provide a counterpoint argument in which the current political and judicial environment provides benefit to the citizenry. The third section of the paper will address the objections posed regarding the moral impermissibility of allowing powerful individuals and corporations to overtake the intent of the law and individual rights. Finally, conclusions will be drawn to definitively demonstrate how ultimately, the government has a strong duty to better regulate big businesses and big corporations so that they better defend the little guy.

Over a period lasting more than 100 years, Congress has variously legislated to limit the influence of corporations on elections, policymaking, and associated socioeconomic outcomes. A minimal goal of this legislation has been to temper hegemony with


However, less than five years ago, the U.S. Supreme Court determined that corporations shall be considered to be entities accorded the same Constitutional rights as individuals. The seeds for judicial interpretation of the Constitution as conveying rights on corporations were sown at least as early as the 1970s, when campaign and lobbying expenditure ceilings were determined to be unconstitutional. In the mature form of democracy now in evidence in the United States, political and financial power are so unequally distributed that government teeters on the brink of plutocracy.

Critical theorists refer to the constructs structural violence and cultural violence, in which a society is set up or functions in such a way that certain groups of people are kept from achieving basic needs or from participating in mainstream society. These conditions are established to ensure and maintain certain privilege, position, and power, and are generally subtle. More overt efforts still consistently occur -- such as the current wave of laws that restrict opportunities to vote, do occur. To bring about change in the status quo, people must first recognize -- through what Paulo Freire referred to as critical consciousness -- that the constraints they experience are often deliberate . The capacity of those with greater wealth, organizational capacity, and resources to curtail the democratic participation of those less well equipped is a form of structural violence. It is a form of modern day bullying where those with more assets and capabilities throw their weight around and stomp their metaphorical "heavy boots" around, making decisions on whim and in ways that only benefit their own selfish desires. Iris Young asserts, "Persons who benefit relatively from structural inequalities have special moral responsibilities to contribute to organized efforts to correct them" (287). While this is true, it very rarely happens. [1: ]

A close examination of the work of Scherer and Palazzo reveals that the politicization of corporations stems from the corporate need -- and responsibility -- to go beyond conventional assumptions about "societal norms and expectations" to actively shape these dynamics in the right way (1108). The argument presupposes inherently moral leadership as an extant condition of…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Alzola M "Corporate dystopia: The ethics of corporate political spending." Business Society February (2013). DOI: 10.1177/0007650312474952

Freire P. Pedagogy of the Oppressed. 30th Anniversary ed. Bloomsbury Academic. 2000.

Gibbins. "Romeo and Juliet." Arden Shakespeare. 2nd ed. (Q2 of 1599; Q1 of 1597). 1980.

Scherer AG and Palazzo G. "Towards a political conception of corporate responsibility: Business and society seen from a Habermasian perspective. Academy of Management Review 32 (2007): 1096-1120.

Cite this Document:

"Big Business In America" (2014, April 18) Retrieved May 23, 2022, from

"Big Business In America" 18 April 2014. Web.23 May. 2022. <>

"Big Business In America", 18 April 2014, Accessed.23 May. 2022,

Related Documents
Big Business George Stigler the
Words: 1218 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 51583737

S. manufactures lost a considerable share of the market to foreign manufacturers. George Stigler developed the economic theory of regulation in the late 1960s, arguing that, instead of regulation being imposed on industries in genuine democratic efforts to protect consumers, big businesses seek out government regulation in an effort to gain monopoly or cartel powers they cannot obtain by market methods (Edwards, 2002). Historically, big businesses have been responsible for creating

Big Business and Industrialization in
Words: 415 Length: 1 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 30686624

This initial influx of labor gave the New Immigrants an opportunity to earn a wage and survive economically in the urban centers of the country. As the majority of these new yet rapidly growing businesses were located in major urban areas, the opportunity they provided New Immigrants of earning a steady paycheck drew them from the more impoverished areas of the world. In conjunction with this development, the exponential

Big Business and Labor in
Words: 963 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Family and Marriage Paper #: 92133129

They protested workplace hazards and the treatment of workers like disposable commodities when laborers became injured, sick, or old. The Knights of Labor and the American Federation of Labor were two of the earliest labor organizations. However, legislation and government actions suppressing the strikers and a failure by the legislature or the legal system to acknowledge the suffering of laborers lead to violent confrontations between workers, managers, and the

Andrew Carnegie and the Rise of Big Business
Words: 1002 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 10803277

Role of Andrew Carnegie Andrew Camegie Andrew Carnegie and the Rise of Big Business Was Andrew Carnegie a "Robber Baron" or a "Captain of Industry"? Andrew Carnegie was a Scottish American born on 25th November 1835. He was an ordinary person but then he succeeded in becoming an entrepreneur, industrialist and a businessman who made a great contribution towards the expansion of American steel industry in the late 19th century. The book, "Andrew Carnegie and

Andrew Carnegie and the Rise of Big Business
Words: 975 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 95394790

Carnegie Andrew Carnegie: Robber Baron or Captain of Industry? Harold Livesay's biography of Andrew Carnegie portrays a man that can be called at once both a Robber Baron and a Captain of Industry. This paper will attempt to show how each title applied to Carnegie in his lifetime and how, in fact, the two titles (far from being dissimilar) may actually be considered synonymous. Andrew Carnegie's humble beginnings do not necessarily qualify him

Collapse of the Big Three America Was
Words: 3475 Length: 13 Pages Topic: Transportation Paper #: 23261159

Collapse of the Big Three America was once the leader and pioneer in the auto industry, a title that the country had for decades and a title that was so dear to America's heart that it was unfathomable to think that title might ever be lost. It's commonly misconstrued that America invented the automobile, when in reality that honor goes to German Karl Benz in 1885 (Rozema, 2010). "Americans did, however,