Capital Budgeting In Health Care Case Study

Length: 5 pages Subject: Economics Type: Case Study Paper: #4883293 Related Topics: Budget Cuts, Net Present Value, Fixed Costs, Health Care Economics

Excerpt from Case Study :

Capital Budgeting

There are five strategic projects that are available for Superior Health System. The system lost money last year, but it does have a contingency fund. Whether it is worth dipping into that fund, or other avenues of financing, depends on the strength of these projects. So it is important to analyze the projects.

Partner with a major supplier who will guarantee price, delivery, and product quality

Expand the ENT, Plastic, Gynecology, and Orthopedics surgical programs

Develop a cost-reduction program.

Spend $3,000,000 to expand primary care physician membership in Corinth Health Systems, SHS's PHO

The rational for this order is as follows. Financially, the first two options are positive. Partnering with a major supplier, if it costs nothing up front and delivers that sort of value, should have been done yesterday. Expanding the ENT, gynecology and orthopedics departments has the highest up front cost, and while that might be a barrier for management to overcome, this option is expected to generate substantial revenues in subsequent years, more than enough to pay for the up-front cost, even with two years.

The third option, the cost-reduction program, is another one that should be done. There is an up-front cost, but it is believed that over the course of a few years, the cost reductions will result in savings significantly beyond the up-front investment.

From a capital budgeting perspective, neither the Henry Street School option nor the primary care option should be undertake. There is nothing in the primary care option that points out how this will generate incremental cash flows for Superior, so it is out. Running a day care is an entirely different business, so that should be entered into with caution and only if it projects to be wildly profitable. It does not -- instead it is estimated that it will not be able to generate any contribution margin, thus not cover fixed costs nor pay back on the building purchase. Both of these options, as they reduce the overall value of the organization, should be rejected.

b. The finance committee's evaluation seems reasonable on some points, silly on others. Corporate


So on that point, the finance committee is incorrect. Further, it should have a better sense of what causes a bond rating to drop. It is actually quite unclear from this analysis that the bond rating would drop, though such a rating might be at least somewhat dependent on the ability of the organization break even while meeting its obligations. It is understandable, however, that the finance committee would be leery of putting their credit rating at risk.

The losses from last year are definitely something that should concern the finance committee, and they are right that such losses are not sustainable. The budget should reflect that the organization wants to set a course that is financially sustainable, unless it has good reason to do otherwise. A good investment is a reasonable reason to run a budget deficit; ongoing operations are not. It will hurt the organization in the long run to set out an irresponsible budget at this point. That said, the $6 million figure is entirely arbitrary, and should be taken with a grain of salt by the finance committee, especially knowing that in capital budgeting, a project with a positive NPV should be undertaken. Arguably the most expensive proposed project, the expansion, has a much higher NPV that leaving the money in the rainy day fund where it is lucky if it actually earns a real return at all.

c. I vote to fund partnering with a major supplier as there is no stated cost. This should have been done yesterday. I support the expansion, which carries with it a $7 million price tag. Among projects, this has the highest NPV, and because we are increasing capacity, that positive cash flow is sustainable over the long run. If the market analysis shows that the revenue projections are reasonable, we should utilize some of the rainy day fund in order to facilitate this sort of organizational growth. The cost reduction program I will also support. Though there is an upfront cost, this project again has a positive net present value. Because of that, and the…

Cite this Document:

"Capital Budgeting In Health Care" (2015, March 15) Retrieved March 26, 2023, from

"Capital Budgeting In Health Care" 15 March 2015. Web.26 March. 2023. <>

"Capital Budgeting In Health Care", 15 March 2015, Accessed.26 March. 2023,

Related Documents
Capital Budgeting the Aim of Hospitals Is
Words: 3028 Length: 11 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 63314935

Capital Budgeting The aim of hospitals is to measure and improve the quality of health care service for the patients. Patient satisfaction is the foremost concern. However, to run a hospital, there are a lot of other factors are also involved; e.g. managing cost, budgeting, optimizing operations and increase patient satisfaction level. In order to achieve the desired level of performance, the hospital needs to be up-to-date with the latest technology. In

Budgeting and Cost Control in Healthcare
Words: 3341 Length: 13 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 45091812

Budgeting and Cost Control in Healthcare One of the most critical issues facing healthcare facilities and organizations is the rapidly increasing cost of providing services. Cost control and budgetary issues are the first consideration for many healthcare facilities. According to statistics, the "single most important thing on the minds of healthcare decision makers is cost management and containment." (Lawson, 2004). In fact, more than 95% of respondents to a survey concluded

Healthcare Financial Management in Practice,
Words: 2456 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 32972252

Some hospitals create a "contingency" budget, which can be offset by a few of these patients. The percentage of non-paying patients can vary a good deal, particularly in a city- or county-owned hospital. This number may not vary, and typically in a budget the hospital CEO and/or CFO negotiates with the governmental bodies for regular subsidies to cover. The billing cycles can be difficult to predict, particularly for Medicare and Medicaid

Healthcare Financial Statements
Words: 1396 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Accounting Paper #: 86456802

Healthcare Financial Statements emphasizes on how accountants belonging to a healthcare organization make use of the accounts rule to evaluate their organization's financial statements. This paper also outlines the troubles a company could be into if its manager has no knowledge of interpreting the financial statements. This paper also highlights the steps taken by managers who have no background of finance. Healthcare Financial Statements All organizations whether they are linked to

Budget Problem Health Care Is
Words: 1819 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 92902059

S. debt. Conclusion Health care is a large part of the federal budget and it is increasing in importance. The rate of growth in health care outlays is greater than the rate of growth in the budget itself. The poses a problem, because the federal budget deficit is increasing in size. Debt service is going to be the most rapidly growing component of the federal budget over the next several years, highlighting

Health Care Finance Financial Analyst Eric Feigenbaum
Words: 1202 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 38662815

Health Care Finance Financial analyst Eric Feigenbaum (2009) notes that while we like to think of hospitals in terms of compassion, patient care and dedication to altruistic aims, they are businesses concerned with revenues and expenses like any other business (Feigenbaum 2009, p.2). In today's hectic world of economic downturn and financial struggles felt from individuals of every demographic and social status, revenue and expense accounting are issues that must be