Business Management -- Human Resource Case Study

Length: 3 pages Sources: 1 Subject: Business - Management Type: Case Study Paper: #13579996 Related Topics: Masters Business Administration, Business Intelligence, Talent Management, Business Case
Excerpt from Case Study :

Analysis of the Apparent Disconnect between Human Resources and Management

In this case, Sue has taken it upon herself that specific human resource practices are the right course for her new organization despite explicit indications from management that those particular practices do not fit the organization's strategic vision, organizational values, or available resources. In her inexperience, Sue has employed a myopic view of the concept of best practices, largely oblivious to the significance of best fit (George & Jones, 2008).

Sue has assumed that all best practices in her previous professional environment necessarily correspond to best practices in her current environment. In fact, the distinguishing features between the two entities whose relevance and significance Sue fails to appreciate make the approach that works in the public sector inappropriate for a private-sector organizations such as that of her current firm. Generally, employment opportunities in the public sector offer different comparative benefits and limitations from those available in the private sector.

For example, even highly skilled public-sector professionals typically earn substantially less than their colleagues with comparable qualifications working in private organizations. However, they generally enjoy shorter and more regular hours, more generous non-monetary perks (such as government tuition assistance). By contrast, private organizations may provide an entirely different corporate culture that includes regular overtime commitments; and they may compensate for sacrifices expected of employees through higher salaries or bonuses. Unlike public-sector employers, private organizations (particularly smaller ones) cannot necessarily afford to invest as...


Creating the expectation on their part without first inquiring into the feasibility of the concept from management's perspective was irresponsible. She should not have assumed that what constituted an element of best practice in one organization necessarily was a best fit for another (George & Jones, 2008).

As to the value of the suggestion itself, it would probably have been a much better fit if it were introduced as a merit-based perk rather than a right automatically enjoyed or expected by all employees of the firm. In that format, Sue's idea could have been used as a performance incentive while providing some of the (undisputed) potential benefits with respect to employee development. But instead of creating an unrealistic expectation in relation to organizational resources, the benefit could have been targeted to those employees who demonstrated the best potential to benefit the organization through their career development. To the extent such a program was achievable given the organization's resources, that might very well have developed into a best practice within that particular organization.


George, J.M. And Jones, G.R. (2008). Understanding and Managing Organizational

Behavior. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.

Gerrig, R.J. And Zimbardo, P.G. (2008). Psychology and Life. New York: Pearson.

Robbins, S.P. And Judge, T.A. (2009). Organizational…

Sources Used in Documents:


George, J.M. And Jones, G.R. (2008). Understanding and Managing Organizational

Behavior. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.

Gerrig, R.J. And Zimbardo, P.G. (2008). Psychology and Life. New York: Pearson.

Robbins, S.P. And Judge, T.A. (2009). Organizational Behavior. Upper Saddle River,

Cite this Document:

"Business Management -- Human Resource" (2010, October 23) Retrieved April 13, 2021, from

"Business Management -- Human Resource" 23 October 2010. Web.13 April. 2021. <>

"Business Management -- Human Resource", 23 October 2010, Accessed.13 April. 2021,

Related Documents
Business Major a Major in Business Management
Words: 1541 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 13965290

Business Major A major in Business Management seems secure, and yet, it could be easily rendered an obsolete concentration. If Business Management were rendered obsolete, it would have adverse implications on the economy, on issues related to social justice, and on the ability for organizations to thrive. Especially during an economic recession, the need to develop future business leaders becomes apparent. Interviews with successful managers who were once students in an

Business Management Business Operations and Systems the
Words: 3206 Length: 11 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 57394706

Business Management Business Operations and Systems The objective of this study is to outline the essential components for effective business operations management for a UK business whose products are delivered to the door. The parcel delivery conundrum will be examined using an appropriate system and methodology and a discussion will be provided to support appropriate business operations models. Included will be CATWOE, Root Definition and a detailed picture to illustrate the

Management and Business Management Theories and Principles
Words: 2108 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 41065652

Management and Business Management Theories and Principles of Each Reading The Fifth Discipline forces managers to look at the way in which learning disabilities which are common to organizations can actually stunt their growth and progress. The author targets several common learning disabilities which can riddle even powerful organizations, they are: identifying with only one position, external enemies, the illusion of taking charge, fixation on events, the parable of the boiled frog,

Business Management Motivation and Communication
Words: 2084 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 87602218

" On the subject of personal development, which company E. should encourage, McGill and Beaty (2001, pp. 85-86) write that in addressing personal development issues, an employer could devise a forum for workers to bring their issues forward. The one rule would be that the issue "is of significance" to the employee; the issues that could be discussed in the personal development session include: "personal motivation towards work"; relationships between managers

Business Management Supply Chain Management Is a
Words: 1538 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 82657722

Business Management Supply chain management is a process conducted by several business entities, which involves planning, implementing and controlling any production and supply activities, with an aim of providing it to consumers in efficient ways. While supplying, there are intermediaries who play a role in connecting producers and consumers, who ensure efficiency in the supply chain too. Supply management is done to ensure collaboration between the intermediaries (Catholic Relief Services, 1999,

Business - Management Theory: Toyota
Words: 2854 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 38336987

Likewise, Lynn points out that, "Japan's recent economic problems may have far more to do with its financial and bureaucratic systems than its managerial systems." According to Everett and Strach, "Japan experienced a decade of zero growth in the 1990s and slumped into recession," but, "The global dynamism and success of Canon, Hoya, Honda, Toyota, TDK, Rohm and Sony, known as the 'seven samurai,' contrasted with the quagmire of